The High Court of Judicature at Bombay has directed Bank of Baroda to ensure the preservation of documents and electronic records pertinent to a USD 15 billion civil suit filed by NMC Healthcare founder Dr. Bavaguthu Raghuram Shetty. While the court declined to issue an immediate order for the mandatory disclosure of these records, it recorded the bank’s formal assurance that all materials in its custody or control will be maintained in their current state, ensuring they remain protected from destruction, interpolation, or alteration until the next date of hearing.

The ongoing legal battle arises from a suit filed by Dr. Shetty against the Bank of Baroda and 25 other defendants, including key former executives of the NMC group. In his petition, Dr. Shetty claims that the bank acted as a primary conduit for fraudulent activities that allegedly drained the finances of his companies. He asserts that through acts of omission and commission, bank officials facilitated the diversion of funds, ignored anti-money laundering alerts, and processed unauthorized transactions that resulted in severe financial and reputational loss. The lawsuit seeks USD 15 billion in damages, alleging that the bank's involvement in the collapse of his business interests went beyond standard banking services, involving the creation of sham accounts and the unauthorized use of his forged signatures.

Ensuring Integrity of Evidence

During the proceedings held on November 19, 2026, Senior Advocate Zal Andhyarujina, appearing for the Plaintiff, pressed for an immediate disclosure of documents, which he argued would establish the extent of the fraud and the precise roles played by the bank's employees. He contended that such disclosure was vital to the integrity of the claim and that the documents were essential to substantiate allegations of systemic negligence and collusion.

In response, the court focused on ensuring that the evidentiary trail remained intact. Justice Arif S. Doctor accepted the statement provided by the bank’s legal team regarding the status of the requested files. As noted in the court order, "He, however, assures the Court that all such documents forming part of the Schedule to the Interim Application and in the custody or control of Defendant No. 1 shall be preserved as they are. His statement is accepted."

This preservation order acts as a crucial procedural safeguard, effectively freezing the current status of the evidence while the court deliberates on the scope of the discovery phase. By accepting this undertaking, the court avoided the need for an immediate contentious ruling on the disclosure, deferring the issue until both parties have formally submitted their arguments in writing.

The Conflict Over Jurisdictional Scope

The defense, led by Senior Advocate Dr. Birendra Saraf, strongly opposed the application for disclosure, emphasizing that the underlying cause of action dated back to 2020. The bank’s counsel also invoked the recent ruling by the Abu Dhabi Global Market (ADGM) Court of First Instance, delivered on November 5, 2026. The bank argued that the ADGM judgment established Dr. Shetty’s complicity in the very fraud he now claims was perpetrated against him.

Furthermore, the bank asserted that the current proceedings in India are barred by Rule 89 of the ADGM Court Procedure Rules, 2016, which imposes restrictions on the use of documents disclosed in foreign litigation. Counsel for the Plaintiff categorically disputed this, maintaining that the ADGM rules have no jurisdiction over the present case in the Bombay High Court and that the causes of action remain distinct.

Justice Doctor acknowledged these conflicting positions, noting that the applicability of the ADGM rules and the merits of the bank's objections would be evaluated once a comprehensive reply-affidavit has been filed. The court has granted the bank a period of three weeks to file its formal response, with a further five days provided for the Plaintiff to file a rejoinder.

Next Steps in the Litigation

The court has scheduled the matter for further hearing on December 17, 2026, specifically to address the applications for ad-interim relief. The delay provides the bank time to consolidate its defense and, as its counsel informed the court, the bank has already moved for a deferment of the hearing, citing the complexities of the voluminous records involved.

For Dr. Shetty, the preservation of these documents is a preliminary victory in a high-stakes litigation that spans multiple international jurisdictions. The suit represents one of the largest damage claims ever brought before the Bombay High Court, involving allegations of wide-scale financial malpractice. While the court has currently declined to order the immediate production of the documents for inspection, the recorded assurance from the bank effectively secures the records, preventing any potential loss of information as the parties prepare for the December hearing.

The court has also mandated that an affidavit of service be filed to confirm that all 25 defendants—who were served but remained unrepresented during this specific session—are properly engaged in the process moving forward. As the case proceeds to December, the focal point will shift from document security to the broader legal question of whether the Indian court will allow a full discovery of records, given the existing judgments rendered by the ADGM court in the United Arab Emirates.