SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

1976 Supreme(SC) 401

SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Y.V. CHANDRACHUD, P.K. GOSWAMI AND A.C. GUPTA, JJ.
Commissioner, Lucknow Division and others, Appellants
Versus
Kumari Prem Lata Misra, Respondent.
Civil Appeal No. 343 of 1974,
D/- 26-10-1976.
Advocates appeared
Mr. D. Mukherjee Sr. Advocate, (Mr. C. P. Lal, Advocate with him), for Appellant; M/s. Akhtar Hussain, S. N. Prasad and D. N. Misra, Advocates, for Respondent.

Advocates:
C.P.LAL, D.MUKHERJI, D.N.Mishra, S.AKHTAR HUSSAIN, S.M.PRASAD

Headnote:

Intermediate Education Act, 1921 – Quash of order – Termination from services – Employment and services - President of managing committee of college principal head mistress of basic section and committee of management were imp leaded as opposite parties respectively - Writ petition was dismissed by a single Judge of High Court on a preliminary ground that none of opposite parties was a public authority and impugned orders suspending her and terminating her services were not made in exercise of any statutory function - On appeal a Division Bench of High Court took view that basic section of college was an integral part of college and held that managing committee of college was a statutory body constituted under Intermediate Education Act and governed by regulations framed there under - Division Bench therefore found writ petition maintainable and remanded case to single Judge to be decided on merits - Intermediate Education Act, 1921 as its long title shows is an Act for establishment of a Board of High School and Intermediate Education - Preamble says that it was enacted because it was expedient to establish a Board to take place of Allahabad University in regulating and supervising system of High School and Intermediate education in United Provinces and to prescribe courses therefore - Section 2 of Act defines among other terms Board Institution and Recognition - Board means Board of High School and Intermediate Education. Institution means whole of an institution or a part thereof as case may be - Recognition means recognition for purpose of preparing candidates for admission to Boards examination – Admittedly Colvin College is a recognized institution – Held, It seems clear from provisions set out above that they all relate to recognized institutions; recognition is by the Board for the purpose of preparing candidates for admission of the Boards examination, and Board means the Board of High School and Intermediate Education - Basic section of school cannot therefore be part of a recognized institution - Court are unable to agree with view taken by Division Bench of High Court that basic section is an integral part of institution and therefore must be governed by provisions of the Intermediate Education Act, 1921 - A school by extending its operation to fields beyond that covered by Act cannot extend ambit of Act to include in its sweep these new fields of education which are outside its scope - Case of appellants on this point appears from this counter-affidavit filed by them in answer to writ petition - It is said that college is running Basic Section independently and is neither registered by Government or affiliated by any local body and neither any grant in aid is being taken by department to run this section accordingly - College has its own rules and regulations to conduct Basic Section - It is not correct to think that since college has to have a committee of management as required by Section 16-A a managing committee that looks after affairs of Basic Section of college must also be functioning as a statutory body discharging duties under Intermediate Education Act and governed by Regulations framed there under - Division Bench sought support for view it had taken from some provisions in Educational Code of Uttar Pradesh but as pointed out by learned single Judge Code is only a compilation of various administrative rules and orders relating to educational institutions in State and has no statutory force - Appeal allowed

Judgment

GUPTA, J.:- Colvin Taluqdars College in Lucknow, run by a society registered under the Societies Registration Act, imparts education at the following different stages:

(i) Pre-basic i.e., nursery classes.

(ii) Junior basic, called primary stage, from class I to V.

(iii) Senior basic i.e., Junior high school stage - from class VI to VIII, and

(iv) (a) Higher secondary stage, called high school stage - classes IX and X,

(b) Intermediate stage - classes XI and XII.

In the beginning the college had no pre-basic or junior basic classes and started with class VI; classes I to V and nursery classes were opened later. The respondent was appointed an assistant teacher in the basic section of the college in 1961. Following certain incidents involving her, she was suspended on or about August 20, 1970 and ultimately her services were terminated by the managing committee of the college some time in October 1970. She filed a writ petition in the High Court at Allahabad (Lucknow Bench) alleging inter alia that the order terminating her services was mala fide and made in violation of the regulations framed under the (U. P.) Intermediate Education Act, 1921. She asked for a writ of certiorari quashing the order of suspension and the order terminating her services, and a writ of mandamus directing the opposite parties to pay the full salary and emoluments due to her. The president of the managing committee of the college, the principal, the head mistress of the basic section and the committee of management were impleaded as opposite parties 1, 2, 3 and 4 respectively. The writ petition was dismissed by a single Judge of the High Court on a preliminary ground that none of the opposite parties was a public authority and the impugned orders suspending her and terminating her services were not made in the exercise of any statutory function. On appeal a Division Bench of the High Court* took the view that the basic section of the college was an integral part of the college and held that the managing committee of the college was a statutory body constituted under the Intermediate Education Act and governed by the regulations framed thereunder. The Division Bench therefore found the writ petition maintainable and remanded the case to the single Judge to be decided on merits.

* ILR (1974) 1 All 220.

2. The Intermediate Education Act, 1921, as its long title shows, is an Act for the establishment of a Board of High School and Intermediate Education. The preamble says that it was enacted because it was expedient to establish a Board to take the place of the Allahabad University in regulating and supervising the system of High School and Intermediate education in the United Provinces, and to prescribe courses therefor. Section 2 of the Act defines, among other terms, Board, Institution, and Recognition. Board means the Board of High School and Intermediate Education. Institution means the whole of an institution or a part thereof, as the case may be. Recognition means recognition for the purpose of preparing candidates for admission to the Boards examination. Admittedly, Colvin Taluqdars College is a recognised institution. Section 7 which defines the powers of the Board, after enumerating certain specific powers, states that the Board will have the power "to do all such other acts and things as may be requisite in order to further the objects of the Board as a body constituted for regulating and supervising High School and Intermediate Education." The powers mentioned in Section 7 all relate to High School and Intermediate classes. Sec. 16-A lays down that for every recognised institution there shall be a scheme of administration which must provide, among other matters, for the constitution of a committee of management. Section 16-B and Section 16-C deal with the preparation of the scheme of administration. Section 16-D authorises the Director of Uttar Pradesh to cause inspection of a recognised institution from time to time and order the removal of an




Click Here to Read the rest of this document
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top