Calcutta High Court
SHAMSUDDIN AHMED AND SIBA PRASAD RAJKHOWA, JJ.
Collector, Land Acquisition, Darjeeling - Appellant
Versus
Sudhangsu Sil - Respondents
F.A. No. 390 of 1988
Decided On : 1 July 1991
LAND ACQUISITION - VALUATION - COMPENSATION - ENHANCEMENT - SALE DEEDS - EVIDENCE - INTERPRETATION OF SECTION 23(1-A) AND 28 OF THE LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1984 - ADDITIONAL COMPENSATION - INTEREST.
Fact of the Case:
The State of West Bengal appealed against the judgment and decree of the District Judge, Darjeeling, which enhanced the compensation awarded by the Land Acquisition Collector for the acquisition of land and buildings at Kalimpong for the construction of Civil and Criminal Courts and a Soil Testing Laboratory.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the District Judge erred in law in enhancing the value of the acquired land from Rs. 2,95,255/- to Rs. 7,01,355/- and in granting additional compensation under Section 23(1-A) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1984, as the provisions of the amended Act were not applicable to the case.
Issues: 1. Whether the District Judge erred in law in enhancing the value of the acquired land from Rs. 2,95,255/- to Rs. 7,01,355/-? 2. Whether the District Judge erred in law in granting additional compensation under Section 23(1-A) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1984?
Ratio Decidendi: 1. The court held that the District Judge erred in law in enhancing the value of the acquired land as the evidence on record did not support such a high valuation. The court relied on the valuation report of a Registered Government Valuer and Chartered Surveyor, who assessed the value of the land at Rs. 1,86,405/- per acre, which was higher than the Collector's valuation but lower than the District Judge's valuation. 2. The court held that the District Judge erred in law in granting additional compensation under Section 23(1-A) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1984, as the provisions of the amended Act were not applicable to the case. The court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Filip Tiago De Gama, which held that the benefit of additional compensation under Section 23(1-A) was available only in cases where the award was made by the Collector or the Court during the period between 30 April, 1982 and 24 September, 1974, or where the proceeding was pending before the Collector on 30-4-82.
Final Decision: The court partly allowed the appeal, modified the impugned award of the District Judge, and directed the Collector to pay the balance of compensation to the claimants within six months.
S. P. RAJKHOWA, J. :- This appeal is directed against the judgment and decree dated 31st July, 1987 passed by the learned District Judge, Darjeeling in Misc. Judicial (Land Acquisition) Case No. 11 of 1977.
2. This case relates to acquisition of land with building and garden known as Sailabhas at Kalimpong for accommodation of Civil and Criminal Courts at Kalimpong and Soil Testing Laboratory of the Agricultural Department under L.A. Case No. 3/5 of 1976-77. The total area of the land is 2.115 acres comprising homestead, garden, sukha, bamboo and road classes of land recorded in the settlement record of Mouza Kalimpong town, J.L. No. 56, P. S. Kalimpong, District Darjeeling, covered by C.S. Plot Nos. 7901, 7902, 7903, 7904, 7905, 7906 and 7907. The property has been acquired by Notification No. 26056-L.A. dt. 24-10-75 published in the Calcutta Extra Ordinary Gazette of the same date and Declaration No. 21552-L.A. dt. 23-12-76 published in Calcutta Extra Ordinary Gazette dt. 24-12-76. The total award of compensation given by the Collector is Rs. 2,95,255/-.
3. The claimants filed an application u/S. 18 of the Land Acquisition Act before the Collector and accordingly the Collector made a reference to the District Judge. After considering the evidence on record the learned District Judge allowed the reference and awarded compensation which is as follows :
(a) Rs. 2,20,979/- for land measuring 2.115 acres;
(b) Rs. 2,61,463/- for building and other structures;
(c) Rs. 30,000/- for fittings;
(d) Rs. 10,000/- for trees;
(e) Rs. 22,181/- for compensation u/S.23(1-A) of the L.A. Act @ 12 per annum from 24-10-75 to 3-3-76;
(f) Rs. 1,56,732/- for compensation u/S.23(2) of the L.A. Act of the total valuation of the land including building, fittings and trees @ 30 per centum
TOTAL Rs. 7,01,355/-
(Rupees Seven Lac One Thousand Three Hundred Fifty-five). Less the amount already drawn.
(g) Interest at the rate of 9% per annum on the excess amount of Rs. 2,32,187/- from the date of award of the Collector to the date of payment u/S.28 of the L.A. Act
(h) Cost of the proceeding fixed at Rs.2000/- to be paid by the Collector to the claimants.
4. Being aggrieved by the judgment and decree, the State has preferred this appeal.
5. The learned counsel for the appellant has mainly urged before us that the learned District Judge erred in law in enhancing the value of the acquired land to Rs. 7,01,355/- from Rs. 2,95,255/- as awarded by the Land Acquisition Collector and that the reasons given for this increased rate is against the evidence on record; that the claimants filed an objection before the L. A. Collector claiming a total sum of Rs. 1,00,000/- for change of residence, place and business and incidental charges but that the learned District Judge erred in law in enhancing the amount of compensation and further erred in law in appointing a Commissioner and placing reliance on Ext. 1 and that the learned District Judge erred in law in allowing Rs. 10,000/- for the trees, Rs. 30,000/- for fittings in the building and Rs. 2,61,463/- for the building and other structures.
6. From the evidence on record we find that the claimants produced before the learned District Judge, the following sale deeds for laying the foundation for assessing the value of the acquired land :- Ext. 3 is a sale deed executed on 18-6-75 showing a transaction of a parcel of vacant land measuring 31¢ x 62¢ = 1922 sq. ft. of D.I.F. Plot No. 104 (old) situated at D. S. Gurung Road of Kalimpong Municipality and within the D.I.F. area of Kalimpong at a consideration of Rs. 13,000/-; Ext. 3(a) is a sale deed dt. 14-7-75 showing a transaction of a parcel of vacant land measuring 20¢ x 19¢ = 380 sq. ft. of Plot No. 227-A situated at Murghi Hatta within the Kalimpong Municipality, Ward No. II, for a consideration of Rs. 1,200/- Ext. 3(b) is a sale deed dt. 23rd July, 1975 showing a transaction of a parcel of vacant land measuring 1261/2 sq. ft. of D.I.F. Plot No. 106 (old) situated
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.