The on Wednesday issued a formal notice to the and the Secretary General of the Supreme Court regarding a filed by the non-governmental organization . The petition seeks urgent judicial intervention to finalize the governing the appointment of judges to the , a task that has remained in a state of suspended animation for approximately 11 years.
A bench comprising Justice MM Sundresh and Justice PB Varale presided over the matter on . During the hearing, the court granted the petitioner permission to file an amended version of the plea, signaling a procedural shift as the case moves forward to address the long-standing . The Union of India, represented by the , and the office of the Chief Justice of India have been tasked with submitting their formal responses to the court’s notice.
The current legal challenge serves as a stark reminder of the lingering friction between the executive and the judiciary since the invalidation of the . Following that landmark decision, the apex court had directed that the existing MoP, which traces its roots to , should be supplemented and finalized by the government in close consultation with the Chief Justice of India. The objective was to create a framework that improved eligibility criteria, institutionalized transparency, and established a mechanism for addressing complaints against prospective candidates. Despite these clear directives, the document remains unfinalized, leading to what the petitioner characterizes as an "inexplicable" failure of the .
The petition, filed through SN Shukla, the general secretary of the organization, details a decade of stalled communications between the government and the judiciary. The documentation provided to the court highlights a series of drafts exchanged, objections raised regarding "national security" clauses, and disagreements over the formation of screening-cum-evaluation committees. According to the filing, the government at one point proposed that such committees, involving representatives from the executive, should assist the in identifying candidates, a suggestion that the judiciary did not accept.
Transparency Demands for Minutes
Beyond the finalization of the MoP, the petition significantly raises the question of administrative accountability by seeking to bring the deliberations of the under the purview of the . The petitioner argues that the current, opaque system of judicial selection breeds subjectivity and erodes public trust. By calling for the minutes of high-level judicial selection meetings to be accessible to the public, the NGO intends to press for a paradigm shift in how constitutional court judges are elevated.
The plea highlights the persistent decline of transparency, noting that when applicants sought information under the Right to Information Act, they were frequently met with refusals, with authorities citing the "secret" nature of the proceedings or claiming that the documents remained under active consideration by multiple constitutional authorities. The petitioner argues that this lack of clarity is not merely an administrative hurdle but a fundamental issue that impacts the quality of justice dispensed by the constitutional courts.
Procedural Hurdles and
The path to the current hearing has not been without its own complications. The matter was initially listed before a bench that included Justice PS Narasimha; however, the judge recused himself from the proceedings on . The record of proceedings indicated that the recusal was prompted by the judge's prior involvement in matters related to the during his tenure as an .
During the most recent proceedings, Justice MM Sundresh candidly remarked on the complexity of hearing a matter that directly touches upon the working of the institution to which the judges themselves belong. He queried,
"Should we take this matter? Because I am also part of
."
In response, Senior Advocate
, appearing for the petitioner, noted that such objections would invariably arise regardless of the bench composition, as any challenge to the
system necessarily involves those who are current or future members of it. The bench ultimately chose to proceed with the issuance of notice, prioritizing the need for an answer from the government over internal reservations regarding the Bench’s composition.
Implications for Future Appointments
The order from the of the Supreme Court stipulated that the Chief Justice of India would act based on the unanimous view of the four senior-most judges of the Court. However, the petitioner contends that the absence of a finalized MoP has left the system operating on informal, fluid arrangements that lack the rigor and stability required for the selection of judges to the Supreme Court and the various High Courts. The petition warns that the existing MoP, which has not been updated since the , fails to address the modern challenges of .
The case represents a significant point of tension between the desire for institutional independence and the growing public call for transparency. By issuing notice, the Court has brought both the and the internal administrative wing of the Supreme Court to the same table. The immediate consequence of this development is that the government must now articulate its position on why the MoP has remained in flux for over a decade.
As the matter proceeds, the petitioner is expected to file an amended plea that further clarifies the specific reliefs requested, including the exact nature of the transparency protocols to be applied to minutes. The Court’s decision to request a formal response ensures that the decade-long administrative silence is broken, compelling a reconciliation between the government’s desire for procedural oversight and the judiciary’s mandate to maintain its autonomy in selecting its members. The next hearing, scheduled after the government submits its reply, will be closely watched for insights into whether the Court is prepared to set a definitive timeline for these long-awaited reforms.
Collegium transparency - judicial reform - memorandum of procedure - judicial appointments - RTI Act