The High Court at Calcutta has upheld the removal of a former Customer Assistant at the State Bank of India, ruling that the subsequent refund of misappropriated or erroneously debited funds to customers does not absolve a bank employee of professional misconduct. In a judgment delivered by Justice Partha Sarathi Chatterjee, the Court dismissed the writ petition filed by the former employee, Prasanta Biswas, who had challenged the enquiry report and the penalty of removal from service imposed by the Disciplinary Authority and affirmed by the Appellate Authority.

The petitioner had served at the Bally Durgapur Branch of the State Bank of India until 2013, when he was accused of a series of irregularities involving the handling of customer accounts. The disciplinary proceedings, which spanned over two years, investigated six distinct articles of charge, ranging from unauthorised double debits and disbursement of funds without verifying specimen signatures to the direct transfer of funds between accounts without obtaining valid debit confirmations or authority letters from the account holders.

Repeated Irregularities in Customer Accounts

The court noted that the allegations against the petitioner were not isolated or minor instances of clerical oversight, but rather represented a pattern of behavior that compromised the integrity of the banking system. One of the central charges involved an incident on September 2, 2013, where the petitioner inadvertently debited a customer's account twice for a single withdrawal. While the petitioner argued that he had brought the discrepancy to the attention of the Branch Manager and eventually rectified the error by crediting the customer's account, the Court found the systemic failure to follow established procedures far more critical than the eventual financial reconciliation.

Further examination of the charges revealed that on several occasions, including transactions dated September 14, 2013, and April 23, 2013, the petitioner processed significant fund transfers without the necessary authorizations from account holders. In one instance, a sum of Rs. 60,000 was moved from a customer's account into accounts held by the petitioner’s father and himself. Although the petitioner contended that he acted under the telephonic instruction of his brother and that authority letters were provided subsequently, the Court emphasized that internal banking safeguards are designed to prevent such unauthorized handling of funds, irrespective of the stated intent or later validation.

Justice Chatterjee underscored that, “A subsequent refund or regularisation of an irregular transaction may make good the financial loss, but it does not, by itself, erase the misconduct already committed.” The ruling highlighted that the fundamental duty of a bank employee is to ensure that every transaction adheres to the mandated security protocols, as these measures protect the institution’s reputation and the depositors’ trust.

Procedural Integrity and Judicial Review

The petitioner sought to challenge the disciplinary action on various procedural grounds, including the claim that the charge-sheet was vaguely drafted and that the reference to Clause 7(c) of the Memorandum of Settlement (MoS), which pertains to minor misconduct, precluded the Bank from imposing a major penalty. The Bank, however, maintained that the reference to the specific clause was an inadvertent error and that the entire disciplinary process had been conducted under the framework for major misconduct, with the petitioner being fully apprised of the gravity of the allegations.

The Court held that a mere technical discrepancy in the citation of a legal provision does not invalidate the entire disciplinary proceeding, provided that the substance of the charges was clear and the delinquent employee was not deprived of a fair opportunity to defend his position. “What is material is the substance of the allegations, the nature of the misconduct attributed to the petitioner and whether he was made sufficiently aware of the charges he was required to meet,” the Court observed.

In this case, the petitioner had been provided with the list of documents and witness statements, and had been granted inspection of the relevant records. The Court found that he failed to demonstrate how the alleged procedural irregularities resulted in any actual prejudice to his defense. Furthermore, the Court rejected the contention that the change in the presiding Disciplinary Authority during the course of the proceedings had caused a failure of justice, noting that the successor authority had access to the complete evidentiary record and that no specific prejudice was established by the petitioner.

Addressing the Claim of Proportionality

The petitioner’s final challenge rested on the argument that the penalty of removal from service was disproportionate, given that the Bank suffered no ultimate financial loss and that some customers had signed letters absolving the staff of any wrongdoing. The Court, however, dismissed this reasoning as legally and factually insufficient. By framing the petitioner’s actions within the context of the high standard of care expected from banking personnel, the Court ruled that the cumulative impact of his conduct—involving repeated instances of unauthorized account handling—justified the disciplinary measure imposed.

The Court concluded that the penalty was not shockingly disproportionate because the trust inherent in the employer-employee relationship within the financial sector had been fundamentally breached. The judgment reiterated that the role of the writ court is not to sit in appeal over the disciplinary findings, but to ensure that the process was fair and that the final decision was supported by evidence. Finding no perversity in the Enquiry Officer's findings or the Disciplinary Authority’s final orders, the Court affirmed the removal, leaving the original penalty of dismissal intact. The decision serves as a significant precedent regarding the strict accountability required of banking staff in ensuring procedural compliance.