SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

1996 Supreme(Pat) 596

PATNA HIGH COURT
Asok Kumar Ganguly, J.
Hindusthan Petroleum Corporation Limited
Versus
State Of Bihar
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 2905 of 1996 ;
Decided On : SEPTEMBER 12, 1996

Headnote:Bihar Restriction of use of Lands Act, 1948 Sec. 6 (1). 6 (2) (a) and Secs. 37, 38 of Regional Development Authority 3rd Ordinance, 1975 - State Govt. leasing 29.4. acres of land for construction of college building, play ground etc on stipulation that the lessee will not part or transfer possession of any portion of land without authorisation by the lessor - college sought permission for creating sub-lease to the predecessor in interest of the petitioner for installation of the petrol pump over an area of O. 37 decimals which was granted in 1957 - a registered deed of lease was executed in 1958 for 10 years with a clause of its renewal for two further terms of 10 years on certain conditions - petrol pump was running and the lessor college refusing to accept rental from 1993 - District Administration demolishing the petrol pump at the instance of PRDA and handling back possession to college - Petrol Pump installed after grant of permission by District Magistrate and after passing of plan by Patna Improvement Trust - no proceeding for illegal construction initiated or pending - no notice to show cause given by PRDA - in its counter affidavit State disowning any responsibility for demolition - lease clearly includes a sub-lease and registered in 1958 is a lease within meaning of sec. 105 T.P. Act - even if it assumed that the predecessor in interest of the petitioner subsequently became a tenant in sufferance, such a tenant can not be evicted except in accordance with procedure established under law - as at the relevant time Act of 1948 was holding the field and sanction for construction was granted under the Act which will be deemed to have been granted u/s 37 of the Ordinance - sec. 38 - does not confer on the Vice-Chairman to cancel the permit of Pre-Ordinance building - construction was authorised one and plea of PRDA that it was unauthorised construction as not shown in the Master Plan is rather difficult to swallow 1995 (1) PLJR 418, 1979 PLJR 258, AIR 1960 SC 1373, AIR 1965 SC 1006, AIR 1954 Bom. 353, 1978 BBCJ 611 1931 AC 662, AIR, 1989 SC 149, AIR 1956 SC 479 ref & discussed. (Paras 11, 14, 15, 16, 19, 20, 23, 31, 33, 35, 42)

       Bihar Regional Development Authority Act 1958, Sec. 18, 20, 21, 54 - demolition of structure by administration at the instance requisition of PRDA - ground stated to be that the Petrol pump was not shown in the Master Plan - from terms of sec. 18, 20, 21 of the Act, a Master Plan can not, in very suggested scheme contain details of all sanctioned building and structures - sec. 54 can not justify the acts of PRDA and can not be pressed into service for demolition of the building the section has certain built safeguard - there is no order u/s 54 - the action of the PRDA authorities in demolishing the structure is wholly de hors sec. 54 - the structures were constructed on the lease hold land so the petitioner company has a right of being heard - the understanding between the college and PRDA deplored and condemned by their illegal acts the PRDA authorities have not only demolished the structures, they have at the same time severe dent to the edifice of the rule of lay on which is based the administration of justice - the PRDA authorities have no right and authority in law to demolish the structures and college authorities have no right to resume possession in this dubious manner - direction given for handing over the possession and petitioner directed to file an appropriate proceeding before Civil Court for damages and PRDA directed to pay cost of Rs. 50,000.00 to Legal Aid. (Paras 43, 44, 45, 51, 53, 54, 61, 62 & 63)

       

Judgment

1. The action of the Patna Regional Development Authority (hereinafter called the P.R.D.A.) and its Officers in demolishing a retail petrol outlet of the petitioner Company situated on a plot of land which was given to the petitioner Company on lease by the Patna Womens College, Patna (hereinafter called the said College) is the subject-matter of challenge in both the writ petitions, one of which is filed by the petitioner Company and the other by its dealer. Since common questions are involved, both the writ petitions were heard analogously and are governed by this common judgment.

2. The material facts of the case are detailed hereinbelow : Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited (for short called the petitioner Company) is a Government of India undertaking and is a Government Company within the meaning of the Companies Act having its registered office at Bombay and one of its regional office at Boring Canal Road, Patna. The petitioner Company is, inter alia, engaged in the business of manufacture and sale of petrol and petroleum products through different outlets situate at various locations in the country. The said Petrol pump is one such retail petrol outlet, situated on an area of 0.37 acres of land which is approximately about 800 sq. ft.

3. In fact, by an indenture of lease dated 25th January, 1946 between the Governor of Bihar as Lessor and the Congregation of the Apostolic Caramel South Kanara, Mangalore, British India, through Mother M. Theodosia, Principal, Patna Womens College, as Lessee, a perpetual lease was given of a piece of land for the use of education purposes, namely, for the establishment of a Womens College and a Girl School at Patna. The said lease was given in respect of a land measuring about 29.4 acres situated at the New Capital in the district of Patna which was more fully described in the schedule attached to the said lease deed. Clause 5 of the said lease deed of 1946 reads as follows :-

"That the Lessee shall not part with or transfer the possession of the said land or any portion thereof except as authorised by the lessor in writing."

4. In accordance with the provisions of the aforesaid clause 5, the Principal of the said College sought for permission from the Chief Engineer, P.W.D., Patna for creation of a sub-lease in respect of a plot of land measuring O.37 acres in favour of M/s. Caltex (India) Limited the predecessor in-interest of the petitioner Company on the consideration that the said Caltex (India) Limited will pay, to the said College, a sum of Rs.10,000/which will be utilised for construction of a playground. It was clearly stated by the College authority in the letter dated 4th February, 1957 (Annexure 2) that the said amount is required by the said College for its students and that the piece of land on which the said petrol pump will be constructed will be situated to the extreme east corner, at a distance of 800 ft. from the said College compound and as such the privacy of the College will not be disturbed in any way. It was also mentioned in the said letter that in the interest of the College and its Students permission may be accorded to the lessee, the College authority, for the finalisation of the said proposed lease with Caltex (India) Limited. Then by a letter dated 9th July, 1957 (Annexure 3) the Principal of the said College was informed that the proposal of the lessee to create a sub-lease for the installation of a petrol pump has been approved by the Government. It was made clear that the lease of the land to the petrol pump will necessarily be for the remaining period of the lease granted to the Womens College and if for any reason, the other part of the land which has been leased to the Womens College reverts to the Government, the land which is given to the petrol pump will automatically revert to the Government. A copy of the said letter was forwarded to the Principal of the said College as also the District Manager, Caltex (India) Limited, Patna, which is





































































Click Here to Read the rest of this document

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top