SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2018 Supreme(Bom) 1979

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY AT NAGPUR BENCH
Manish Pitale, J.
Rekha Rajkumar Bhiwapurkar and Another – Appellants
Versus
Ashok Kanhaiyyalal Bhiwapurkar and Others – Respondents
Second Appeal No. 419 of 2017
Decided On : 03-05-2018

Subject

Property Law - Partition and Separate Possession

Act Referred

HINDU SUCCESSION ACT : S.8, S.23, S.6, S.29(a)

Headnote

Decree of partition - Separate possession - Share in suit property - Failed to demonstrate perversity - Hindu Succession Act, 1956 - Section 8 - By this appeal, appellants are challenging judgment and order passed by Court of Ad hoc District Judge, Nagpur in Regular Civil Appeal, whereby appellate Court has dismissed appeal and confirmed decree of partition and separate possession passed by Court of Civil Judge Senior Division, Nagpur in a suit filed by respondent Nos 1 and 2 - Parties are related to each other and belong to same family - Kanhaiyyalal Bhiwapurkar was father of respondents herein - Filed Regular Civil Suit, for partition and separate possession of suit property, which was House, Ramdaspeth, Nagpur, consisting of three buildings A, B and C - said respondents claimed that they and other sons and daughters of said Kanhaiyyalal had 1/7th share in suit property while appellant no 3 herein, being grandson of Kanhaiyyalal had 1/14th share in suit property - Said respondents claimed that upon demise of Kanhaiyyalal aforesaid children and their mother had a share each in suit property under S 8 of Act of 1956 - It was claimed that, their mother had executed Will bequeathing her share in suit property in favour of appellant No 3 and respondent No 3 herein - On this basis, decree for partition and separate possession was claimed in suit property - Initially only respondent No1 was plaintiff, but, later on respondent No 2 was transposed as plaintiff No 2 –Held, This appeal is found to be without any merit as appellants have failed to demonstrate any perversity in findings rendered by two Courts below and hence this appeal is dismissed with no order as to costs - On pronouncement of judgment, it is submitted on behalf of appellants that there was an interim order operating in this appeal, which may be continued in interest of justice to enable appellants to take appropriate steps to challenge present order - In interest of justice, adinterim order passed by this Court is continued for a period of 8 weeks from today - Appeal is dismissed

Advocates Appeared:
H.D. Dangre, A.S. Jaiswal, Piyush Shukla.

JUDGMENT :

1. By this appeal, the appellants are challenging the judgment and order dated 14.10.2016 passed by the Court of Ad hoc District Judge, Nagpur (appellate Court) in Regular Civil Appeal No. 566 of 2017, whereby the appellate Court has dismissed the appeal and confirmed the decree of partition and separate possession passed by the Court of Civil Judge Senior Division, Nagpur (trial Court) in a suit filed by respondent Nos. 1 and 2.

2. The parties are related to each other and belong to the same family. Kanhaiyyalal Bhiwapurkar was the father of respondents herein. He was the grandfather of appellant Nos. 2 and 3 herein and father-in-law of appellant No. 1. The family consisted of Kanhaiyyalal Bhiwapurkar, his wife Vinodini, three sons and three daughters. The respondent Nos. 1 and 2 herein being one of the son and daughter of said Kanhaiyyalal Bhiwapurkar, filed Regular Civil Suit No. 363 of 1999 on 13.4.1999, for partition and separate possession of the suit property, which was House No. 139 on plot Nos. 130 and 131, Ramdaspeth, Nagpur, consisting of three buildings A, B and C. The said respondents (original plaintiffs) claimed that they and other sons and daughters of the said Kanhaiyyalal Bhiwapurkar had 1/7th share in the suit property while appellant No. 3 herein, being grandson of Kanhaiyyalal Bhiwapurkar had 1/14th share in the suit property. The said respondents (original plaintiffs) claimed that upon the demise of Kanhaiyyalal Bhiwapurkar on 23.01.1975, the aforesaid children and their mother Vinodini had a share each in the suit property under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 [for short "Act of 1956"]. It was claimed that on 14.11.1991, their mother Vinodini had executed Will bequeathing her share in the suit property in favour of appellant No. 3 and respondent No. 3 herein. On this basis, decree for partition and separate possession was claimed in the suit property. Initially only respondent No. 1 was the plaintiff, but, later on respondent No. 2 was transposed as plaintiff No. 2.

3. On 24.11.2005, the defendants filed their written statement, wherein there was no denial of the fact that late Kanhaiyyalal Bhiwapurkar was the absolute and exclusive owner of the suit property. But, it was contended that since the suit property consisted of dwelling houses, the daughters of late Kanhaiyyalal Bhiwapurkar did not have any claim of succession and partition by virtue of Section 23 of the Act of 1956, and that upon reading of Section 8 with Section 23 of the Act of 1956, the suit property stood devolved only in the name of widow of Kanhaiyyalal Bhiwapurkar i.e. Vinodini and her three sons. On the basis of the pleadings of parties, the trial Court framed issues, including an issue as to whether the defendants proved that under Section 8 read with Section 23 of the Act of 1956, the suit property devolved only on the sons and widow of late Kanhaiyyalal Bhiwapurkar and that the married daughters had no share in the same. Evidence of the parties was recorded before the trial Court, wherein it was specifically deposed by the original plaintiffs that the suit property was the absolute and exclusive property of late Kanhaiyyalal Bhiwapurkar and that all the sisters and brothers had 1/7th share each in the suit property.

4. On the basis of the pleadings, as well as oral and documentary evidence on record, by judgment and order dated 07.04.2008, the trial Court decreed the suit and held that widow of late Kanhaiyyalal Bhiwapurkar i.e. Vinodini, along with 3 sons and 3 daughters had 1/7th share each in the suit property. It was also held that respondent No. 3 herein and appellant No. 3 herein were entitled to 1/14th share in the suit property. The trial Court found that Will Deed dated 14.11.1991 executed by Vinodini was not disputed and that she had died on 30.05.1998. The trial Court found that by operation of Section 8 of the Act of 1956, said late Vinodini Bhiwapurkar and 3 sons along with 3 daughters, all had 1/7t

















1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top