The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT) Chandigarh Regional Bench has delivered a significant ruling allowing Maruti Suzuki India Limited to claim CENVAT credit totaling ₹1,19,81,989. The dispute arose from service tax paid on compensation charges that the automotive manufacturer incurred due to shortfalls in the off-take of natural gas, a critical input for its vehicle manufacturing operations in Gurugram. In a decision that clarifies the scope of “input service” under the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004, the tribunal bench comprising Member (Judicial) P. Dinesha and Member (Technical) P. Anjani Kumar rejected the Revenue’s argument that such payments were ineligible for tax credit.

The case originated from a contractual arrangement between the appellant, Maruti Suzuki, and the Gas Authority of India Limited (GAIL). Under the terms of the agreement, Maruti Suzuki was obligated to procure a minimum quantity of natural gas monthly. Failure to meet this requirement triggered a penalty clause, resulting in the company paying ₹8,55,85,634 in compensation for a shortfall spanning four to five years. GAIL, treating this compensation as a consideration for the “declared service” of tolerating the non-fulfilment of the purchase commitment, duly discharged the applicable service tax. Upon paying the tax, Maruti Suzuki availed the corresponding CENVAT credit. The Revenue authorities challenged this, arguing that the service provided—the toleration of a shortfall—did not qualify as an “input service” used in or in relation to the manufacture of finished goods.

The tribunal’s decision hinged on an interpretation of the “inclusive” part of Rule 2(l) of the CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004. This provision encompasses services used in relation to the procurement of inputs. The tribunal reasoned that the penal amount paid by the appellant to GAIL was intrinsically linked to the procurement of natural gas. Without the procurement contract, the payment of compensation—and the accompanying service tax—would never have occurred. By establishing this direct nexus between the input (gas) and the payment, the tribunal concluded that the activity qualified as an input service.

“The penal amount paid by the appellants to GAIL is undoubtedly in relation to the procurement of goods. If the appellants did not procure natural gas from GAIL, there would have been no occasion to pay the penal amount and the applicable service tax for the same,” the tribunal observed in its final order.

The Revenue had further contended that no service was actually received by the manufacturer. However, the bench highlighted an inconsistency in the department's position. The Revenue had not challenged the payment of service tax by GAIL, nor had it questioned the underlying transaction from the service provider's end. The court emphasized that the Revenue could not simultaneously accept that service tax was legitimately due and paid on a declared service while denying that the recipient was entitled to the corresponding credit. By validating the transaction as a service on which tax was paid, the Revenue effectively acknowledged the service's existence.

Counsel for the appellant, Krati Singh, provided a robust defense, supported by legal precedents and government circulars. She argued that the denial of credit at the recipient’s end is unsustainable when the tax payment at the provider’s end remains undisputed. The appellant highlighted that this specific arrangement had been communicated to the department regarding their Manesar unit previously, where no such credit denial proceedings were initiated. The tribunal found merit in the reliance placed on judicial precedents, particularly the case of M/s Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd, where it was established that if the department chooses to tax a transaction at the provider's end, it cannot deny credit at the recipient's end without disturbing the original tax assessment.

“The Revenue having accepted that GAIL has rendered the service to the appellants cannot say that the appellants have not received any service,” the tribunal noted, underscoring the necessity for consistency in tax enforcement. This observation serves as a major takeaway for corporate taxpayers, reinforcing the principle that the department cannot adopt contradictory stances on the same transaction to maximize tax collection while simultaneously restricting credit availability.

The tribunal’s findings also addressed the broader implications of the “inclusive” definition of input services. By confirming that expenses incurred in the context of input procurement—even those arising from contractual penalties—are eligible for credit, the bench has provided much-needed clarity for manufacturers operating under complex long-term supply agreements. The ruling suggests that as long as an expenditure is directly attributable to the process of procuring manufacturing inputs, it falls within the protective ambit of the CENVAT credit framework.

The appellant's reliance on various judgments of the Supreme Court and other benches of the CESTAT further fortified the argument that the Revenue’s approach was procedurally inconsistent. By adhering to the logic that the service provider’s assessment cannot be ignored when evaluating the recipient’s credit entitlement, the Chandigarh bench has reinforced a stable tax environment for industrial players.

Consequently, the tribunal set aside the order-in-appeal dated September 27, 2019, and the original demand confirmed by the Joint Commissioner of CGST. The appeal was allowed, with the tribunal granting consequential relief to the appellant in accordance with the law. This resolution marks the end of a long-standing dispute that began with a show-cause notice in December 2016, providing finality to Maruti Suzuki’s claim and setting a precedent for other manufacturers navigating similar supply chain penalty disputes under the indirect tax regime.