The has ruled that an (ARC) can be substituted as a in a under . This significant judicial clarification establishes that an entity acquiring a bank’s financial assets through a under , may step into the shoes of the original lender to pursue for . The bench, comprised of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu, underscored that while the law facilitates the continuation of legal proceedings by assignees, this does not grant them an automatic right without .
The dispute originated from a complaint filed by against Kishore Avarsekar and others regarding the dishonour of three post-dated cheques. , having acquired the bank's financial assets through a formal assignment agreement, sought to replace the bank as the in the ongoing criminal trial. The petitioners challenged this substitution, arguing that the of the SARFAESI Act did not extend to and that an ARC could not assume the status of a "payee" or a "" under the Negotiable Instruments Act.
Behind Financial Asset Acquisition
The Supreme Court examined the breadth of Section 5 of the SARFAESI Act, specifically sub-sections (4) and (5), which regulate the continuity of proceedings when financial assets are transferred. The court rejected the argument that the term
"other proceeding of whatever nature"
should be interpreted through the principle of
to include only civil or recovery-related matters. Justice Datta, writing for the bench, clarified that the legislature intended a far wider scope to prevent the loss of pending litigation due to the change in ownership of financial assets.
"The words '
' are not qualified as ‘civil’ or ‘recovery’ proceedings; on the contrary, the expression 'other proceeding of whatever nature' is deliberately unqualified,"
the court noted. This interpretation ensures that the
remains robust, allowing the assignee to inherit both the assets and the accompanying
. By permitting substitution, the Court aims to ensure that no proceeding relating to a financial asset is abandoned or rendered void simply because the original lender, which initiated the action, has divested its interest. This, the bench reasoned, aligns with the broader objective of the SARFAESI Act to facilitate efficient
and ensure that recovery processes are not obstructed by technical shifts in the status of the creditor.
Strict Proof Standards for Legal Continuity
Despite upholding the legality of the substitution, the Supreme Court introduced a critical safeguard to prevent the misuse of this power. An ARC cannot rely solely on the assignment deed to automatically claim the right to prosecute a dishonoured cheque case. It must demonstrate that it has legitimately acquired not just the debt, but the physical instruments and the corresponding legal rights associated with the specific financial asset in question.
The court laid out a four-pronged evidentiary requirement for ARCs seeking to continue Section 138 prosecutions. The assignee must prove that the dishonoured cheque was delivered to it along with the underlying financial asset, that there has been an endorsement or assignment sufficient to make the ARC a "" under , that the essential ingredients of the Section 138 offence are satisfied, and that the substitution is not an attempt to deviate from or unfairly improve upon the case initially established by the original .
"While a pending complaint under Section 138, N.I. Act does not
on assignment to an ARC of the financial asset/debt under
, such assignment does not, per se, make the ARC the payee or the
,"
the judgment clarifies. This caveat acts as a necessary check, ensuring that the transition of parties does not prejudice the accused's right to a
or allow for the introduction of evidence that the original bank had not properly preserved.
Procedural History of the Dispute
The legal battle over this substitution has been extensive. The presiding over the initial complaint allowed the application for substitution in . The accused subsequently sought relief through a in the , which was dismissed in . Following this, the petitioners approached the , invoking its under and . The High Court's dismissal of their in led to the final appeal before the Supreme Court.
Throughout these proceedings, the petitioners contended that the reliance on earlier high court precedents regarding the and the was misplaced, as the statutory frameworks of those laws operate in entirely different spheres than the SARFAESI Act. The Supreme Court agreed with this assessment, noting that the legislative objectives of the SARFAESI Act are distinct and require an interpretation focused on the seamless transfer of rights, titles, and interests from financial institutions to ARCs.
With the dismissal of the , the Supreme Court has cleared the path for the trial to proceed with the ARC as the . However, the ruling remains balanced by the caveat that the accused retain the right to challenge the merits of the ARC's status as a during the upcoming trial. The trial magistrate is now empowered to proceed, provided the assigned entity meets the strict evidentiary standards established in this order. This decision effectively ends the uncertainty regarding the of asset reconstruction firms in pending cheque bounce cases, provided they can satisfy the stringent requirements of the Negotiable Instruments Act at the trial stage.
financial asset - holder in due course