The Delhi High Court has directed the return of ten separate commercial intellectual property suits, ruling that the plaintiffs failed to establish a credible basis for territorial jurisdiction within the national capital. Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav, presiding over the matters, emphasized that the judiciary must prevent forum shopping by litigants who attempt to invoke the jurisdiction of the Delhi High Court based on mere "slender" connections, such as sporadic website access or isolated transactions.

The court’s decision stems from a systematic application of the governing principles established in its recent ruling in ABD Maestro Private Limited v. Great Galleon Ventures Ltd . By invoking the doctrine of forum non-conveniens , the court has signaled a shift toward ensuring that litigation occurs in the locations where the "material, integral and essential" part of the cause of action arises, rather than at a venue chosen solely for its perceived convenience or accessibility.

In its analysis of the ten suits—which spanned industries ranging from pharmaceuticals and jet engine technology to food manufacturing and digital music licensing—the court found that most plaintiffs were attempting to drag defendants to Delhi despite their primary business operations, manufacturing, and alleged infringement activities occurring entirely within other states like Gujarat, Telangana, Madhya Pradesh, and Maharashtra.

Scrutinizing the Nexus of Infringement

In the patent infringement suit filed by Novartis AG against Lucius Pharmaceuticals Co., Ltd. , the court acknowledged that a portion of the cause of action —specifically the sale of the drug Dabrafenib—had occurred within Delhi. However, Justice Kaurav observed that the plaintiff’s primary corporate affiliate, holding the marketing and import licenses for the patented compound, was located in Mumbai. The court determined that the dispute maintained a significantly stronger connection to Mumbai than to Delhi, noting, "Mumbai, which is the natural forum for the plaintiffs, has a better connection with the lis , indeed owing to the presence of plaintiff no. 2 at that place."

Similarly, the court dismissed the case brought by German firm Gebr Schmid GMBH against Waaree Energies Ltd. , regarding patented solar cell processing technology. While the plaintiff attempted to rely on a sale invoice and an investigator’s purchase to establish jurisdiction, the court observed that the manufacturing process at the heart of the patent dispute took place in Surat, Gujarat. Justice Kaurav pointed out the logistical absurdity of allowing jurisdiction to be dictated by the mere location of a sample delivery, stating, "Jurisdictional tests cannot be of such a nature that courts in each of these States can equally be moved. In this case, the material, integral and essential part of the cause of action , the substance and origin of the dispute, lies outside the jurisdiction of this Court."

Piercing the Veil of Clever Drafting

A significant portion of the judgment focused on the common legal strategy of using "trap transactions" and vague claims of online interactivity to establish a presence in Delhi. In the suit filed by Nyra Chocolates Pvt. Ltd. against Dolphin Foods India Limited, the court analyzed a "trap order" facilitated by the plaintiff to create a territorial link. The court deemed this evidence insufficient and potentially unfair, noting that the pleading lacked the necessary details to demonstrate an bona fide transaction.

The court criticized the use of what it termed " clever drafting ," where plaintiffs omit essential information to suggest that a cause of action exists in Delhi. In several instances, including the matter involving Plusplus Lifesciences LLP , the court noted that despite a quia timet (preemptive) claim, the plaintiffs were unable to specify where the manufacturing or actual infringing activity occurred. The court held that, "This is a fit case to apply the dictum of Manjula and pierce through the clever drafting made in the plaint."

Regarding the role of investigators and agents, the judgment clarified: "As a rule, the use of an investigator or any other person set up by the plaintiff to find jurisdiction before a forum court amounts to concocting jurisdiction ." The court cautioned that such practices do not serve the interests of justice and undermine the principle of territoriality , which is essential for ensuring that parties are not forced to defend complex commercial litigation in forums that lack a substantial connection to the dispute.

Upholding Forum Conveniens as a Safeguard

The court underscored that the doctrine of forum non-conveniens is not merely a procedural preference but a necessary safeguard against the abuse of judicial processes. It emphasized that even if a High Court technically possesses jurisdiction under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, it is not obligated to entertain every matter if doing so would lead to judicial inefficiency or facilitate forum shopping.

Reflecting on the wider impact of this jurisdictional stance, the court noted that "the enforcement of fundamental rights under the Constitution , which are intended to protect life and liberty, is made subject to the doctrine of forum conveniens." By this logic, the court reasoned that intellectual property rights, which are statutory or common law in nature, should not be granted a superior status that allows plaintiffs to bypass natural and more appropriate local forums.

In the case of Global Music Junction Private Limited, the court identified multiple prior agreements between the parties that contained exclusive jurisdiction clauses in favor of courts in Mumbai. Despite these existing contracts, the plaintiff had approached the Delhi High Court based on the argument that its content, allegedly infringed by the defendants, was accessible via streaming platforms within the capital. The court rejected this argument as "absurd," noting that the core of the dispute was a contractual breach that had no factual origin in Delhi.

The court has ordered the return of the plaints in all ten matters, including those filed by Mold-Tek Packaging Limited, HLE Glascoat Limited, and PRVNÍ BRNĚNSKÁ STROJÍRNA VELKÁ BÍTEŠ A.S., under Order VII Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Plaintiffs have been granted the liberty to present their cases before the appropriate courts where the material, integral, and essential parts of the cause of action have arisen.