SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

1983 Supreme(SC) 240

SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
D.A. DESAI, O. CHINNAPPA REDDY AND A. VARADARAJAN, JJ.
Abhinash Chandra Gautam (since deceased) through his LRs. Appellant
Versus
Union Territory of Tripura and another, Respondents.
Civil Appeal No. 1507 of 1970, D/- 24-8-1983.#
Advocates appeared
M/s. N. K. Sharma, Vineet Kumar and Miss Deepika Saxena, Advocates for Appellant; Mr. M. M. Abdul Khader, Sr. Advocate Miss A. Subhashini, Advocate with him, for Respondent.
From judgment and order of Judl. Commissioners Court at Tripura in F. A. No. 1 of 1960, Dated 20-9-1967.

Advocates:
A.Subhashini, DIPIKA SAXENA, M.M.ABDUL KHADER, N.K.SHARMA, VINIT KUMAR

Headnote:

Employment and Service matter - Retirement - Back wages - Back wages payable to appellant for period to date of his retirement, his earning as a teacher should be taken into consideration and what amount should be deduced from back wages proportionate to amount earned by him - It may be mentioned that deceased appellant was discharged from service, which discharge is held to be invalid and illegal and he is held to be continuously in service which entitles him to back wages - That part of decree by which deceased appellants discharged from service is held to be illegal and invalid is unassailable as concurrently held by all courts - respondents contended that deceased appellant served as a teacher and his earning as a teacher must be deducted from back wages payable to him by respondents - Learned counsel who appeared for appellant pointed out that appellant has admitted in his evidence that he was serving as a teacher on a monthly salary - It was submitted that appellant to keep his body and soul together had to eke out a living - This is not controverted and there is no material to show that appellant earned something more than per month – Held, appellant obtained his employment as a teacher on a salary - 21/2 years after his discharge from service, which discharge has been held illegal and invalid - Working out period of 21/2 years approximately appellant obtained employment as a teacher - Appellant is entitled to back wages as if his service was uninterrupted - But while computing total amount payable as back wages, amount earned by him at Rs. 100/- p. m. must be deducted and balance should be paid to him by respondent - Accordingly set aside decree of learned Judicial Commissioner and restore decree of trial Court - In execution of decree computation of back wages should be made in manner herein indicated and if court-fee is payable, same may be recovered - Balance amount shall be paid to appellant at 12% interest p. a - Appellant shall be entitled to cost which is quantified - Appellant is dead but his heirs and legal representatives have been substituted and brought on record and decree shall be in their favour and amount shall be paid to them - Decree shall be complied with within four months from today - Order accordingly.

JUDGMENT

 The only point canvassed for consideration in this appeal is whether while computing the back wages payable to the appellant for the period from 8th July, 1952 to the date of his retirement in 1976, his earning as a teacher should be taken into consideration and what amount should be deduced from back wages proportionate to the amount earned by him It may be mentioned that deceased appellant was discharged from service, which discharge is held to be invalid and illegal and he is held to be continuously in service which entitles him to back wages. That part of the decree by which deceased appellants discharged from service is held to be illegal and invalid is unassailable as concurrently held by all courts, The question of computing back wages arises in these circumstances. The respondents contended that deceased appellant served as a teacher and his earning as a teacher must be deducted from back wages payable to him by the respondents. Mr. N. K. Sharma, learned counsel who appeared for the appellant pointed out that the appellant has admitted in his evidence that he was serving as a teacher on a monthly salary of Rs. 100/-. It was submitted that the appellant to keep his body and soul together had to eke out a living. This is not controverted and there is no material to show that the appellant earned something more than Rs. 100/- per month

2. Evidence further shows that the appellant obtained his employment as a teacher on a salary of Rs. 100/- p. m. 21/2 years after his discharge from service, which discharge has been held illegal and invalid. Working out the period of 21/2 years approximately the appellant obtained employment as a teacher from January, 1955. The appellant is entitled to the back wages as if his service was uninterrupted. But while computing the total amount payable as back wages, the amount earned by him from January 1955 at Rs. 100/- p. m. must be deducted and the balance should be paid to him by the respondents. We accordingly set aside the decree of the learned Judicial Commissioner and restore the decree of the trial Court. In the execution of decree the computation of back wages should be made in the manner herein indicated and if the court-fee is payable, the same may be recovered. The balance amount shall be paid to the appellant at 12% interest p. a. The appellant shall be entitled to cost which is quantified at Rs. 5,000/

3. We are informed that the appellant is dead but his heirs and legal representatives have been substituted and brought on record and decree shall be in their favour and the amount shall be paid to them. Decree shall be complied with within four months from today.

Order accordingly.

For Citation: AIR 1984 SC 320

Vikas Info Solutions Pvt. Ltd.

Click Here to Read the rest of this document
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top