SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2019 Supreme(Bom) 834

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD
SUNIL K. KOTWAL, J.
The State of Maharashtra & Ors. - Petitioners
Versus
Srikant Tamanappa Udge & Ors. - Respondents
FIRST APPEAL NO.1094 OF 2002, XOBJEN. NO. (ST.) 5895 OF 2013
Decided On : 04-06-2019

Subject

Land Acquisition - COMPENSATION

Act Referred

LAND ACQUISITION ACT : S.4(1), S.28, S.18, S.4, S.23(1)(a), S.23(2), S.34

Headnote

Land Acquisition Act – Sections 4, 23, 28, 34 – Enhancement Of Compensation – First Appeal is filed by the State of Maharashtra and Acquiring Body, who were the respondents in Land Acquisition Reference (L.A.R.) against the judgment and award passed by Additional District Judge, whereas compensation at the rate of Rs. 450/- per square metre was awarded for the land acquired from claimant No.1 and compensation at the rate of Rs. 7,500/- per Aar was awarded for the area of 5 Hectare 06 Aar acquired from claimant No.2. – Respondents in First Appeal are the original claimants. – The respondents/claimants have also filed Cross-objection for enhancement of compensation amount at the rate of Rs. 500/- per sq.ft. – What is the reasonable and fair market value of the acquired land on the date of notification under Section 4 (1) of the Act? :- Rs. 778/- per sq. mtr. for 87 Aar of the share of claimant No.1 and Rs.584/- per sq. mtr. for 5 H. 06 Aar of the share of claimant No.2. – Whether the claimants are entitled to interest on enhanced compensation under Section 28 of the Act from the date of dispossession i.e. from 22.12.1992 or from the date of passing of award i.e. from 29.08.1997? :- From the date of passing of award i.e. 29.08.1997. – Held, Though the claimants have claimed compensation at the rate awarded by the Reference Court in L.A.R. No.175/1994 (Exh.34) and L.A.R. No.509/2013 (Exh.35), the copy of judgment in L.A.R. No.175/1994 (Exh.34) shows that land Survey No.45/2 situated at village Kaneri and the copy of judgment in L.A.R. No.509/1993 (Exh.35) shows that land survey No.104/B is situated at Latur were acquired. – The purpose of acquisition in these both cases was for ring road and in L.A.R. No.509/1993 notification under Section 4 (1) of the Act was published – However, in the case at hand the purpose of acquisition is for submersions in Katpur Dam. – Even the date of publication of notification is altogether different – Thus, it is clear that the date of notification under Section 4 (1) of the Act in above-said both Land References is distinct than the notification in the case at hand. – So also the purpose for acquisition is different. – Thus, the parameters for determining compensation will be different in the case at hand than in above said two Land References. – In the circumstances, as held by this Court in the case of “Prakash Borade Vs. State of Maharashtra” (supra), on the ground of parity the rate awarded in L.A.R. No.175/1994 and L.A.R. No.509/1993 cannot be accepted in the case at hand. – Thus, court conclusion is that just and fair market value of 87 Aar acquired land of the share of claimant No.1 comes to Rs. 778/- per square metre and market value of the acquired land of the share of claimant No.2 admeasuring 5 Hectare 06 Aar comes to Rs. 584/- per square metre, on the date of publication of notification under Section 4 (1) of the Act. – Provisions under Sections 28 and 34 of the Act are para materia. – Intent and language expressed and used in both these Sections are identical except difference of stage at which interest is to be granted. – So also, interest under Section 34 of the Act is awarded on compensation awarded by Collector, payable from the date of award when the possession is taken prior to publication of notification under Section 4 (1) of the Act in view of the judgment of Full Bench of this Court in the case of “State of Maharashtra Vs. Kailas Shiva Rangari” reported in [2016 (4) ALL MR 513]. – Therefore, interest under Section 28 of the Act on the enhanced compensation (excess compensation than awarded by Collector) is also payable from the date of award, when the possession of acquired land is taken prior to the date of publication of notification under Section 4 (1) of the Act. – Therefore, interpretation accorded to Section 34 would also have its equal application while understanding import of Section 28 of the Act. – Subsequently, in the case of State of Maharashtra Vs. Pandharinath Misal (supra), this Court held that in view of the Full Bench judgment in the case of “State of Maharashtra Vs. Kailas Shiva Rangari” (supra), whenever possession of the acquired land is taken prior to the date of publication of notification under Section 4 (1) of the Act, the interest under Section 28 of the Act is payable from the date of passing of award by the Collector. – Similar view was again taken by this Court in the case of “Prakash Manikrao Borade & others Vs. State of Maharashtra” (supra). – Court hold that the claimants are entitled to interest on enhanced compensation amount (excess compensation) from the date of passing of award by the Collector – However, in view of the law settled by Full Bench of this Court in the case of “State of Maharashtra Vs. Kailas Shiva Rangari” (supra), the claimants are entitled to rental compensation from the date of taking possession to the date of passing of award. – For that purpose the claimants have to approach the Collector and not the Reference Court under the Act – Order Accordingly

Advocates Appeared:
For the Petitioners:Mr. A.M. Phule, A.G.P., Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar, Advocate.
For the Respondents:Mr. V.D. Gunale and Mr. V.G. Kodale, Advocates.

JUDGMENT :

1. First Appeal No.1094 of 2002 is filed by the State of Maharashtra and Acquiring Body, who were the respondents in Land Acquisition Reference (L.A.R.) No. 954/1997, against the judgment and award passed by 2nd Additional District Judge, Latur whereas compensation at the rate of Rs. 450/- per square metre was awarded for the land acquired from claimant No.1 and compensation at the rate of Rs. 7,500/- per Aar was awarded for the area of 5 Hectare 06 Aar acquired from claimant No.2.

2. The respondents in First Appeal are the original claimants. The respondents/claimants have also filed Cross-objection for enhancement of compensation amount at the rate of Rs. 500/- per sq.ft.

3. For the sake of convenience, hereinafter the parties are referred to in accordance with their status in the Land Reference as “claimants” and “State” as well as “Acquiring Body”.

4. Undisputed facts in between the parties are that out of Survey No.166 situated at Latur, 5 Hectare 93 Aar land was acquired by State of Maharashtra for Acquiring Body, for construction of Katpur Dam (Minor Irrigation Dam). Claimant No.1 had share in the acquired land to the extent of 87 Aar and claimant No.2 had 5 Hectare 06 Aar share in the acquired land. Claimant No.1 is practicing Advocate at Latur and he is father of minor claimant No.2. Even it is not disputed that notification under Section 4 (1) of the Land Acquisition Act (hereinafter referred to as the “Act”), was published in Government Official Gazettee on 22.04.1993. The collector passed award on 29.08.1997. At the appellate stage it is not disputed that possession of the acquired land was taken by Acquiring Body on 22.12.1992. The Collector offered compensation at the rate of Rs.1,20,000/- per Hectare for the acquired land. Being dissatisfied with this award, the claimants filed L.A.R. No.954/1997 which was decided by the Reference Court and out of acquired land, for the land acquired from claimant No.1, compensation was awarded at the rate of Rs. 450/- per squre metre and for the land acquired from claimant No.2 compensation was awarded at the rate of Rs. 7,500/- per Aar. This award has been challenged by both parties.

5. Heard Mr. A.M. Phule, learned A.G.P. for appellant No.1 and Mr. V.R. Sonwalkar, learned Counsel for appellant No.2. Learned Counsel Mr. V.D. Gunale and Mr. V.G. Korale argued for respondent Nos.1 and 2 respectively.

6. Learned A.G.P. for the appellant submits that the sale instances (Exhs.12, 13 and 15) being regarding small N.A. plots, cannot be accepted as comparable sale instances to determine the market value of the acquired land admeasuring 5 Hectare 93 Aar.

7. The next contention of the learned A.G.P. is that though the claimants placed reliance on the award passed in L.A.R. No.175/1994 (Exh.34) and L.A.R. No. 509/1993 (Exh.35), these Land References cannot be considered because the date of notification under Section 4 (1) of the Act and purpose of acquisition, in these both Land References, is altogether different, and therefore, the rate awarded by Reference Court in those Land References cannot be considered for determining the rate of compensation in the case at hand. To substantiate this contention, learned A.G.P. placed reliance on the cases of “Ali Mohammad Beigh and others Vs. State of J & K” (AIR 2017 SC 1518) and “Prakash Manikrao Borade & others Vs. State of Maharashtra and others” delivered by this Court on 7 January 2019 in First Appeal No.1586 of 2009.

8. The next objection raised by learned A.G.P. is that the learned Reference Court awarded interest under Section 28 of the Act on compensation since 22.12.1992 i.e. from the date of taking possession of the acquired land by State, when notification under Section 4 (1) of the Act was published in Official Gazette on 22.04.1993. He submits that as the possession was taken by Acquiring Body prior to the date of publica



























































1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top