SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2008 Supreme(Pat) 950

PATNA HIGH COURT
Ghanshyam Prasad, J.
Imranuddin Khan
Versus
Waris Imam
Appeal from appellate decree No. 642 of 1986 ;
Decided On : JULY 15, 2008

Subject

Tort Law - Malicious Prosecution

Act Referred

INDIAN PENAL CODE : S.109, S.323, S.379

Headnote

Tort-Suit filed for damages on the ground of malicious prosecution-Courts below holding that there was no reasonable and probable cause for prosecution-It is purely personal liability-Cause of action for damages relating to original defendant abated with his death-His heirs can not be held liable to pay any damage for malicious prosecution-Appeal partly allowed. (Paras 18 to 23)

       1968 BLJR 441; AIR 1974 Allahabad 129-Referred to.

       Maxim-Action personalis Moritur cum Persona-It is applied in action for tort-Death of wronged or wrong doer puts an end to the cause of action. (Para 21)

       

Judgment

GHANSHYAM PRASAD, J.

1. This Second Appeal has been preferred by the defendants against the judgment and decree dated 14.7.1986 passed by the 4th Additional. District Judge, Gaya in Money Appeal No.2 of 1984/7 of 1981. The learned Additional District Judge vide above judgment has dismissed the appeal and confirmed the judgment and decree dated 8.6.1981 passed by the Additional Munsif II, Gaya in Money Suit No. 20/1980/62/1978.

2. The facts lending to this Second Appeal are as follows; The appellants were defendants in the aforesaid suit. The plaintiff-respondent was a practicing Advocate at Gaya. He filed the suit against the defendant no.1 and his brother-in-law as original defendant no.2, Wazhat Hussain Khan, who was retired Sub-Inspector of police, for damages and compensation to the tune of Rupees one thousand along with some other reliefs. The suit was ultimately decreed on contest.

3. During the pendency of the suit the original defendant no.2 died and on his place his heirs were substituted as defendant nos. 2(a) to 2(c), who are appellants in this appeal as appellant nos.2 to 4. The defendants preferred the appeal against the judgment of lower court which was also dismissed, Thereafter, the instant Second Appeal has been filed.

4. The case of the plaintiff respondent in short is that he was a practicing Advocate commanding respect in the society. One Moinuddin Khan was tenant in one of the houses of original defendant no.2. There were several litigations between them including one under Mouse Control Act in which plaintiff was working against the defendant. Being aggrieved by it, both defendants in collusion and conspiracy with each other got one first information lodged by the defendant no.1 against the plaintiff and others before Kotwali police station on 16.2.1975 with false and concocted allegations. The defendant no.2 being retired police personnel influenced the investigation and got the charge-sheet submitted against the plaintiff and three others under Ss. 379 and 323/109 of the Indian Penal Code. Ultimately the plaintiff was put on trial. However, the trial ended in clean acquittal of the plaintiff. It is alleged that the plaintiff during the trial suffered mental and monetary loss and also loss of prestige as a result of false implication in criminal case, The total damage was assessed and estimated to the tune of rupees one thousand.

5. Two sets of written statements were filed, one on behalf of the defendant no.1 and other on behalf of heirs of original defendant no.2 i.e. defendants nos.2 (a) to 2 (c). The case of defendant no.l is that the plaintiff actively participated in instigation of other accused persons to assault and rob him and, therefore, first information report was lodged against the plaintiff also. He denied about collusion and conspiracy with original defendant no.2. He also denied about any bad motive or ill will to lodge the first information report. It has been averred that the first information report was lodged with true facts. The plaintiff was not cleanly acquitted. He was given benefit of doubt. He also denied about any monetary loss. According to him, the. plaintiff being lawyer himself conducted his case and they did not suffer any monetary loss.

6. The other defendants while adopting the written statement of defendant no.1 denied that Moinuddin was ever tenant in any house of defendant no.2. He also denied that defendant no.2 had anything in lodging criminal case by defendant no. 1. The defendant no. 1 filed criminal case with true facts. The original defendant no.2 after retirement had no influence on the police department nor did he get the case diary of the case manipulated. The police properly investigated the case and submitted charge-sheet against the plaintiff and others.

7. The learned trial court framed as many as seven issues. However, the suit was decreed on the basis of findings on issue no. 6, which runs as follows:

"Was the criminal proceeding launched agains




























1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top