The High Court of Chhattisgarh has ruled that landowners cannot seek the restoration of property acquired for public infrastructure projects under the colonial-era Land Acquisition Act, 1894, even if portions of that land remain unutilised by the state. The decision, delivered by Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad, effectively bars claims for the return of acquired land based solely on allegations of non-use, confirming that such property vests absolutely in the government upon the completion of acquisition proceedings.

The petitions were brought forward by Bajrang Lal and other landowners from Village Brahmanpali, Tehsil Kharsia, in the Raigarh district. They sought to challenge a September 2021 order from the District Collector, which had denied their request to recover parcels of land initially acquired for the Minimata Bango Canal Project. The petitioners had argued that since the canal construction was completed over a decade ago, the specific segments of their land that were not physically occupied by the water-bearing structure should be considered surplus and returned to their original owners. Relying on reports from local revenue officials and the newer Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, the plaintiffs contended that the state held no further legal basis to retain the land.

Operational Requirements for Irrigation Infrastructure

During the proceedings, the High Court directed the Water Resources Department and the Collector of Raigarh to provide technical clarity on whether the contested portions of the land were redundant. Both the Collector and the Executive Engineer of the Bango Canal Project submitted detailed affidavits and site maps, explaining that land acquisition for a linear irrigation project is not limited to the canal bed alone. The authorities emphasized that space along the canal embankments is essential for regular inspections, maintenance, structural safety, and long-term operational supervision.

The Executive Engineer further stated that the remaining portions of the acquired land were earmarked for future departmental infrastructure, including site offices, equipment storage, and housing for maintenance staff. The court observed that the technical requirements of such projects often necessitate maintaining a reserve pool of land to accommodate long-term development plans. Justice Prasad noted that it is not for the courts to determine the necessity of keeping such land vacant, provided the acquisition itself was legally valid. The ruling clarified that the absence of a permanent physical structure upon a particular parcel does not render that land "unutilised" or surplus in the legal sense.

As the court explained, "The land situated along its banks is required to facilitate inspection and maintenance, while the remaining portions may be required for future operational and public purposes." This finding was central to the dismissal of the petitioners' claims, as the state demonstrated a continuing, bona fide public interest in retaining the entire acquired area.

Scope of Statutory Provisions and Retrospective Claims

A critical component of the litigation involved the interpretation of Section 101 of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013. The petitioners had invoked this section, which allows for the return of acquired land to original owners if it remains unutilised for five years. However, the High Court determined that this provision is not applicable to land acquisition proceedings finalized under the older 1894 Act.

The court relied on the landmark constitutional interpretation provided in Indore Development Authority v. Manoharlal , which established that the 2013 Act cannot be applied retrospectively to reopen long-concluded acquisitions. Justice Prasad underscored that once land has vested in the government, the legislative framework of the 1894 Act does not provide a mechanism for the automatic reversion of property. The ruling reaffirmed the principles laid down in earlier Supreme Court cases, including Govt. of A.P. v. Syed Akbar , noting that "it is axiomatic that the land acquired for a public purpose would be utilised for any other public purpose, though use of it was intended for the original public purpose."

The court further emphasized that because the original 2004 acquisition award was never challenged in its own right, the legal status of the land as property belonging to the State could not be disturbed simply through a later request for reconveyance . "Section 101 cannot be said to be applicable to an acquisition made under the 1894 Act," the court stated, reinforcing that the statutory protections of the 2013 Act are distinct and prospective in their application.

The court ultimately found that the petitioners failed to identify any enforceable statutory right to restoration. Because the land was lawfully vested, and the state had provided a justification based on technical operational needs, the High Court concluded that there was no ground to interfere with the Collector's decision. By dismissing both writ petitions, the High Court of Chhattisgarh has reinforced the finality of completed land acquisition processes, ensuring that public infrastructure agencies can maintain necessary reserve land for future maintenance and expansion without the risk of piecemeal litigation from original landowners. The petitioners' claims were rejected in their entirety, and no orders regarding costs were passed.