Judgment

R. S. PATHAK. J. (Minority view) :- This appeal by special leave has been preferred by Tata Consultancy Engineers against an award dated 20th December, 1978 of the Industrial Tribunal, Maharashtra, Bombay revising the wage scales of certain categories of employees and granting various other benefits.

2. Tata Consultant Engineers, at its inception, was a partnership firm but subsequently the partnership was dissolved and in 1974 the undertaking became one of the divisions of Tata Sons Limited. It functions as a consulting organisation and a service industry, and does not manufacture any product or carry on trade. Its work force consists of engineers and supervisors and different categories of workmen. Out of 665 employees at Bombay. the draftsmen and the administrative staff number 306, These workmen are members of the Tata Consultant Employees Union. They served a Charter of Demands in July, 1974, on the appellant. and as their demands were not accepted and conciliation proceedings proved fruitless, the State Government made a reference of the dispute under Section 10 (1) (d) to the Industrial Tribunal, Maharashtra for adjudication. The Reference was numbered I.-T. No. 292 o