Judgment

GROVER, J. :- This is an appeal by certificate from a judgment of the Madras High Court.

2. The appellant s predecessor in office T. G. Kuppuswamy Iyer filed on April 14, 1950 a suit in the District Court, Madurai, under S. 84 (2) of the Madras Hindu Religious Endowments Act, (Act II of 1927) against the respondent and two other persons who are not parties to the appeal for a declaration that the suit Mandapam was a private Mandapam i.e. family property of Thoguluva Thirumalier and was not a temple covered by the provisions of the aforesaid Act. This suit had to be instituted because the authorities appointed under the Madras Act II of 1927 had held that the premises No. 29 South Masi Street, Madurai wherein the idol of Sri Srinivasaparumal and certain other idols were located was a temple within the meaning of the said Act. The District Judge decreed the suit in favour of the appellant but the High Court, on appeal, reversed that judgment and passed a decree holding that the premises constituted a temple. The appellant thereupon filed a petition for leave to appeal to this court but the High Court refused to grant the certificate. The matter was brought to this Court. By a