SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2004 Supreme(Bom) 1058

IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Khawilkar A.M., J.
Adarsh Vidya Mandir Trust another .... Petitioners.
Versus
Awadesh Narayan Komal Singh others.... Respondents.
Writ Petition No. 6025 of 2004, decided on 29-7-2004.
Advocates appeared :
S.J. Panicker, for petitioners.
Mihir Desai, for respondent No. 1.
M.H. Solkar, A.G.P., for respondents 2 3.

Subject

Administrative Law - Disciplinary Proceedings

Act Referred

MAHARASHTRA EMPLOYEES OF PRIVATE SCHOOLS CONDITIONS OF SERVICE REGULATION ACT : S.10

Headnote

Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Rules, 1981 - Rules 37 - punishment of reduction of rank to Assistant Teacher passed on the head master for acts of commission and omission - Tribunal finding the order vitiated for non-compliance of principles of natural justice - matter remanded to tribunal for fresh consideration. WP 463/1983; (1996) 9 SCC 322 - Relied upon.
JUDGMENT - KHANWILKAR A.M., J.: - Heard Counsel for the parties.

2. Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith, by consent. Mr. Desai waives notice for respondent No. 1. Mr. Solkar, A.G.P. waives notice for respondents 2 and 3.

3. As short question is involved, the matter is heard for final disposal forthwith, by consent.

4. The respondent No. 1 was employed as Head Master in the petitioner school. He was issued charge-sheet in respect of certain acts of commission and omission. According to the petitioners, the charges are of serious nature. The disciplinary proceedings were held and have finally concluded, recommending reduction of the respondent No. 1 from the post of Head Master to that of Assistant Teacher. That recommendation has been accepted by the Management and order of reduction was accordingly passed. That order was questioned before the School Tribunal by way of statutory appeal being Appeal No. 6 of 1996. The Tribunal has accepted the argument canvassed on behalf of the respondent No. 1 that the enquiry was vitiated due to participation of one of the Judges as witness during the enquiry, and further observed that no fair opportunity was afforded to the respondent No. 1 during the enquiry. Accordingly, the Tribunal while allowing the appeal, passed the following order :

"1. The appeal filed by above named Appellate bearing No. MUM/6/1996 is hereby allowed.

2. The order dated 5-1-1996 signed by the President Shri R.L. Singh reducing the appellant in rank from the post of Headmaster to Asst. Teacher is hereby quashed and set aside.

3. The respondents are hereby directed to reinstate the appellant to his original post of Headmaster from the date of the order 5-1-1996 and to difference in emoluments and other consequential benefits as per Rules.

4. Compliance shall be reported within 40 days from the date of receipt of judgment."

5. Counsel for the petitioners has assailed the correctness of the view taken by the Tribunal. He submits that the conclusion reached by the Tribunal cannot be sustained. He further submits that in any case, assuming that the Tribunal was justified in taking the view that there has been breach of principles of natural justice, in such a case, the Tribunal had two remedies which ought to have been resorted to, instead of setting aside the reduction order and directing reinstatement. According to the petitioners, the Tribunal could have itself examined the charges against the respondent No. 1 on merits by affording both the parties opportunity to establish their position or otherwise, the Tribunal could have relegated the parties to the stage which has been faulted by the Tribunal, as resulting in breach of principles of natural justice. To buttress this submission, reliance is placed on the unreported decision of the Division Bench of our High Court in Writ Petition No. 463 of 1983 decided on 12th August, 1987 in the case of (Children's Educational Uplift Society v. Shri Narayan H. Sukheja others)1, and reported decision of the Apex Court reported in 1996(9) S.C.C. 322 in the case of (State of Punjab others v. Dr. Harbhajan Singh Greasy)2.

6. Counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, supports the conclusion reached by the Tribunal. He, however, fairly submits that in view of the exposition in the aforesaid two decisions pressed into service on behalf of the petitioners, it would be in the interest of justice to relegate the parties before the Tribunal instead of allowing the further enquiry to be held by the management. He submits that the Tribunal be directed to examine the merits of the charges levelled against the respondent No. 1 by affording fair opportunity to both the sides to establish their case.

7. Having considered the rival submissions, I have no hesitation in affirming the opinion expressed by the Tribunal that the enquiry conducted by the management is vitiated on account of breach of principles of natural justice. The Tribunal has recorded reasons to support the said opinion which, to












1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top