P. V. KUNHIKRISHNAN
Davis P. R. – Appellant
Versus
State of Kerala Represented By Public Prosecutor – Respondent
Based on the provided legal document, the court has clarified the following key points regarding bail conditions in cases involving offences of house trespass coupled with mischief:
When an offence of house trespass, which is a non-bailable offence, is committed along with mischief, the court may impose a condition for the accused to deposit an amount equivalent to damages, half of the damages, or even double the damages as a condition for granting bail. This deposited amount will be kept subject to further investigation and trial proceedings (!) .
If the accused are exonerated during police investigation or are acquitted by the court, they are entitled to claim back the deposited amount by filing an application before the appropriate court (!) (!) .
Conversely, if the court finds the accused guilty and convicts them, the deposited amount can be directed to be disbursed to the victim as per law (!) .
The court has the discretion to impose such a deposit condition considering the nature of the offence, particularly when offences involve serious mischief coupled with house trespass, which are non-bailable (!) .
The court emphasized that while imposing such conditions, the deposit should be justified and made with proper reasons, and the order should be a speaking order to ensure transparency and fairness (!) .
The court also noted that the amount deposited is not a penalty but a safeguard during the investigation and trial, intended to serve as a "legal pinch" to prevent vandalism and destruction, and to provide a measure of security for the victims (!) (!) .
The court highlighted that the law permits imposing such deposit conditions to balance the rights of the accused with the need to protect victims and maintain public order, especially in cases involving property damage and violence (!) (!) (!) .
In the specific case at hand, the court directed that each accused deposit a specified amount (Rs.45,000/- for each in one case and Rs.25,000/- for each in another) as a condition for bail, with the understanding that these amounts are subject to the final outcome of the investigation and trial (!) (!) .
The court clarified that if the accused comply with the bail conditions, including the deposit, they must appear before the investigating officer, cooperate with the investigation, and not leave the jurisdiction without permission. Any violation of these conditions can lead to cancellation of bail (!) (!) (!) (!) (!) .
The deposited amounts are intended to be a temporary safeguard, and the final legal determination will govern whether the amounts are refunded or utilized for compensation to victims (!) .
These points reflect the court's approach to balancing the rights of the accused with the interests of victims and public order, especially in cases involving serious property damage and non-bailable offences.
ORDER
P.V. Kunhikrishnan, J.—Destruction of property is a form of violence. Nowadays, when criminal offences are committed, there is a tendency to damage the private properties of the victims, like their residential houses, household items, office items, etc. If a physical hurt is caused, it can be cured on some occasions by medication. But the destruction of property can be compensated only through money. However, the victims in criminal cases have to wait a long time to get compensation. If damages are caused to private properties by the assailants, can a condition be imposed to deposit the damages assessed by the Police as a condition for granting bail, subject to the result of the final decision in the investigation and also by a competent court, is the question to be decided in this case.
2. I will narrate the facts in these bail applications separately. BA No.427/2025 is filed by the accused in Crime No.36/2025 of Mala Police Station, Thrissur District. The above case is registered against the petitioners alleging offences punishable under Sections 126(2), 115(2), 118(1), 110, 333, 324(5) and 3(5) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (for short, BNS). The prosecution case is
Hemachandran M. T. @ Kamalesh and Ors. vs. Sub Inspector of Police and Anr.
Hemanth Kumar and Ors. vs. Sub Inspector of Police and Anr. (2011 (4) KHC 89). – Relied.
Jolly George Varghese and Anr. vs. The Bank of Cochin ((1980) 2 SCC 360). (Para 17) – Relied.
Kodungallur Film Society and Anr. vs. Union of India and Ors.
If an offence of house trespass which is a non-bailable offence coupled with mischief is committed, Court can direct accused to deposit amount of damages/half of amount or even double amount of damag....
The court established that bail can be granted with conditions requiring the deposit of damages for property destruction, emphasizing accountability and deterrence against vandalism.
Bail conditions in cases of vandalism to healthcare institutions must include deposit of damage costs to ensure accountability and discourage further offenses.
Court grants bail under specific conditions despite allegations, citing insufficient grounds for continued detention.
Grant of bail – Any conditions imposed must be reasonable and directly related to this objective – While deciding bail application, it is not the jurisdiction of Court to decide civil disputes as bet....
Granting bail under stringent conditions based on the period of detention, the extent of loss caused to the victims, and the possibility of the applicant absconding or tampering with the prosecution ....
Grant of Pre-arrest bail (Anticipatory bail) – Conditions to be imposed must not be onerous or unreasonable or excessive – Tests for grant of anticipatory bail are well delineated and stand recognize....
Mere violation of bail condition is not sufficient to warrant cancellation of bail; a summary inquiry is necessary to determine the impact of the accused's involvement on the administration of justic....
The court finds pre-arrest bail appropriate due to insufficient evidence implicating the applicants in the alleged crime.
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.