SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
[BEFORE J. M. SHELAT AND C. A, VAIDIALINGAM, jj.]
PRANAB CHATTERJEE
Versus
STATE OF BIHAR AND ANOTHER.
Writ Petition No. 326 of 1970, decided on October 13, 1970
Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 - Sections 151, 117(3) and 107 - Constitution of India,, 1950 - Article 22 - I. P. G - Sections 143 and 447 - Petitioner along with nine others was arrested on August 9, 1970 at about 10.30 a.m. by police officers headed by Divisional Inspector Parasnath Singh at village Het Kandra in Police Station Sindri, situated within Dhanbad district - Arrest of petitioner was stated to have been made under Section 151, Cr. P. C - Petitioner is an activist of Samyukta Socialist Party and was also former Chairman of Bihar unit of said party - Violation of mandatory provisions of Article 22 of Constitution and remand orders stated to have been passed are illegal as petitioner has never been produced before Magistrate - Held, Limited extent that stage for passing an interim order of detention under Section 117(3), Cr. P. C. has not been shown to have been reached before committing petitioner to jail custody on August 9, 1970 in M. P. and it is on this short ground that detention under Section 117(3), Cr. P. C. is held to be illegal - Petitioner was reported to be sick and unable to attend the court on August 25. 1970 and on all other subsequent occasions - He was transferred to New Delhi on September 28, 1970 for being produced before this Court - Already referred to the majority decision of this Court in Raj Narain v. Superintendent, Central Jail, New Delhi and Another (supra) that an order of remand passed under such circumstances is not illegal - But in view of fact that we have to consider legality of petitioner s detention on date when return has been filed in this Court, that is, on September 24, 1970, petitioner s detention on that date cannot be considered to be illegal because he was kept in detention under proper orders of remand as an under-trial prisoner – Petition dismissed.
Judgment
Vaidlalingam, J.-The petitioner has filed this petition under Article 32 of the Constitution for his release by a writ of habeas corpus from detention in the district jail, Dhanbad, Bihar State. The averments made in the petition are briefly as follows.
2. The petitioner along with nine others was arrested on August 9, 1970 at about 10.30 a.m. by the police officers headed by the Divisional Inspector Parasnath Singh at village Het Kandra in Police Station Sindri, situated within the Dhanbad district. The arrest of the petitioner was stated to have been made under Section 151, Cr. P. C. The petitioner is an activist of Samyukta Socialist Party and was also the former Chairman of the Bihar unit of the said party. On August 9, 1970, the petitioner and his companions were standing scattered unarmed over an area of land in survey plot No. 295 in Khata No. 49 of village Het Kandra in Jharia Anchal in Dhanbad district. He was selecting suitable portion in the said land for cultivation by landless persons who were also present along with the petitioner. The land is stated to be Gair Mazarua land. After his arrest he was taken to Sindri police station and kept there till 2 p. m. and then brought to the district jail, Dhanbad, to which he was admitted after 3.30 p.m. and is being kept in custody in the said jail under the control of the second respondent to the writ petition, the Superintendent of District Jail, Dhanbad. The petitioner was at no time- produced before a Magistrate for remand in the Jail custody, The petitioner learnt from the Superintendent of the Jail that he has been remanded to custody under Sections 151, 117(3) and 107, Cr. P. C. He has not been informed about the grounds for his arrest nor furnished with any other information regarding the reasons for his arrest. The petitioner has been arrested by the officers of the Sindri Police Station due to the influence of Indian Iron and Steel Company who are bent upon grabbing all public lands including survey plot No. 295. The petitioner filed a petition for habeas corpus before the Patna High Court on August 11, 1970, but it has been withdrawn on September 4, 1970. There has been a violation of the mandatory provisions of Article 22 of the Constitution and the remand orders stated to have been passed are illegal as the petitioner has never been produced before the Magistrate.
3. In the return filed by the second respondent, the Superintendent of the District Jaii, it has been stated that the petitioner was arrested not only under Section 151, Gr. P. G., but also under Sections 151/107/117(3) Cr. P. C. on August 9, 1970, on a warrant issued by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Dhanbad. Another warrant for the detention of the petitioner under Sections 143 and 447, I. P. G., has been issued by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Dhanbad, in Sindri Police Station, Case No. 3(5) of 1970. A further warrant is also stated to have been issued by the same Magistrate on August 11, 1970 for detaining the petitioner under the same sections in Sindri Police Station Case No. 5(8) of 1970. The second respondent also refers to an order stated to have been issued on August 2, 1970, by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate under Section 144, Cr. P. C., with which we are not at present concerned. He states that on August 9, 1970, at about 10 a. m. the petitioner and other members of the Samyukta Socialist Party forcibly entered Government lands as well as the lands of the Indian Iron and Steel Company in village Het Kandra within the Sindri Police Station. After fixing party flags on the land they started ploughing the land after mobilising the villagers. This highhanded act of the petitioner and his companions was objected to by the Halka Karamchari and by the management of the Indian Iron and Steel Company. The petitioner and his companions were, however, adamant in ploughing the fields forcibly despite the warning given by the police. The large number of villagers who had by then collected at th
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.