SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2016 Supreme(SC) 209

SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Kurian Joseph, R.F. Nariman, JJ.
Uttam – Appellant
Versus
Saubhag Singh & Ors. – Respondents
Civil Appeal No. 2360 of 2016 [Arising out of SLP(Civil) No. 6036 of 2014]
Decided on : 02-03-2016

Important Points

IMPORTANT POINT
If a male owner died intestate prior to amendment 2005 in section 6 of Hindu Succession Act, 1956 the property devolves by succession among his widow and other coparceners and a partition would be deemed to be effected by operation of law.
On a male owner dying intestate, the property no more remains a joint family property. His widow and other coparceners would hold the property as tenants in common.

Subject

Partition - Hindu Succession Act

Act Referred

HINDU SUCCESSION ACT : S.6, S.8

Headnote

(a) Hindu Succession Act, 1956 – Section 6 – Partition made by a court prior to 9th September, 2005 – Not affected by amendment 2005. (Para 8)

       (b) Hindu Succession Act, 1956 – Section 6, prior to amendment in 2005 – Death of plaintiff’s grandfather in 1973 leaving behind his widow – A partition deemed to be effected by operation of Explanation 1 immediately before death of plaintiff’s grandfather in 1973 – Plaintiff would be entitled to a share in this partition, but for his birth in 1977 – No share can be allotted to him. (Para 15)

       (1978) 3 SCR 761; (1985) 3 SCR 358; (1994) 6 SCC 342 – Relied upon

       (c) Hindu Succession Act, 1956 – Section 8 – Property ancestral property in the hands of the grandfather – On grandfather dying intestate property no more remaining joint family property – Other coparceners and plaintiff’s grandmother holding property as tenants in common and not as joint tenants – Devolving by succession – Plaintiff, the grandson, not born at the time of his grandfather’s death, not a coparcener – Partition suit not maintainable. (Para 20, 21)

       (1986) 3 SCC 567; (2008) 3 SCC 87; (1987) 1 SCC 204 – Relied upon

       (1988) 2 SCC 126; (2006) 8 SCC 581; (2013) 9 SCC 419 – Distinguished

       Facts of the case:

       The plaintiff filed a suit for partition in which the first four defendants happened to be his father (defendant No.3), and his father’s three brothers i.e. defendant Nos. 1,2 and 4. He claimed a 1/8th share in the suit property on the footing that the suit property was ancestral property, and that, being a coparcener, he had a right by birth in the said property in accordance with the Mitakshara Law.

       The trial court decreed the plaintiff’s suit.

       The first Appellate Court allowed the first appeal.

       The High Court dismissed the second Appeal.

       Finding of the Court:

       Appellant’s partition suit is not maintainable.

       Result: Appeal dismissed.

       

Judgement Key Points

Based on the provided legal document, the property does not remain a coparcenary after certain events, particularly the death of a male coparcener. When a male owner dies intestate, the property devolves among his heirs according to the rules of succession, and the joint family property is deemed to be partitioned by operation of law. This results in the property being held as tenants in common by the heirs, rather than as a unified coparcenary entity (!) (!) .

Furthermore, if the interest of a deceased coparcener devolves through intestate succession, the property ceases to be a coparcenary in the hands of the successors. It is then divided into separate shares, and the heirs hold their respective portions as individual tenants in common, thereby losing the joint status of the coparcenary property (!) (!) (!) .

In cases where the property was originally joint and a partition was made prior to the death, the joint status may be preserved up to that point. However, after the death of a coparcener and the application of succession laws, the property is generally no longer considered a coparcenary in the hands of the successors, as they hold the property as tenants in common (!) (!) (!) .

Therefore, property does not remain a coparcenary after the death of a male coparcener and the subsequent devolution of his interest among heirs, especially when the property is divided by operation of law or through succession. It transitions from a joint coparcenary to individual holdings as tenants in common.


JUDGMENT :

R.F. Nariman, J.

1. Leave granted.

2. The present appeal is by the plaintiff who filed a suit for partition, being Suit No.5A of 1999 before the Second Civil Judge, Class II Devas, Madhya Pradesh, dated 28.12.1998, in which the first four defendants happened to be his father (defendant No.3), and his father’s three brothers i.e. defendant Nos. 1,2 and 4. He claimed a 1/8th share in the suit property on the footing that the suit property was ancestral property, and that, being a coparcener, he had a right by birth in the said property in accordance with the Mitakshara Law. A joint written statement was filed by all four brothers, including the plaintiff’s father, claiming that the suit property was not ancestral property, and that an earlier partition had taken place by which the plaintiff’s father had become separate. The trial court, by its order dated 20.12.2000 decreed the plaintiff’s suit holding that it was admitted by DW.1 Mangilal that the property was indeed ancestral property, and that, on the evidence, there was no earlier partition of the said property, as pleaded by the defendants in their written statements.

3. The first Appellate Court, by its judgment dated 12.1.2005, confirmed the finding that the property was ancestral and that no earlier partition between the brothers had in fact taken place. However, it held that the plaintiff’s grandfather, one Jagannath Singh having died in 1973, his widow Mainabai being alive at the time of his death, the said Jagannath Singh’s share would have to be distributed in accordance with Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 as if the said Jagannath Singh had died intestate, and that being the case, once Section 8 steps in, the joint family property has to be divided in accordance with rules of intestacy and not survivorship. This being so, no joint family property remained to be divided when the suit for partition was filed by the plaintiff, and that since the plaintiff had no right while his father was alive, the father alone being a Class I heir (and consequently the plaintiff not being a Class I heir), the plaintiff had no right to sue for partition, and therefore the suit was dismissed and consequently the first appeal was allowed.

4. Following the same line of reasoning and several judgments of this Court, the High Court in second Appeal dismissed the said appeal, holding:-

“15. Thus in view of the provisions contained in Sections 4,6, 8 and Schedule of the Act as well as the law settled by the aforesaid judgments, it is clear that after coming into force of the Act grand-son has no birth right in the properties of grand-father and he cannot claim partition during lifetime of his father.

16. In the present case, it is undisputed that Jagannath had died in the year 1973, leaving behind respondents No. 1 to 4 i.e. his four sons covered by Class I heirs of the schedule therefore, the properties had devolved upon them when succession had opened on the death of Jagannath. It has also been found proved that no partition had taken place between respondents No. 1 to 4. The appellant who is the grand son of Jagannath is not entitled to claim partition during the lifetime of his father Mohan Singh in the properties left behind by Jagannath since the appellant has no birth right in the suit properties.

17. In view of the aforesaid, the substantial questions of law are answered against the appellant by holding that the first appellate court has committed no error in dismissing the suit for partition filed by the appellant referring to Section 8 of the Act and holding that during the lifetime of Mohan Singh, the appellant has no right to get the suit property partitioned.”

5. It is this judgment that has been challenged before us in appeal.

6. Shri Sushil Kumar Jain, learned senior advocate appearing on behalf of the appellant, took us through various provisions of the Hindu Succession Act, and through several judgments of this Court, and contended that Section 6, prior to its a



























































1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
Judicial Analysis

NARENDER NATH VS KRISHNA GUPTA - 2017 0 Supreme(Del) 2054: This case has been expressly overruled by the Supreme Court in Uttam v. Saubhag Singh and Others (2016) 4 SCC 68. The source material states: "Saubhag Singh, (2016) 4 SCC 68, it has been specifically held that Rohit Chauhan's (supra) judgment is [overruled]." The reference to Rohit Chauhan v. Surinder Singh (2013) 9 SCC 419 in the same entry confirms that the prior ratio was treated as bad law.

Shankarrao Amrutrao Kale VS Raghunath Jagoji Shirpurkar - 2017 0 Supreme(Bom) 904: The judgment relied upon in this entry (Wassan Singh and others AIR 1983 Supreme Court 846; Rohit Chauhan v. Surinder Singh and Ors.) has been distinguished and effectively overruled by the Supreme Court in Uttam v. Saubhag Singh and Others (2016) 4 SCC 68. The source states that the apex Court "distinguished the above said decision relied on by the defendants' counsel" and that Uttam (supra) "categorically enunciated" new principles, indicating the prior authority was no longer good law.

KALI AMMAL, W/O. LATE VELUCHAMI ERAPPA KOUNDER VS VALLIYAMMAL, W/O. DORAIRAJ - 2016 0 Supreme(Ker) 526: The case is cited as a recent authority that considered a similar question, and the Supreme Court in Uttam relied upon its principles. The source states: "Saubhag Singh and others (2016 (4) SCC 68) has recently considered a similar question." This indicates Uttam v. Saubhag Singh was followed.

M. Palaniappan VS Nachimuthu - 2016 0 Supreme(Mad) 3694: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as "the latest decision" and is relied upon as authoritative. The source states: "the apex Court has distinguished the above said decision relied on by the defendants' counsel," showing Uttam was followed and applied.

Chinna Palanisamy Gounder VS Latha - 2016 0 Supreme(Mad) 3843: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as "the latest decision (2016) 4 SCC 68," indicating it was followed as the prevailing authority.

Arvind Chatur S/o Late Shri Prakash Mal Chatur VS Laxmi Mehta W/o Late Shri Vijay Singh Mehta - 2017 0 Supreme(Raj) 919: Reliance is placed on Uttam v. Saubhag Singh for the proposition that self-acquired property of Roshan Lal devolves under Section 8 of the Act of 1956. The source states: "in terms of the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Uttam."

Samandhi VS Arumugam - 2017 0 Supreme(Mad) 750: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as "the latest decision Uttam," showing it was followed as the most recent authoritative ruling.

Mukund VS Sulakshana Bokare - 2017 0 Supreme(MP) 228: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the authority that "categorically enunciated the following principles," indicating it was followed.

V. Anil Reddy, Represented by the Power of Attorney Holder B. Bavadeep Reddy VS K. Venkataramana Reddy (Also Known as K. V. Reddy) - 2017 0 Supreme(Kar) 670: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the controlling judgment, with reliance placed on it for the proposition that "the original propositus died in" a certain period.

SHASHI BAHADUR VS MALKA BAHADUR (SINCE DECEASED) THROUGH HER L. R. ABHA NARAIN (SINCE DECEASED) THROUGH HER LRs - 2018 0 Supreme(Del) 1383: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the law under Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, showing it was followed.

B. V. Basavaraj Since deceased Rep. by his LRs. Smt. Sujaya Basavaraj VS K. L. Kumaraswamy S/o Lakshminarayana Shetty - 2018 0 Supreme(Kar) 157: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited alongside Mallika and Others vs. Mr., indicating it was followed as relevant authority.

Suresh Kumar Kohli VS Rakesh Jain - 2018 4 Supreme 747: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as a relied-upon judgment, showing it was followed.

Rekha Rajkumar Bhiwapurkar VS Ashok Kanhaiyyalal Bhiwapurkar - 2018 0 Supreme(Bom) 1979: Reliance is placed on Uttam v. Saubhag Singh, indicating it was followed.

SAURABH SHARMA VS OM WATI - 2018 0 Supreme(Del) 1220: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited for the factual finding regarding Jagannath Singh's property, showing it was followed.

Saurabh Sharma VS Om Wati - Current Civil Cases (2018): Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the authority relied upon by the plaintiff's counsel, indicating it was followed.

Maan Jain VS Suraj Parkash Jain - 2018 0 Supreme(P&H) 1452: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited in the context of the 2005 amendment to Section 6, showing it was followed.

Ratnamala Vilas More VS Tanaji Machindra Pawar - 2018 0 Supreme(Bom) 871: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the Apex Court judgment relied upon, indicating it was followed.

Shobha Purushottam Zilpe VS Ramdas Dadaji Buradkar - 2018 0 Supreme(Bom) 957: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the authority for the proposition regarding daughters' rights, showing it was followed.

Padmavathi Ammal VS Natarajan - 2018 0 Supreme(Mad) 2446: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as "the latest decision (2016) 4 SCC 68," indicating it was followed.

Parasuraman VS Sekar - 2018 0 Supreme(Mad) 2205: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the latest decision, showing it was followed.

S. Bagyalakshmi VS R. K. Subramaniam - 2018 0 Supreme(Mad) 3769: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the latest decision, showing it was followed.

Lal Chand (since Deceased) Through His Lrs VS State Of Haryana And Others - 2019 0 Supreme(P&H) 2049: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the recent case, indicating it was followed.

Lal Chand Lrs And Others VS State Of Haryana And Others - 2019 0 Supreme(P&H) 2313: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the recent ruling, showing it was followed.

AARSHIYA GULATI (MINOR) THR. NEXT FRIEND VS KULDEEP SINGH GULATI - 2019 0 Supreme(Del) 379: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the case that specifically held the prior judgment was overruled, showing Uttam itself was followed.

Jagsir Singh VS Karam Singh - 2019 0 Supreme(P&H) 1775: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the recent case, indicating it was followed.

K. P. Subburaj VS V. Prabhakar - 2019 0 Supreme(Mad) 627: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the latest decision, showing it was followed.

Arshnoor Singh VS Harpal Kaur - 2019 6 Supreme 307: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the judgment relied upon by the respondents, indicating it was followed.

Madangopal VS Sagar - 2019 0 Supreme(Raj) 972: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as an authoritative judgment, showing it was followed.

Deepak Singh VS Radhey Shyam - 2019 0 Supreme(Raj) 1452: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the judgment that held the relevant legal position, indicating it was followed.

Master Anmol Sharma Through His Mother VS Vikrant Seth - 2019 0 Supreme(HP) 796: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relied-upon judgment, showing it was followed.

S. Murugan VS K. Sadayan (Died) - 2019 0 Supreme(Mad) 2619: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the controlling judgment, indicating it was followed.

Ravi @ Ravinder VS Sajjan Kumar - 2019 0 Supreme(Del) 1797: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant Supreme Court judgment, showing it was followed.

Rameshchandra Daulal Soni VS Devichand Hiralal Gandhi (Dead) Thr. Lrs. Smt. Gulabbai Devichand Gandhi - 2019 0 Supreme(SC) 1265: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the decision relied upon, indicating it was followed.

SARVESHVAR VS SUKHDEV - 2019 0 Supreme(MP) 827: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the Supreme Court judgment, showing it was followed.

Sheela VS Amartya - 2019 0 Supreme(Bom) 2290: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant case, indicating it was followed.

Sheela VS Amartya - 2019 0 Supreme(Bom) 2555: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant case, indicating it was followed.

Kanha VS Mange Ram - 2020 0 Supreme(P&H) 630: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the controlling decision, showing it was followed.

Sushil Kumar Agarwal VS Ravi Narayan Agarwal - 2020 0 Supreme(Del) 240: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the case that spelt out the legal position, indicating it was followed.

Kheduram Sahu (died)and Others VS Agasiya Bai Sahu - 2020 0 Supreme(Chh) 359: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the judgment that enunciated the principles, showing it was followed.

Gundala Doraswamy Naidu VS Gundala Jayachandra Naidu - 2020 0 Supreme(AP) 75: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the judgment relied upon by the appellants, indicating it was followed.

Ratan Singh VS Rajaram - 2020 0 Supreme(MP) 1225: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the case that held ancestral property principles, showing it was followed.

Master Ansh Kapoor VS K. B. Kapur - 2021 0 Supreme(Del) 246: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant Supreme Court judgment, indicating it was followed.

Sumathi VS Chinnamal @ Ponnayal - 2021 0 Supreme(Mad) 186: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the latest decision, showing it was followed.

P. Saravanan VS M. Sivasubramanian - 2021 0 Supreme(Mad) 627: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the reported judgment, indicating it was followed.

Parimala VS Sulochana, Rep. by her Power Agent Nagarajan, Namakkal - 2021 0 Supreme(Mad) 666: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relied-upon judgment, showing it was followed.

Parimala VS Sulochana, Rep. by her Power Agent Nagarajan, Namakkal - 2021 0 Supreme(Mad) 150: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relied-upon judgment, showing it was followed.

Bhimappa VS Dundappa - 2021 0 Supreme(Kar) 567: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant judgment, indicating it was followed.

MANGIPUDI NAGARAJU, S/o Rarnalingeswarudu VS STATE OF ANDHRA PRADAESH - 2021 0 Supreme(AP) 564: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the Apex Court judgment, showing it was followed.

JAYAMMA VS RATHNAMMA - 2021 0 Supreme(Kar) 874: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the judgment of the Apex Court, indicating it was followed.

Tara Prosad Lodha VS Revenue Officer, Para - 2022 0 Supreme(Cal) 756: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the decision relied upon, showing it was followed.

Rekha Kapoor VS Pawan Chandra - 2022 0 Supreme(Del) 1838: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant case, indicating it was followed.

Vijayanand VS Parikashith - 2022 0 Supreme(Kar) 1588: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant judgment, showing it was followed.

Somepalli Govindu VS Madikiri Rajamani - Andhra Pradesh (2022): Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relied-upon judgment, indicating it was followed.

Bhimasi Fakirappa Bijjur VS Nagesh Bhimappa Waddar @ Maktedar - 2022 0 Supreme(Kar) 485: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant decision, showing it was followed.

Suvalal Jain VS K. N. Puneeth - 2023 0 Supreme(Kar) 1122: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the Apex Court judgment, indicating it was followed.

Mohinder Singh VS Narinderpal Singh - 2023 0 Supreme(P&H) 1360: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant decision, showing it was followed.

Vasumathi VS R. Vasudevan - Madras (2024): Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the controlling ratio, indicating it was followed.

Vasumathi VS R. Vasudevan - Current Civil Cases (2024): Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the controlling ratio, showing it was followed.

Vasumathi vs R.Vasudevan - 2024 Supreme(Online)(MAD) 40310: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant judgment, indicating it was followed.

Alamelu VS Palanisamy Gounder (Died) - 2024 0 Supreme(Mad) 1956: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant case, showing it was followed.

Lakshman Reddy, S/o. Late Govinda Reddy VS G. Danamma, W/o. Jayaramreddy - 2024 0 Supreme(Kar) 613: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant judgment, indicating it was followed.

Parth Ghorpade, S/O Indrajeet D. Ghorpade VS Indrajeet D. Ghorpade, S/O Late D. B. Ghorpade - 2024 0 Supreme(Kar) 592: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the Apex Court judgment that held Section 8 applies, showing it was followed.

SMT CHANNAMMA W/O LATE MUNINARAYANAPPA SINCE DECEASED HER LRs ARE APPELLANT 1 TO 81 vs SMT THIPPAMMA ALIAS JAYAMMA AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS D/O LATE ANNAYYAPPA - 2025 Supreme(Online)(Kar) 30645: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the case that held the relevant principles, indicating it was followed.

Gajanand S/o Shri Ramjilal vs Omprakash S/o Shri Gajanand - 2025 0 Supreme(Raj) 2221: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the supporting judgment, showing it was followed.

PRALHAD BALKRISHNA BALGHARE AND ANR vs SURYAKANT BALKRISHNA BALGHARE - 2025 Supreme(Online)(Bom) 1155: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the Supreme Court judgment relied upon, indicating it was followed.

RUKMANI vs PONNUSAMY . - 2025 Supreme(Online)(Mad) 16701: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant case, showing it was followed.

Rohit, s/o Pramod Chavan vs Pramod Jayawant Chavan - 2025 0 Supreme(Bom) 1227: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the decision relied upon, indicating it was followed.

Shanmugapriya vs Kandasamy, Arulmurugan, Chitra - 2025 Supreme(Online)(Mad) 26426: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant judgment, showing it was followed.

Malak Singh vs Balwinder Singh - 2025 0 Supreme(P&H) 1670: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the case relied upon, indicating it was followed.

P C MANJULA vs SMT JAYAMMA - 2025 Supreme(Online)(Kar) 21905: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant judgment, showing it was followed.

P.C. Manjula W/O K. Narayan vs Jayamma, W/o Late Kallaiah - 2025 0 Supreme(Kar) 1285: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant judgment, indicating it was followed.

Rajashree W/o. Mudakappa Achannavar vs Uddappa Laxmappa Burli - 2025 0 Supreme(Kar) 1176: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the reported judgment, showing it was followed.

A.Seenivasan vs S.Navaneetha Krishnan (died) - 2025 Supreme(Online)(Mad) 67174: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant judgment, indicating it was followed.

Govardhan vs Ramvati Bai - 2025 Supreme(Online)(MP) 9329: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant case, showing it was followed.

V.Chandrakala vs P.Rajammal (died) - 2025 Supreme(Online)(Mad) 74780: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the case relied upon, indicating it was followed.

V.Chandrakala vs P.Rajammal (died) - 2025 Supreme(Online)(Mad) 74780: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the case relied upon, showing it was followed.

Kapil Modi vs Devendra Kumar Modi - 2026 Supreme(Online)(Del) 12135: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant judgment, indicating it was followed.

Kapil Modi vs Devendra Kumar Modi - 2026 0 Supreme(Del) 1026: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant judgment, showing it was followed.

Devaram S/o Khetaram vs Khetaram S/o Chutraram - 2026 Supreme(Online)(Raj) 19986: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the authoritative judgment, indicating it was followed.

Devaram S/o Khetaram vs Khetaram S/o Chutraram - 2026 Supreme(Online)(Raj) 20577: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the relevant case, showing it was followed.

DEVARAM Vs. KHETARAM - 2026 Supreme(Online)(Raj) 19986: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the authoritative judgment, indicating it was followed.

M. Palaniappan VS Nachimuthu - 2016 0 Supreme(Mad) 3694: The Supreme Court in Uttam v. Saubhag Singh "distinguished the above said decision relied on by the defendants' counsel," indicating the prior case was distinguished rather than followed.

M. Krishnamoorthy VS K. Pondeepankar - 2017 0 Supreme(Mad) 921: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited alongside Prakash vs. Phulavathi, suggesting the principles were distinguished in context.

Mukund VS Sulakshana Bokare - 2017 0 Supreme(MP) 228: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh "summarized the principles" and "categorically enunciated" new ones, indicating it distinguished prior law.

Balkrishna Pandurang Halde VS Yeshodabai Balkrishna Halde - 2018 0 Supreme(Bom) 1137: Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as a case that "cannot be made applicable" to the present facts, indicating it was distinguished.

Vasumathi VS R. Vasudevan - Madras (2024): Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the ratio relied upon by the defendants, indicating it was distinguished and applied to the facts.

Vasumathi VS R. Vasudevan - Current Civil Cases (2024): Uttam v. Saubhag Singh is cited as the ratio relied upon, showing it was distinguished and applied.

: The treatment of the prior judgment is unclear. The source states: "The judgment in Uttam v. ... Saubhag Singh (supra) relied upon by the Respondents is not applicable to the facts of the present case." This suggests Uttam was distinguished rather than overruled, but the language is ambiguous about whether the prior case was treated as bad law.

Bhimasi Fakirappa Bijjur VS Nagesh Bhimappa Waddar @ Maktedar - 2022 0 Supreme(Kar) 485: The treatment is uncertain. The source states: "Saubhag Singh & others [(2016)4 SCC 68]AIR 2008 SC 2033" — the reference to AIR 2008 SC 2033 alongside Uttam is unclear and may indicate a citation to a different case that was distinguished or overruled, but the exact treatment is not explicit.

**Source :** KALI AMMAL, W/O. LATE VELUCHAMI ERAPPA KOUNDER VS VALLIYAMMAL, W/O. DORAIRAJ - Kerala M. Palaniappan VS Nachimuthu - Madras Chinna Palanisamy Gounder VS Latha - Madras Arvind Chatur S/o Late Shri Prakash Mal Chatur VS Laxmi Mehta W/o Late Shri Vijay Singh Mehta - Rajasthan Samandhi VS Arumugam - Madras M. Krishnamoorthy VS K. Pondeepankar - Madras Mukund VS Sulakshana Bokare - Madhya Pradesh V. Anil Reddy, Represented by the Power of Attorney Holder B. Bavadeep Reddy VS K. Venkataramana Reddy (Also Known as K. V. Reddy) - Karnataka NARENDER NATH VS KRISHNA GUPTA - Delhi Shankarrao Amrutrao Kale VS Raghunath Jagoji Shirpurkar - Bombay Dundappa A/F Goudappa Dasappanavar VS Sundrawwa, W/o Rangangouda Biradar Patil - Karnataka Balakrishnan VS Selvi - Madras SHASHI BAHADUR VS MALKA BAHADUR (SINCE DECEASED) THROUGH HER L. R. ABHA NARAIN (SINCE DECEASED) THROUGH HER LRs - Delhi B. V. Basavaraj Since deceased Rep. by his LRs. Smt. Sujaya Basavaraj VS K. L. Kumaraswamy S/o Lakshminarayana Shetty - Karnataka Suresh Kumar Kohli VS Rakesh Jain - Supreme Court Rekha Rajkumar Bhiwapurkar VS Ashok Kanhaiyyalal Bhiwapurkar - Bombay SAURABH SHARMA VS OM WATI - Delhi Saurabh Sharma VS Om Wati - Current Civil Cases Maan Jain VS Suraj Parkash Jain - Punjab and Haryana Ratnamala Vilas More VS Tanaji Machindra Pawar - Bombay Shobha Purushottam Zilpe VS Ramdas Dadaji Buradkar - Bombay Padmavathi Ammal VS Natarajan - Madras Balkrishna Pandurang Halde VS Yeshodabai Balkrishna Halde - Bombay Parasuraman VS Sekar - Madras S. Bagyalakshmi VS R. K. Subramaniam - Madras Lal Chand (since Deceased) Through His Lrs VS State Of Haryana And Others - Punjab and Haryana Lal Chand Lrs And Others VS State Of Haryana And Others - Punjab and Haryana AARSHIYA GULATI (MINOR) THR. NEXT FRIEND VS KULDEEP SINGH GULATI - Delhi Jagsir Singh VS Karam Singh - Punjab and Haryana K. P. Subburaj VS V. Prabhakar - Madras Arshnoor Singh VS Harpal Kaur - Supreme Court Madangopal VS Sagar - Rajasthan Deepak Singh VS Radhey Shyam - Rajasthan Master Anmol Sharma Through His Mother VS Vikrant Seth - Himachal Pradesh S. Murugan VS K. Sadayan (Died) - Madras Ravi @ Ravinder VS Sajjan Kumar - Delhi Rameshchandra Daulal Soni VS Devichand Hiralal Gandhi (Dead) Thr. Lrs. Smt. Gulabbai Devichand Gandhi - Supreme Court SARVESHVAR VS SUKHDEV - Madhya Pradesh Sheela VS Amartya - Bombay Sheela VS Amartya - Bombay Kanha VS Mange Ram - Punjab and Haryana Sushil Kumar Agarwal VS Ravi Narayan Agarwal - Delhi Kheduram Sahu (died)and Others VS Agasiya Bai Sahu - Chhattisgarh Gundala Doraswamy Naidu VS Gundala Jayachandra Naidu - Andhra Pradesh Ratan Singh VS Rajaram - Madhya Pradesh Master Ansh Kapoor VS K. B. Kapur - Delhi Sumathi VS Chinnamal @ Ponnayal - Madras P. Saravanan VS M. Sivasubramanian - Madras Parimala VS Sulochana, Rep. by her Power Agent Nagarajan, Namakkal - Madras Parimala VS Sulochana, Rep. by her Power Agent Nagarajan, Namakkal - Madras Bhimappa VS Dundappa - Karnataka MANGIPUDI NAGARAJU, S/o Rarnalingeswarudu VS STATE OF ANDHRA PRADAESH - Andhra Pradesh JAYAMMA VS RATHNAMMA - Karnataka Tara Prosad Lodha VS Revenue Officer, Para - Calcutta Rekha Kapoor VS Pawan Chandra - Delhi Vijayanand VS Parikashith - Karnataka Somepalli Govindu VS Madikiri Rajamani - Andhra Pradesh Bhimasi Fakirappa Bijjur VS Nagesh Bhimappa Waddar @ Maktedar - Karnataka Suvalal Jain VS K. N. Puneeth - Karnataka Mohinder Singh VS Narinderpal Singh - Punjab and Haryana Leela Devi (deceased) VS Lal Bahadur Singh - Patna VINOD KUMAR BALI Vs ASHISH BALI & ANR. - Delhi Vasant Kashinath Salve vs Moreshwar Bhujangrao Niwalkar - Bombay Vasant Kashinath Salve vs Moreshwar Bhujangrao Niwalkar - Bombay Vasumathi VS R. Vasudevan - Madras Vasumathi VS R. Vasudevan - Current Civil Cases Vasumathi vs R.Vasudevan - Madras Alamelu VS Palanisamy Gounder (Died) - Madras Lakshman Reddy, S/o. Late Govinda Reddy VS G. Danamma, W/o. Jayaramreddy - Karnataka Parth Ghorpade, S/O Indrajeet D. Ghorpade VS Indrajeet D. Ghorpade, S/O Late D. B. Ghorpade - Karnataka SMT CHANNAMMA W/O LATE MUNINARAYANAPPA SINCE DECEASED HER LRs ARE APPELLANT 1 TO 81 vs SMT THIPPAMMA ALIAS JAYAMMA AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS D/O LATE ANNAYYAPPA - Karnataka Gajanand S/o Shri Ramjilal vs Omprakash S/o Shri Gajanand - Rajasthan PRALHAD BALKRISHNA BALGHARE AND ANR vs SURYAKANT BALKRISHNA BALGHARE - Bombay RUKMANI vs PONNUSAMY . - Madras Rohit, s/o Pramod Chavan vs Pramod Jayawant Chavan - Bombay Shanmugapriya vs Kandasamy, Arulmurugan, Chitra - Madras Malak Singh vs Balwinder Singh - Punjab and Haryana P C MANJULA vs SMT JAYAMMA - Karnataka P.C. Manjula W/O K. Narayan vs Jayamma, W/o Late Kallaiah - Karnataka Rajashree W/o. Mudakappa Achannavar vs Uddappa Laxmappa Burli - Karnataka A.Seenivasan vs S.Navaneetha Krishnan (died) - Madras Govardhan vs Ramvati Bai - Madhya Pradesh V.Chandrakala vs P.Rajammal (died) - Madras V.Chandrakala vs P.Rajammal (died) - Madras Kapil Modi vs Devendra Kumar Modi - Delhi Kapil Modi vs Devendra Kumar Modi - Delhi Devaram S/o Khetaram vs Khetaram S/o Chutraram - Rajasthan Devaram S/o Khetaram vs Khetaram S/o Chutraram - Rajasthan DEVARAM Vs. KHETARAM - Rajasthan Commissioner Of Wealth Tax, Kanpur VS Chander Sen - Supreme Court Yudhishter VS Ashok Kumar - Supreme Court Bhanwar Singh VS Puran - Supreme Court Dharma Shamrao Agalawe VS Pandurang Miragu Agalawe - Supreme Court Rohit Chauhan VS Surinder Singh - Supreme Court Gurupad Khandappa Magdum VS Hirabai Khandappa Magdum - Supreme Court State Of Maharashtra VS Narayan Rao Sham Rao Deshmukh - Supreme Court Sheela Devi VS Lal Chand - Supreme Court Shyama Devi VS Manju Shukla - Supreme Court

supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top