SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2010 Supreme(AP) 241

High Court of Andhra Pradesh
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAMESH RANGANATHAN
Mallampati Guravaiah
Versus
The Govt. of Andhra Pradesh, Department of Revenue (Endowments) & 4 Others
W.P.No. 23174 OF 2009
DECIDED ON : 30-03-2010

Subject

Administrative Law - Judicial Review

Act Referred

ANDHRA PRADESH CHARITABLE AND HINDU RELIGIOUS INSTITUTIONS AND ENDOWMENTS ACT : S.6(b), S.6(a), S.28(1)(b), S.28(1)(a), S.6, S.28
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : Art.226

Headnote

(A)A.P. CHARITABLE AND HINDU RELIGIOUS INSTITUTIONS AND ENDOWMENTS ACT, 1987—Sections 6 and 28—Subsequent amendment of Act 30 of 1987 by Act 33/2007 cannot set at naught the earlier judgment of High Court in writ petitions, particularly when Act 33/2007 has not been brought into force retrospectively— Issues which have been concluded inter-parties cannot be raised again in proceedings inter-parties. (Paras 10 and 11)

       (B)CONSTITUTION OF INDIA—Article 226—Legislature cannot overrule a judicial decision . (Paras 12 15, 16 and 18)

ADVOCATES APPEARED:
For the Petitioners:S. Posani Venkateswarlu, Advocate.
For the Respondents:R1 to R3 - G.P. for Endowments, R4 - M. Vidyasagar, Advocate.

JUDGMENT :

The order under challenge in this writ petition is the proceedings of the 1st respondent, in Memo No. 45189/End. IV.2/09-1 dated 15.09.2009 (15.10.2009), as being contrary to law, arbitrary and without jurisdiction.

2. Sri Vengamamba Perantalu Temple, situated within the limits of Narrawada Gram Panchayat, Duttalur Mandal, Nellore District, has been notified under Section 6 of the A.P. Charitable and Hindu Religious Institutions and Endowments Act, 1987 (Act No.30 of 1987). The 4th respondent herein is the Managing Trustee of the said temple. On receipt of information, that the 4th respondent had allegedly committed grave and serious irregularities, the 3rd respondent was appointed as the Enquiry Officer to enquire into these allegations. Charges were framed against the 4th respondent and the Enquiry Officer submitted his report holding that all the charges were proved. The 3rd respondent issued a notice to the 4th respondent and, thereafter, passed final orders under Section 28(1)(a)&(b) of Act 30 of 1987 on 03.12.2003 disqualifying him as a trustee of the temple. The 4th respondent filed R.P. No.4 of 2005 before the Regional Joint Commissioner of Endowments, questioning the order of disqualification passed by the Deputy Commissioner of Endowments. The Regional Joint Commissioner, by order dated 08.03.2006, allowed the Revision petition and remanded the matter back to the Deputy Commissioner of Endowments for fresh enquiry.

3. Aggrieved by the order of the Regional Joint Commissioner dated 08.03.2006, the petitioner filed W.P. No.11469 of 2006 and the 4th respondent herein filed W.P. No.11969 of 2006. This Court, by a common order dated 20.06.2006, disposed off both the writ petitions observing that, as on the date of initiation of disciplinary proceedings and conducting enquiry, the temple was under Section 6(b) category for which the Deputy Commissioner was the competent authority; and, before final orders could be passed, the temple was re-classified as a Section 6(a) temple for which the Commissioner of Endowments was the competent authority. This Court directed the Commissioner of Endowments to conclude the enquiry held against the 4th respondent herein and, thereafter, pass appropriate orders. The Commissioner, after furnishing a copy of the enquiry report and calling upon the 4th respondent to submit his objections thereto, considered the material on record and passed orders on 19.09.2006, under Section 28 of the Act, disqualifying the 4th respondent as a trustee of the temple. The 4th respondent approached the Government questioning the order of the Commissioner dated 19.09.2009. The 1st respondent, in turn, issued Memo dated 15.09.2009 (15.10.2009) suspending the order of the Commissioner dated 19.09.2009. The 1st respondent also directed maintenance of status quo as on 19.09.2009. Aggrieved by the said order of the Government, suspending the order of the Commissioner, the present writ petition is filed.

4. The petitioner would contend that, though he had filed a caveat, the 1st respondent did not issue any prior notice either to him or to his Counsel before passing the ex parte interim order. In his Counter affidavit, the 4th respondent would submit that the 2nd respondent suffered from inherent lack of jurisdiction to pass the impugned order as Act 33 of 2007 conferred power on the Dharmika Parishad to pass an order disqualifying a trustee, of a Section 6(a) temple whose income exceeded Rs.25 lakhs per annum, from holding office. The 4th respondent would further submit that he had filed an appeal under Section 90 of the Act and the Government had the jurisdiction to entertain the appeal. He would deny that he had filed a Revision Petition under Section 93 of the Act. In his counter-affidavit the 5th respondent states that the income of the temple, for the year 2008-2009, was 98 lakhs and that the Government had entertained the Revision under Section 93 of Act 30 of 1987.

5. Sri Posani Venkateswarlu, Lear

















1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top