The Supreme Court of India has directed Shiv Sena (UBT) Rajya Sabha Member of Parliament Sanjay Raut and senior journalist Nikhil Wagle to file additional affidavits regarding their recent social media conduct, which serves as the basis for ongoing criminal contempt proceedings . During a hearing held on Tuesday, a two-judge bench comprised of Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi underscored that while legal apologies have been tendered, their sincerity must be absolute, particularly given the standing of the individuals involved. The Court set the next date of hearing for December 8, 2026 , ordering both respondents to appear in person to facilitate a comprehensive final order on the matter.

The contempt petition was initiated by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) following consent from the Attorney General for India, R. Venkataramani , under the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 . The proceedings were triggered by a series of social media posts allegedly targeting Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and the broader functioning of the judiciary. During the latest session, the judicial bench emphasized that public figures and those in the media hold a special obligation to maintain decorum when criticizing the legal institution.

Addressing Sanjay Raut directly, Justice Kumar stressed that as a veteran parliamentarian with decades of experience in the public eye, his choice of language should reflect a deep-seated respect for the rule of law . “Mr. Sanjay Raut, you are a seasoned politician. We have been hearing your political debates since our advocate days. You are a seasoned parliamentarian, and you yourself were in the press. You should know what restraint in language means,” Justice Kumar observed. The bench further admonished that in matters of such significant institutional magnitude, any expression of regret must originate from the heart, rather than being a mere tactical maneuver or a reflection of the mind.

The Albania Controversy and SCBA Objections

The hearing delved into specific allegations brought forward by the Supreme Court Bar Association, represented by its President, Senior Advocate Pradeep Rai . The SCBA argued that while Raut had submitted an affidavit of apology on October 26, 2026 , his conduct remained problematic. Specifically, the Association pointed to a social media post shared by Raut on October 19 , which depicted images of the Supreme Court of Albania being set on fire by protesters. The petitioner contended that this served as an oblique, inflammatory message directed at the Indian judiciary.

Senior Advocate Pradeep Rai argued that these actions, taken even after the contempt proceedings were formally initiated, displayed a pattern of behavior that warranted an “iron hand” response from the Court. The SCBA submitted that the politician’s original apology failed to address these subsequent posts, thereby undermining the sincerity of his remorse. Responding to the bench’s inquiry, counsel for Raut acknowledged that the comments were indefensible, maintained the unconditional nature of the apology already tendered, and signaled a willingness to file a detailed additional affidavit to address the Court’s specific concerns regarding his social media timeline.

Journalistic Responsibility and the Fourth Estate

Parallel to the proceedings against the MP, the bench addressed the case of journalist Nikhil Wagle, who joined the hearing via video conference. Senior Advocate Indira Jaising , representing Wagle, argued that the journalist had immediately removed the disputed social media post upon receiving notice of the contempt action. She emphasized that Wagle, a professional with over fifty years of experience, had never previously been the subject of contempt proceedings and that his actions were an impulsive lapse rather than a calculated assault on the judiciary.

Jaising underscored Wagle’s history as a litigant who frequently utilizes the Court to protect fundamental rights , arguing that he holds the institution in high regard and possesses no personal vendetta against it. However, the bench maintained that even an award-winning professional does not hold a license to use unparliamentary language when discussing judicial functions. Justice Kumar shared a personal reflection on the profession, noting that his own father had identified as a journalist for his entire life, viewing the press as the essential "fourth estate" of democracy. The judge cautioned, however, that this elevated position carries an inherent responsibility. "It gives a very bad taste in our mouth to even repeat it," Justice Kumar stated regarding the nature of the remarks, emphasizing that professional achievements cannot excuse a departure from civil discourse.

Procedural Path to Resolution

The Court’s instruction for both respondents to file additional affidavits is a critical step in the procedural progression of the case. By requiring this documentation, the bench intends to clear the record regarding all flagged social media activity before reaching a final verdict. The Court has not yet made a substantive finding on whether criminal contempt is established, maintaining a neutral stance while allowing both parties full opportunity to explain their positions in writing.

The controversy originated following a request by an opposition delegation, led by Leader of the Opposition Rahul Gandhi, to meet with the Chief Justice of India regarding election-related concerns. Upon the Chief Justice’s refusal to meet them in an in-person capacity—directing the delegation instead to approach the Court through formal legal petitions—the respondents allegedly posted disparaging remarks on social media. These posts, according to the SCBA, crossed the threshold from fair criticism to contemptuous behavior.

As the matter moves toward the December 8 hearing, the focus remains on the sincerity of the apologies and the respondents' ability to account for their continued social media activity during the pendency of the case. The bench has indicated that its goal is to provide a comprehensive, final resolution that balances the protection of judicial dignity with the respondents' right to express views. Whether the additional affidavits will mitigate the severity of the proceedings or further illustrate a pattern of non-compliance remains the central issue for the upcoming session. Both Raut and Wagle remain under the Court’s mandate to present themselves for the next hearing, where the bench will evaluate the material on record to determine the final outcome of the petition.