SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

1989 Supreme(SC) 625

SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
K.N. SINGH AND N.M. KASLIWAL, JJ.
Bihar State Madarasa Education Board, Patna; Appellant
Versus
Managing Committee of Madarasa Hanfia Arabic College, Jamalia and others, Respondents
Civil Appeals Nos.463-64 of 1986, D/- 5-12-1989.

Advocates:
M.K.SHAH, M.Qamaruddin, P.C.KAPUR, S.N.Mishra

Headnote:Constitution of India-Article 30(1)-protects the right of minorities to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice-such right is not absolute-where a minority institution obtains financial aid and recognition from the State, it is subject to reasonable restrictions-State has right to impose regulations made in the interest of efficiency of institution's discipline, health, sanitation and public order although they may impinge on the exclusive right of administration and management of the institution-a minority institution not taking aid and recognition from the State need not be subjected to regulatory provisions. (1959) SCR 995, (1963) 2 SCR 837, (1971) 1 SCR 1734, (1975)1 SCR 173, (1979) 1 SCR 820, 1988 (I) SCC 206 - Followed. (Para 5)

       Constitution of India-Article 30(1) and Section 3 of Bihar State Madarasa Education Board Act, 1982-Article 30(1) does not contemplate that an autonomous Education Board should be constituted only of persons belonging to minority community-Madarasa Education Hoard consisting of members interested in teaching and research of Persian, Arabic and Islamic studies safeguards the interest of Madarasas of the Muslim community. (Para 7)

       Bihar State Madarasa Education Board Art. 1982-Section 7(2)(n) and Article 30(1) of the Constitution of India-State has power to regulate management and administration of minority institutions-although such regulations may have indirect effect on the absolute right of the minorities, that would not violate Article 30(1) as it is the duty of the State to ensure efficiency in educational institutions-however, there is no power in the State to completely take over management of a minority institution-State cannot frame rules or regulations compelling the management to surrender its right of administration-section 7(2) (n) in so far as provides for dissolution of managing committee of Madarasas is violative of Article 30(1). (1971) 1 SCR 734-Followed. (Para 6)

Judgment

SINGH, J.:- These two appeals are directed against the judgment and order of High Court of Patna dated November 6, 1989, quashing the order of the Bihar State Madarasa Education Board dissolving the Managing Committee of the respondents institution.

2. The State Legislature of Bihar enacted the Bihar State Madarasa Education Board Act (Act 32 of 1982) providing for the constitution of an autonomous Board for development and supervision of Madarasa Education in the State of Bihar. "Madarasa" as defined by S. 2 means an educational institution providing instruction in Islamic, Arabic and Persian studies and recognised as such by the Board. The Board means the Board established under S. 3 of the Act. Section 3 provides for the constitution of State Madarasa Education Board which is a body corporate with perpetual succession and a common seal. The Board consists of a Chairman appointed by the State Government, Director of Education (In charge of oriental Education), Director, Institution of Post-graduate studies and research in Arabic and Persian, Patna. The Principal, Madarasa Islamia, Shamsul Hoda Patna, Chairman, Bihar, Sunni Wakf Board, Patna, Chairman Bihar Shia Wakf Board, Patna, two members of the State Legislature nominated by the Government having interest in Madarasa Education or Islamic studies, two senior teachers of recognised Madarasa nominated by the State Government, and three other members nominated by the State Government who have interest in Madarasa Education or Islamic studies. The Board is invested with powers and functions to provide for instruction and research in Arabic, Persian and Islamic studies and to advise the State Government on all matters relating to Madarasa Education. The Act empowers the Board to direct, supervise and control Madarasa Education, to grant recognition to Madarasas in accordance with the regulations framed by it, to conduct different Madarasa examinations, to publish results, to make regulations prescribing conditions of employees of the Board, to provide for the constitution of the Managing Committee, to constitute academic committee, recognition committee examination committee, and for carrying on its powers and functions in regulating the education in Madarasa Institutions. The Board is headed by a Chairman nominated by the State Government under S. 10(2), of the Act, it lays down that no person shall be eligible for appointment as Chairman unless he holds adequate administrative experience under the Central or State Government and he has teaching or research experience for not less than 10 years in post-graduate educational institutions or he is regarded scholar in Arabic, Persian, Islamic studies and he is interested in Madarasa Education. The Board as constituted by the Act is an autonomous body entrusted with the duty to grant recognition, aid, supervise and control the academic efficiency in the Madarasa Institutions, aided and recognised by it. The members of the Board consist of those persons who are connected with or interested in the teaching and research of Arabic, Persian and Islamic studies, and interested in the Madarasa Education. The Legislature has enacted the Act with the primary purpose of providing an autonomous educational authority for regulating the efficiency of Madarasa Institutions where studies are carried on in Arabic, Persian and Islamic studies.

3. The Hanfia Arabic College Jamalia and Madarasa Shamsul Uloom the respondents institutions are Madarasa institutions aided and recognised by the Board under the provisions of the Act, as such the respondents institutions are subject to the provisions of the Act and the regulations framed by the Board in matters relating to their management and administration. The Committees of management of the two respondent institutions failed to comply with the directions issued by the Board with regard to payment of salary to teachers, whereupon the Board in exercise of its power under S. 7(2)(n) of the Act disso











Click Here to Read the rest of this document
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top