HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA
S. C. Lahiri, H. K. Bose
MAHALUXMI BANK LTD. - Appellant
Versus
REGISTRAR OF COMPANIES, WEST BENGAL - Respondent
A. F. O. O. 267 Of 1959
Decided On : SEPTEMBER 07, 1960
COMPANY LAW - ALTERATION OF OBJECT CLAUSES - CONFIRMATION - JURISDICTION OF COURT - FACTORS TO BE CONSIDERED - DISCRETION OF COURT - INTEREST OF CREDITORS, SHAREHOLDERS AND PUBLIC - PUBLICITY OF PROCEEDINGS - APPROVAL OF CENTRAL GOVERNMENT - SECTION 17 OF THE COMPANIES ACT, 1956 - SECTION 49C OF THE BANKING COMPANIES ACT, 1949 - RETROSPECTIVE OPERATION.
Fact of the Case:
The appellant company, Mahaluxmi Bank Ltd., was incorporated in 1910 as a company limited by shares to carry on inter alia the business of banking. In 1950, a scheme of arrangement between the company and its creditors was sanctioned by the court, prohibiting the company from receiving further deposits or functioning as a bank until further orders from the Reserve Bank of India. In 1953, the Reserve Bank of India directed the company to convert itself into a non-banking company and to alter its Memorandum of Association accordingly. The company complied with these directions and obtained an order from the court confirming the alteration of its objects. However, the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies opposed the confirmation and filed an affidavit-in-opposition. The company then applied to the Central Government for approval of the change of its name to Mahaluxmi Loan and Trading Co. Ltd., as required under Section 11(4) of the Indian Companies Act, 1913. The Central Government suggested that the company's object clauses be further altered to eschew the business of banking. The company filed an application for confirmation of the alteration of its objects, which was dismissed by the trial court.
Finding of the Court:
The court held that the trial court erred in refusing to confirm the alteration of the company's objects. The court found that the company had complied with all the requirements of Section 17 of the Companies Act, 1956, and that the alteration was in the best interests of the company, its creditors, and the public. The court also held that Section 49C of the Banking Companies Act, 1949, which requires a certificate from the Reserve Bank of India for the confirmation of alteration of the Memorandum of a banking company, was not applicable to the present case as it was not retrospective in operation.
Issues: 1. Whether the court has jurisdiction to confirm the alteration of the company's objects under Section 17 of the Companies Act, 1956? 2. Whether the alteration of the company's objects is in the best interests of the company, its creditors, and the public? 3. Whether Section 49C of the Banking Companies Act, 1949, is applicable to the present case?
Ratio Decidendi: 1. The court has jurisdiction to confirm the alteration of the company's objects under Section 17 of the Companies Act, 1956, provided that the conditions laid down in that section have been fulfilled. 2. The alteration of the company's objects is in the best interests of the company, its creditors, and the public, as it will allow the company to continue its operations as a non-banking company and to avoid the restrictions imposed by the Banking Companies Act, 1949. 3. Section 49C of the Banking Companies Act, 1949, is not applicable to the present case as it is not retrospective in operation.
Final Decision: The appeal was allowed, the judgment and order of the trial court were set aside, and an order was made in terms of prayer (a) of the petition.
( 1 ) THIS is an appeal from an order of P. B. Mukharji, J. dated the 1,5th June, 1959 dismissing an application for confirmation of certain alterations in the object clauses of the Memorandum of Association of a company known as Mahaluxmi Bank Ltd.
( 2 ) THE appellant company was incorporated under the Indian Companies Act in 1910 as a company limited by shares to carry on inter alia the business of banking. On 27th February, 1950 by an order made by this Court a scheme of arrangement between the company and its creditors was sanctioned and by the said order the company was prohibited from receiving further deposits or to function as a bank until further orders from the Reserve Bank of India. The relevant portion of that order read as follows:"and it is further ordered that the said company shall not be entitled to receive further deposits or to function as a Bank until the Reserve Bank of India permits the said Bank to do so. "by a letter dated 20th August, 1953 the company applied to the Reserve Bank of India for permis sion to carry on non-banking business. The Reserve Bank of India by its letter dated the 27th August 1953, stated that if the company desired to convert itself into a non-banking company it should: (1) pass a resolution declaring in unequivocal terms its intentions to cease carrying on the business of banking; (2) alter the Memorandum of Association so as to delete therefrom such clauses as enable it to transact the business of banking; and (3) change its name so as to conform to section 7 of the Banking Companies Act, 1949. In pursuance of these directions of the Reserve Bank of India the company convened two separate meetings of the share-holders and creditors on 28th June, 1954 and 29th June, 1954 respectively to consider the question of conversion of the company into a non-banking company and at both these meetings it was unanimously resolved that the name of the company be changed to Mahaluxmi Loan and Trading Company Ltd. , and the object clauses in the Memorandum of Association be altered suitably. Thereafter fay a special resolution of the company passed at an Extraordinary General Meeting of the company held on 14th August, 1954, it was resolved that the objects of the company be altered by aban- doning the object clauses relating to banking and to expand the scope of its object with a view to carry on other non-banking business which under existing situation may conveniently and advantageously be taken up and carried on with its existing non-banking business. On 7th September, 1954, the company made an application to this Court for
confirmation of the alteration of its objects as passed by the special resolution dated the 14th of August, 1954 and upon presentation of such application directions were given for proper advertisements and for service of notice on the Reserve Bank of India and the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies, West Bengal. It appears that the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies thereafter filed an affidavit-in-opposition in answer to this application and also appeared at the hearing of the application and opposed the application but on the 25th January, 1955 this Court made an order confirming the said alteration. A certified copy of this order was duly filed with the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies as required under the provisions of the Indian Companies Act and it appears that on the 29th May, 1958, the registration was effected by the Registrar of Joint Stock Companies. The alterations that were confirmed by the order were inter alia as follows:"1. That the object clauses in the Memorandum of Association of the Company be and are, hereby altered and/or modified as follows: a. Sub-clauses b, g, h, k, n and o of Clause 3 be deleted. B. The following be added in Clause 3 as Sub-clauses b, c, d and e. (b) To borrow or to take deposit of money on interest or otherwise and either with or without security from any person or persons, local authorities, Government and
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.