S.B.SINHA, V.V.S.RAO
Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. , Saleemnagar – Appellant
Versus
Municipal Corporation of Hyderabad – Respondent
( 1 ) WHETHER the first respondent herein can grant permission for construction of building in a park is the question involved in this application.
( 2 ) THE first writ petitioner is the Cooperative Housing Society. It has purchased 24 acres 14 guntas of land on 23-10-1956. The said land belonged to one Mir Osman ali Khan who sold it to Saleem Khan. The latter sold it to the first petitioner-society and whereafter plots were allotted to its members by it. The building plan submitted by the society for construction of the buildings was approved. There exists and approved lay out. As per the lay out an extent of 2500 square yards, which is covered by roads on four sides, was set apart for park and the said land was handed over to the Municipal Corporation of Hyderabad, which assumed the possession thereof. The first respondent, however, instead of developing the area as a park leased out about 1800 square yards of the park site to the second respondent for construction of school therein by reason of a lease deed dated 31-12-1981. Some other encroachments had also been made in the said area. The petitioners, therefore, have filed the writ petition for the following r
BHAGYA NAGAR COLONY WELFARE ASSOCIATION VS Government Of A. P. , REP. BY ITS SECRETARY - 2003 0 Supreme(AP) 610: This case explicitly states that reliance was placed on the judgment in "Co-operative Housing Society, Saleemnagar Limited", indicating positive treatment as followed or relied upon.
Grand Vasant Residents Wel. Ass VS DDA - 2014 0 Supreme(Del) 709: Quotes and cites "2001 (5) ALD 663 Co-operative Housing Society, Saleemnagar Limited vs Municipal Corporation of Hyderabad" with "it was held as under:", followed by an excerpt, showing it was followed or applied. Also references a Supreme Court case positively.
Lakshmi Nagar Colony Residents Association VS Hyderabad Urban Development Authority - 2014 0 Supreme(AP) 1459: Cites "Co-operative Housing Society, Saleemnagar Limited's case 2001 (5) ALT 737", referring to it directly as a precedent alongside other cases like "(1995) 1 SCC 47", indicating reliance or positive treatment.
G. SOMA RAJU VS Government Of A. P. , TRANSPORT, ROADS AND BUILDINGS (PORTS) DEPT. - 2002 0 Supreme(AP) 855: Mentions "Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. , v. ... Municipal Corporation of Hyderabad" in sequence with other cases, but no explicit treatment language like followed or overruled; appears as part of ongoing litigation or reference.
Ramakrishna Educational Society, Nandyal VS Chairman, Nandyal Municipality, Kurnool District - 2006 0 Supreme(AP) 398: Refers to "Srinivasa Co-operative Housing Society colony" and declares a related permission "unsustainable in law", but does not clearly treat prior cases; contextually mentions the colony tied to prior housing society cases without explicit treatment signal.
Howrah Ganatantrik Nagarik Samity VS Chief Secretary - 1999 0 Supreme(Cal) 647: Standalone statement on prohibition of construction in public parks and municipal duty; no citation to other cases or treatment language.
L. V. Varadarajalu Naidu and others VS The Collector of Tiruvallur District at Tiruvallur & Others - 1999 0 Supreme(Mad) 822: Standalone statement on government duty to protect natural resources; no citation to other cases or treatment language.
G. SOMA RAJU VS Government Of A. P. , TRANSPORT, ROADS AND BUILDINGS (PORTS) DEPT. - 2002 0 Supreme(AP) 855: Treatment is ambiguous; it lists multiple cases including "Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. , v. ... Municipal Corporation of Hyderabad" alongside others and a letter, but lacks keywords indicating specific treatment (e.g., followed, overruled). Categorized as mentioned due to contextual reference, but unclear if positively relied upon or otherwise treated.
Ramakrishna Educational Society, Nandyal VS Chairman, Nandyal Municipality, Kurnool District - 2006 0 Supreme(AP) 398: Ambiguous; declares a permission "unsustainable in law" in context of "Srinivasa Co-operative housing Society Colony", which overlaps with prior housing society cases, but does not explicitly treat any listed case. Could imply criticism of related permissions, but no direct treatment keywords; categorized as mentioned.
Lakshmi Nagar Colony Residents Association VS Hyderabad Urban Development Authority - 2014 0 Supreme(AP) 1459: References "Housing Society, Saleemnagar Limited's case" alongside other citations, but the phrasing is fragmented (e.g., "223 (4) ALD 74, Co-operative Housing Society... 2001 (5) ALT 737"); treatment appears positive but not explicitly stated as "followed"; placed in followed but noted here for potential ambiguity in exact status.
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.