1. Administration cancelled a successful e-auction bid for a site, citing it as below market trends, leading to a challenge regarding the validity of contract cancellation and subsequent re-auction. (Para 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 )
2026 Supreme(SC) 1273
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Alok Aradhe, JJ.
Satinder Pal Singh & Ors. – Appellants
Versus
Bedi Hospital & Ors. – Respondents
Civil Appeal No(s). 13855 of 2026 @ Special Leave Petition No. 33791 of 2025, Civil Appeal No(s). 13856 of 2026 @ Special Leave Petition No. 33793 of 2025
Decided On : 16-10-2026
Important Points
Subject
Administrative Law - Public Procurement
Act Referred
CHANDIGARH ESTATE RULES: R.5, R.5(iv)
CONTRACT ACT: S.2(h)
Headnote
(B) Public Auction - Sanctity of process - While highest bids should generally not be discarded without valid reason, the requirements of transparency and natural justice are met if the reasons for cancellation are clearly communicated and the total consideration is refunded (Para 21).
Facts of the case:
An administration conducted an e-auction for two similarly sized health-care sites. Despite the sites being identical, one fetched a significantly higher bid than the other. The administration cancelled the lower bid, citing that the amount did not reflect market trends, and refunded the entire amount before issuing the allotment letter or executing the conveyance deed. A subsequent auction was conducted, which resulted in a significantly higher price. The High Court quashed the cancellation of the first bid and the agreement to sell.
Findings of Court:
The agreement to sell does not constitute an enforceable contract until the conveyance deed is executed. The administration's decision to maximize public revenue by revisiting the auction is a legitimate exercise of power and is not arbitrary. The cancellation was transparent, the reasons were provided, and a full refund was issued.
Issues: Whether the cancellation of the bid contract and the agreement to sell, prior to the issuance of the allotment letter and the execution of the conveyance deed, was arbitrary or illegal, especially when conducted to maximize the sale price of public property.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that as long as the conveyance deed is not executed, the administration can exercise its power under the relevant rules to withdraw a site or reject a bid. Maximizing the price for the sale of public property is a dominant consideration and a valid ground for revisiting an auction process before a final contract is concluded.
Result: Appeals allowed, the judgment and order of the High Court is set aside, and a fresh e-auction for the site is directed to be conducted within three months.
Legal Category Hierarchy
For the Petitioner(s): Mr. T. V. Ratnam- 751, AOR Mr. Rajendra Prasad Maurya, Adv. Mr. Vikramjeet Banerjee, A.S.G. Tadimalla Bhaskar Gowtham, Adv. Mr. Bhuvan Kapoor, Adv. Mr. Varun Chugh, Adv. Mr. Krishna Kant Dubey, Adv. Mr. Shreekant Neelappa Terdal, AOR
For the Respondent(s): Mr. Bhargava V. Desai, AOR Mr. Shivam Sharma, Adv.
Table of Contents
2. The bidder argued that the auction process possessed sanctity and the highest bid could not be discarded arbitrarily, while the administration argued it had authority to ensure price maximization. (Para 9 , 21 , 26 )
3. The court observed that public authorities may recall auction processes before formal contract execution to achieve better price discovery provided the action is not arbitrary or unreasonable. (Para 19 , 20 , 25 )
4. A contract from a public auction is only concluded upon execution of the conveyance deed; hence, authorities may reject highest bids for price maximization before that stage. (Para 19 , 20 )
5. The High Court judgment was set aside, and the administration was directed to conduct a fresh e-auction for the disputed site within three months. (Para 22 , 27 , 28 )
6. At what stage does a contract for the sale of public land via e-auction become legally enforceable?
A contract for the sale of public property via e-auction only becomes enforceable following the execution of the conveyance deed. Until that point, the administration retains the authority to withdraw a site or reject a bid, provided its action is not arbitrary, to ensure fair market price. (Para 15 , 17 , 19 )
7. Can a public authority cancel an auction after accepting the highest bid based on market trends?
Yes, a public authority can cancel an auction process for price maximization, provided the decision is made before the finalization of the allotment letter and execution of the conveyance deed. Such action is justified if it serves the public interest of obtaining the best possible price for public property. (Para 20 , 21 )
8. Does the mere existence of a highest bid create a vested right that prevents an authority from re-auctioning a property?
No, the highest bidder does not acquire an indefeasible right to the property simply by participating. The authority reserves the right to reject the highest bid for valid reasons, such as price concerns, provided there is no violation of principles of natural justice and the process maintains transparency. (Para 15 , 19 , 21 )
JUDGMENT :
1. Leave granted.
2. These Civil Appeals arise out of the final judgment and order of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh1[CWP No. 2811 of 2023 allowing the writ petition filed by M/s Bedi Hospital, respondent no. 1 herein and the writ petitioner before the High Court, challenging the letters of cancellation of the bid contract dated 27.01.2023 and the Agreement to Sell dated 09.02.2023 on the ground that the bid amount offered by M/s Bedi Hospital is not reflective of market trends. For reasons to follow, we set aside the High Court’s decision and have directed the Chandigarh Administration to conduct a fresh e-auction for the said site within a period of three months.
3. The short facts giving rise to the filing of the present civil appeals are as follows: The Chandigarh Administration issued an e-auction notice on 31.08.2022 calling for the e-auction of 12 residential sites, 1 commercial site, and 2 nursing home sites on a freehold basis. In these appeals, we are only concerned with the two nursing home sites, namely Site No. 3 and Site No. 4, located at Sector 33C, Chandigarh, admeasuring 744.44 sq. yards each. The corrigendum published by the Chandigarh Administration dated 04.09.2022 fixed the reserve price for both sites at Rs 6.91 Crores.
4. M/s Bedi Hospital and the appellant submitted their respective bids for both sites, and on 20.10.2022 after conclusion of the auction process, the Appellant’s bid for Site No.3 was accepted and approved as its bid of Rs. 18.25 Crores was the highest. As regards Site No. 4 is concerned, M/s Bedi Hospital’s bid of Rs. 12.58 Crores was accepted and approved. For consideration of the present set of appeals, we are concerned only with Site No. 4 and the controversy that ensued as regards Site No. 4, as follows.
5. After M/s Bedi Hospital was declared as the Highest Bidder for Site No. 4, it deposited the required 25% of the bid amount on 21.10.2022, following which the Estate Officer issued an Agreement to Sell in favour of M/s Bedi Hospital on 28.10.2022. Thereafter, on 16.11.2022, M/s Bedi Hospital also deposited the balance 75% of the bid amount. As the Chandigarh Administration was not issuing the necessary Allotment Letter for execution of the Conveyance Deed, M/s Bedi Hospital addressed a letter dated 12.01.2023 to the Chandigarh Administration requesting them to expedite the formalities.
6. It is in the above-referred circumstances that the Chandigarh Administration seems to have had a rethink on 11.01.2023 about finalising formal allotment in favour of M/s Bedi Hospital for the reason that the bid amount for Site No. 4 was, according to them, not “reflective of the market trend”. This is understandable for the reason that while the adjacent Site No. 3 for the same extent had fetched Rs.18.25 crores, the bid of M/s Bedi Hospital for the plot in question, auctioned on the same day, fetched only Rs.12.58 crores.
7. On 27.01.2023, the Chandigarh Administration issued the first impugned letter to M/s Bedi Hospital cancelling the bid contract, the relevant portion of which reads as follows:
- “It is intimated that the Bid Contract awarded in your favour on 20.10.2022 in respect of Nursing Home Site No. 4, Sector 33-C, Chandigarh is hereby cancelled with immediate effect due to the reason that the site adjacent to Nursing Home Site No. 4 having same area, has fetched the highest bid of Rs. 18,25,75,598/-. Such huge difference i.e. Rs. 6 crores between the adjacent sites having same area does not reflect the market trend. Therefore, it has been decided by the Administration to cancel the current bid for Nursing Home Site No. 4 and re-auction it with reserve price as the highest bid of Nursing Home Site No. 3 Sector 33-C, Chandigarh. The refund of the amount deposited by you has been processed and will be credited in your account by 31.01.2023.
It is pertinent to mention here that as per the sub-clause
(i) under clause I of the general terms and conditions for sale of Nurs