2018 Supreme(Bom) 462
IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT NAGPUR
MANISH PITALE, J.
Nilkanth Baliram Sawarkar - Appellant
Versus
Vidyanand Balkrishna Ogale Respondent
Second Appeal No. 464 of 2016
Decided On : 03-05-2018
Subject
Tort Law - MALICIOUS PROSECUTION
Act Referred
INDIAN PENAL CODE : S.447, S.466, S.467, S.468, S.471, S.447, S.466, S.467, S.468, S.471
LIMITATION ACT : Art.74, Art.23, Art.74, Art.23
Headnote
Indian Penal Code, 1860 - Sections 447, 466, 467, 468 and 471 - Anticipatory Bail - Unnecessarily facing humiliation - Quashing of First Information Report - Special Leave - Civil Suit - Respondent in the present case approached the Police Station on 05-09-2002, making allegations against the appellant herein to the effect that he had encroached on the property of the respondent. After the appellant explained the factual position by showing Sale Deed by which he had purchased the property in question, the Police was satisfied that the dispute was of civil nature and that no cognizance was taken of the complaint made by the respondent. Thereafter, the respondent approached the Sub-Registrar and claimed that there was fabrication and forgery at the behest of the appellant in the aforesaid Sale Deed, upon which the Sub-Registrar issued notice to the appellant - Sub-Registrar forwarded a letter to the Police Station in that regard and the respondent again approached the Police Station, as also the Assistant Commissioner of Police, upon which the Police registered Crime against the appellant - Held, Trial Court partly decreed suit for damages for malicious prosecution in favor of appellant while dismissing the counter claim of the respondent on the question of alleged encroachment of the property. A perusal of the prayer clause of Regular Civil Appeal wherein the impugned judgment and order has been passed by the trial Court shows that the respondent specifically prayed for setting aside of the impugned judgment and decree of the trial Court and for dismissal of the suit for damages for malicious prosecution filed by the appellant. Although the grounds raised in the appeal pertained to both decretal of suit for damages for malicious prosecution instituted by the appellant and regarding the dismissal of the counter claim, the prayer made was specific and the appellate Court in the impugned judgment and order considered only the aspect of the suit of the appellant being partly decreed. In the facts of the present case, it becomes evident that the appeal being First Appeal No.357 of 2011 filed by the respondent pertained only to the question of dismissal of counter claim and that Regular Civil Appeal No.424 of 2012, wherein the appellate Court passed the impugned judgment and order, concerned only the question of decree passed in the suit for damages for malicious prosecution in favour of the appellant - First Appeal dismissal
For the Appellant :P.N. Kothari, Advocate.
For the Respondent:Abhijeet Khare, Advocate.
1. In this case, although the appellate Court has upheld the findings rendered by the trial Court on the question of malicious prosecution and the compensation granted in favour of the appellant, the suit has been dismissed by the appellate Court as being barred by limitation. As a result, although the findings on merits are rendered in favour of the appellant, solely on the ground of limitation, the suit itself has been dismissed.
2. The respondent in the present case approached the Police Station on 05-09-2002, making allegations against the appellant herein to the effect that he had encroached on the property of the respondent. After the appellant explained the factual position by showing Sale Deed by which he had purchased the property in question, the Police was satisfied that the dispute was of civil nature and that no cognizance was taken of the complaint made by the respondent. Thereafter, the respondent approached the Sub-Registrar and claimed that there was fabrication and forgery at the behest of the appellant in the aforesaid Sale Deed, upon which the Sub-Registrar issued notice to the appellant. The Sub-Registrar forwarded a letter to the Police Station in that regard and the respondent again approached the Police Station, as also the Assistant Commissioner of Police, upon which the Police registered Crime No.107 of 2003 against the appellant Under Sections 447, 466, 467, 468 and 471 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. The appellant was constrained to approach the Sessions Court for grant of Anticipatory Bail, which was granted on the condition that the appellant would appear before the Police Station on alternate days.
3. In this situation, as the appellant felt that he was unnecessarily facing humiliation, he filed Criminal Writ Petition No.248 of 2003, before this Court for quashing of First Information Report [FIR]. During the pendency of the said Writ Petition, chargesheet was filed in the Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, which was registered as Criminal Complaint Case No.216 of 2003, against the appellant.
4. On 05-11-2003, the aforesaid petition filed by the appellant was allowed and the FIR as well as the chargesheet were quashed by this Court. Thereafter, on 29-11-2003, the Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate dropped the proceedings against the appellant, in the light of the aforesaid order of this Court.
5. The respondent filed a Special Leave Petition before the Hon'ble Supreme Court against the order passed by this Court for quashing of FIR and chargesheet. On 06-02-2004, notices were issued in the aforesaid Special Leave Petition. Thereafter, on 03-09-2004, the Hon'ble Supreme Court dismissed the Special Leave Petition. On 24-11-2004, the appellant filed Special Civil Suit No.818 of 2004, before the Court of Joint Civil Judge Senior Division, Nagpur (trial Court) for damages for malicious prosecution and defamation against the respondent. In this suit, along with his written statement, the respondent filed a counter claim praying for a direction to the appellant to handover the possession of encroached area of land after due enquiry and for a separate enquiry into mesne profit. The trial Court considered the suit and the counterclaim and by its judgment and order dated 27-08-2010, the trial Court partly decreed the suit and dismissed the counter claim filed by the respondent. The trial Court gave findings in favour of the appellant in respect of the damages for malicious prosecution and that there was no encroachment made by him as alleged by the respondent. On this basis, the trial Court directed the respondent to pay an amount of Rs. 4,40,000/- along with interest at the rate of 12% per annum to the appellant from the date of suit till its actual payment.
6. Aggrieved by the same, the respondent filed two appeals one against the dismissal of his counter claim and the other against the suit