Restrains 'HOTEL JEROME'S HOLIDAY INN' From Using 'HOLIDAY INN' Trademark
In a significant interim ruling, the on , granted an against a hotel operating under the name "HOTEL JEROME'S HOLIDAY INN", restraining it from using the "HOLIDAY INN" owned by The court also directed the removal of all listings from third-party online travel platforms.
The 'HOLIDAY INN' Legacy and the Dispute
, the proprietor of the globally recognized "HOLIDAY INN" brand, approached the court alleging and . The plaintiff stated that it has held a registration for the word mark "HOLIDAY INN" since , with subsequent registrations for "HOLIDAY INN RESORT" and various formative marks. Notably, "HOLIDAY INN" has been designated as a in India, and previous Benches of the have already protected the mark against unauthorized use.
The defendant, Mr. Jerome Fernandes, was found to be operating a hotel under the name "HOTEL JEROME'S HOLIDAY INN", which the plaintiff argued completely subsumes its registered "HOLIDAY INN" mark.
Six Continents' Plea for Protection
Counsel for the plaintiff, , submitted that the defendant's use of the name infringed the plaintiff's registered trademarks and amounted to . The plaintiff sought an injunction to stop the use of the impugned mark, to recall promotional materials, to disclose related trademark applications and domain names, and to remove online advertisements from platforms like , , , and .
Prima Facie Case, , and Irreparable Injury
Justice Anup Jairam Bhambhani, after a preliminary examination of the matter, held that the plaintiff had made out a prima facie case. The court observed that the lay in favor of the plaintiff and against the defendant, and that would be caused if the was not granted.
The court noted that the plaintiff had a long-standing registration and a , and the defendant's use of "HOLIDAY INN" as part of its hotel name was likely to cause confusion among consumers.
What the Court Said
In its order, the court stated: “This court is of the view that the plaintiff has succeeded in making-out a in its favour; that the also lies in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendant; and it would appear that would be caused to the plaintiff if the as prayed-for is not granted.”
Ex-Parte Injunction Granted; Online Listings to be Removed
The court restrained the defendant from using the mark "HOTEL JEROME'S HOLIDAY INN", "HOLIDAY INN", or any as a trademark, trade name, corporate name, or domain name. Additionally, the defendant was directed to remove all advertisements and listings from third-party websites, including , , , and , and to disclose any other online listings.
The court also allowed various applications filed by the plaintiff, including exemption from pre-litigation mediation and permission to file additional documents, including on CD/DVD.
The case will next be heard before the Joint Registrar on , for completion of pleadings. The will remain in force until the next hearing.