1996 Supreme(Kar) 123
Karnataka High Court
VEERESH KAMBIMATH - Appellant
Versus
CHANAVEERAPPA NARAGUND - Respondent
Decided On : 02-19-96
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Torts
Act Referred
Headnote
Malicious Prosecution - Damages - Sections 342, 427, 504, 506 read with Section 34, I. P. C. - The principle laid down in Balbhaddar Singh and Another v Badri Sah and Another was followed by the Andhra Pradesh high Court in T. V. Lakshmojirao v Somavarapu venkatappaiah. Referring to the aforesaid case, the Andhra Pradesh High Court held that it can be taken as well established, that if a person does nothing beyond giving information to the police, which he considers true, an action for damages for malicious prosecution would not be maintainable against him.
Fact of the Case:
The appellant filed a complaint against the respondents alleging wrongful confinement and nuisance. The respondents were acquitted, and they filed a suit for damages.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the appellant did not go beyond giving what he believed to be correct information to the police and did not interfere with the investigation. The court held that the complaint was not instituted with any malicious intention.
Issues: Whether the appellant's complaint was malicious and led to damages for the respondents.
Ratio Decidendi: The court applied the principle that if a person does nothing beyond giving information to the police, which he considers true, an action for damages for malicious prosecution would not be maintainable against him.
Final Decision: The decree for damages was set aside, and the suit was dismissed. The appeal was allowed with no costs.
( 1 ) THE defendant in Original Suit No. 100 of 1984 in the Court of the Principal Munsiff at Gadag is the appellant. The suit is filed by the respondents for damages of Rs. 4,075/- with interest and for costs, alleging that the appellant filed a criminal complaint against the respondents with a motive to evict them from the premises and caused damage to their reputation and loss of business. The suit was resisted by the appellant contending that he filed a genuine complaint against the respondents as they wrongfully confined him and caused mischief which ended in the acquittal of the respondents and that there is no case for grant of damages.
( 2 ) THE Trial Court held that the respondents are entitled to damages and granted a decree for damages in a sum of Rs. 2,000/ -. The appellant preferred the appeal before the Civil judge, Gadag, in Regular Appeal No. 23 of 1988 against the decree of the Trial Court. The appeal was dismissed by the learned Civil Judge, confirming the decree of the Trial Court.
( 3 ) THE brief facts leading to the present litigation are as follows: the appellant became the owner of the shop in which the respondents are the tenants, by virtue of a partition. The appellant filed a complaint before the JMFC, Gadag, alleging that the respondents had wrongfully confined him and that they were committing nuisance by tethering a buffalo in the shop premises. The complaint was forwarded to the police, who after investigation, filed a charge-sheet against the respondents under sections 342, 427, 504 and 506 read with Section 34, I. P. C. The state examined five witnesses for the prosecution. The learned magistrate after trial, acquitted the respondents, holding that the prosecution failed to prove that the accused wrongfully confined the complainant and committed nuisance and that there was no explanation for the delay in filing the complaint. Subsequently, the respondents filed the suit for damages.
( 4 ) LEARNED Counsel for the appellant contended that the complaint filed by the appellant was not out of any malice or with an oblique motive and that it was a genuine complaint and if the evidence for the prosecution was not sufficient and the respondents were acquitted, it cannot lead to the inference that the complaint was a false complaint. He further contended that though the appellant filed the complaint before the Magistrate, the same was investigated into and the State was the prosecutor and thereafter the appellant did not take any active role in the prosecution and that he may not be held guilty of malicious prosecution and that the Courts below were in error in decreeing the suit for damages.
( 5 ) THE appellant succeeded to the premises in possession of the respondents. He was an young person who visited the premises and thereafter certain events have led the appellant to file a complaint before the Court. After investigation, the police filed the charge-sheet and the appellant was examined as one of the prosecution witness, apart from four others. In fact, the prosecution was conducted by the State even though the criminal process was set in motion by the appellant. There is nothing on record to show that the appellant, apart from filing the complaint before the Magistrate, took any active role in prosecuting the respondents. A submission was made by the learned Counsel for the respondents that the trial underwent several adjournments, putting the respondents to hardship. When the State is the prosecutor, the appellant loses all control over the prosecution and he cannot be blamed for the delay, if any, caused in the trial.
( 6 ) LEARNED Counsel for the petitioner placed reliance on Gaya Prasad v Bhagat Singh, in which it was observed thus:"the principle here laid down is sound enough if properly understood and its application to a particular case was, no doubt, justified, but in the opinion of their Lordships it is not of universal application. In India, the police has special powe