SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

1973 Supreme(SC) 273

SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
A.N. RAY, C.J.I., D.G. PALEKAR, Y.V. CHANDRACHUD, P.N. BHAGWATI AND V.R. KRISHNA IYER JJ.
M/s. Daruka and Co., Petitioner
Versus
The Union of India and others, Respondents
Writ Petn. No. 94 of 1972, D/- 31-8-1973.

Advocates:
B.D.SHARMA, B.SEN, J.B.DADACHAN, M.N.SHROFF, O.C.MATHUR, R.K.GARG, Ravindra Narayan, S.C.AGRAWAL, S.T.DESAI

Headnote:

Constitution of India, 1950 - Article 32, 19 (1) (g), 31 and 14 - Imports and Exports Act, 1947 - Section 3, 19, 265, 3 (1) (a) and 4 (a) - Import Control Order 1955 - clause 6 (h) - Import and Export of Goods - Shipment - Challenges Trade Notice - Whether canalisation scheme could have been made under 1947 Act - Whether withholding of right to engage in export trade from newcomer mine-owners not having export in certain basic years - Whether each is an instalment contract severable from other instalments - Whether it is one contract to be performed in instalments - Whether breach of contract is a repudiation of whole contract - Whether it is a severable breach giving rise to a claim for compensation but not a right to treat whole contract as repudiated - Whether duty is an absolute one or mote usually, whether it is only to use all reasonable diligence to obtain necessary licenses – Held, Affidavit evidence is that obligation to export goods arises when foreign buyers open letters of credit for specified quantity of goods - If no date is fixed for bringing into effect canalisation scheme with reference to opening of letter of credit it will give rise to ingenious devices of creating specious contracts - Contracts may be brought into existence by antedating such contracts - Some consignments of mica scrap; cuttings, powder, flakes and mica splittings were despatched by Rail Wagon from Giridih/Kodarma to Calcutta Port for shipment by specific steamer - If for reason of changed pattern of export steamers were not availed or shipment was delayed traders would suffer loss for non-shipment of goods and incur railway demurrage and Port Commissioners demurrage and storage charges - Association therefore asked for relief in matter of export in accordance with contractual terms of existing contracts - Andhra Pradesh Chamber of Commerce added that there were contracts prior to 24 January 1972 stating shipment date for which letters of credit were to be established in due course - Certain contracts were executed in part and for remaining part letters of credit were to be established in due course prior to stipulated time of shipment - Background it cannot be said that Government authorities acted mala fide in extending date of opening of letter of credit - Relaxation was to minimise hardships to traders - Relaxation was to prevent dislocation of trade on a large scale - Association gave instances of traders who could not succeed in opening letters of credit for reasons beyond their control - Petition dismissed.

Judgment

RAY, C. J. :- This petition under Article 32 of the Constitution challenges the Trade Notice Dated 29 January, 1972 referred to as the impugned notice.

2. The import and export of goods is regulated by the Imports and Exports Act, 1947 referred to as the 1947 Act. Section 3 of the 1947 Act empowers the Government to issue orders making provisions for prohibiting, restricting or otherwise controlling the import and export of goods of special description. In exercise of the powers conferred under Section 3 of the 1947 Act the Central Government from time to time issued orders regulating export of goods. The Export Control Order, 1968 referred to as the 1968 Order came into existence under these powers. Clause 3 (1) of the 1968 Order provides that no person shall export goods of the description specified in Schedule 1 of the 1968 Order except under and in accordance with the licence granted by the Central Government or by an Officer specified in Schedule 11 of the 1968 Order. Mica scrap and mica waste are included as item No. 22 (a) of Part B of Schedule 1 of the 1968 Order. Part B of Schedule 1 of the 1968 Order enumerates the items the export of which is allowed on merits or subject to ceilings or other conditions to be specified from time to time.

3. I he impugned Notice is issued by the Controller of Imports & Exports under the aforesaid statutory provisions. Under Trade Notice dated 13 March, 1968 reproducing Export Control Order No 1/68-ETC Dated 8 March, 1968 export of mica including mica splittings, blocks, scrap waste which are included in the list of items in Part B of Schedule 1 of the Export Control Order was allowed on merits.

4. Under the impugned notice the export of mica is decided to be under the scheme to canalise the export of all grades and variety of mica, excepting manufactured and fabricated mica, micanite, reconstituted mica powder and mica paper through the Minerals and Metals Trading Corporation of India Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as the Corporation). The impugned Notice further states that this canalisation of export scheme will be effective from 24 January, 1972. With regard to cases falling under pre-canalisation commitment category, the port licensing authorities may allow export if the shipping documents produced by the exporters are accompanied by documents showing that the contract was entered into with the foreign buyers before 24 January, 1972 or telegraphic offer and acceptance is dated prior to 24 January, 1972 and irrevocable letter of credit at sight is opened in a Bank in India or in foreign country before 24 January, 1972.

5. The impugned Notice further states that exporters who wish to avail themselves of the pre-canalisation commitment category are to furnish particulars on or before 15 February, 1972 at the office of the Controller of Imports & Exports. The particulars are first, full statement showing quantity grade of the mica (blocks, splittings, condenser films, mica scrap and factory cuttings), delivery period name of the buyers, contract number and date with particulars of letter of credit number and date and second, quantities already shipped under these contracts and balance quantities to be shipped.

6. Pursuant to the decision notified under the impugned notice the Corporation issued immediately thereafter a Press Notice on export of mica prescribing the procedure to be adopted by the exporters taking recourse to the Canalisation Scheme.

7. The Press Note states that after consideration of the prevailing trade practices and with a view to causing least dislocation in the existing arrangements between the buyers abroad and the local sellers it has been decided to consider requests from the trade on furnishing full particulars of foreign buyers and other relevant details to negotiate sales of mica on behalf of the Corporation. The Corporation will enter into a sale contract with the foreign buyers on a principal to principal basis. The Corporation will simultaneously enter





























Click Here to Read the rest of this document
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top