SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1992 Supreme(Cal) 374

High Court Of Calcutta
J. N. HORE
AMIRUDDIN ALI ALIAS, AMIRUDDIN MONDAL - Appellant
Versus
KALI BALA BHUNIA - Respondent
Appellate Decree 1393  Of  1969
Decided On : 09/17/1992

Important Points

A transaction induced by fraudulent misrepresentation as to the character of the document is void, while a transaction induced by fraudulent misrepresentation as to the contents of the document is merely voidable.

Subject

Contract Law - FRAUD AND MISREPRESENTATION

Act Referred

EVIDENCE ACT : S.111, S.105

Headnote

FRAUDULENT MISREPRESENTATION - EXECUTION OF DOCUMENT - VOID TRANSACTION - BURDEN OF PROOF - VOIDABLE TRANSACTION - DISTINCTION - VOID AB INITIO - SALE DEED - POWER OF ATTORNEY - PARDANASHIN LADY - PROTECTION - ILLITERATE VILLAGE WOMAN - PROTECTION - ONUS OF PROOF - SHIFTING OF ONUS - VALIDITY OF DOCUMENT - CONSCIOUS AND INTELLIGENT EXECUTION - KNOWLEDGE OF CONTENTS - FRAUDULENT MISREPRESENTATION AS TO NATURE AND CONTENTS - VOID TRANSACTION - VOIDABLE TRANSACTION - DISTINCTION.

Fact of the Case:

Plaintiff, an illiterate village widow, executed a sale deed in favor of the defendant, claiming that she was fraudulently misled into believing it was a power of attorney. She filed a suit for a declaration that the sale deed was void and for an injunction restraining the defendant from interfering with her possession of the suit land.

Finding of the Court:

The trial court and the lower appellate court found that the plaintiff was not aware of the true nature of the document and that it was not her conscious and intelligent execution. They held that the sale deed was void and not binding on the plaintiff.

Issues: 1. Whether the onus of proof lies on the defendant to prove that the execution of the sale deed was the conscious and intelligent act of the plaintiff, an illiterate village woman? 2. Whether a transaction induced by fraudulent misrepresentation as to the character of the document is void or voidable?

Ratio Decidendi: 1. The court held that the onus of proof lies on the defendant to prove that the execution of the sale deed was the conscious and intelligent act of the plaintiff, an illiterate village woman. The court relied on the principle that a transaction entered into with a pardanashin lady or an illiterate village woman is presumed to be voidable, and the burden of proof lies on the person who seeks to sustain the transaction to prove that it was executed with full knowledge and understanding of the nature of the transaction. 2. The court held that a transaction induced by fraudulent misrepresentation as to the character of the document is void, while a transaction induced by fraudulent misrepresentation as to the contents of the document is merely voidable. In the instant case, the court found that there was fraudulent misrepresentation both with regard to the nature and contents of the document, and therefore the sale deed was void ab initio and not binding on the plaintiff.

Final Decision: The appeal was dismissed with costs, and the judgment and decree of the lower appellate court were affirmed.

Advocates Appeared:
HIMANSHU KUMAR BASU, MINAL KANTI ROY

J. N. HORE, J.

( 1 ) THIS appeal is directed against the judgment and decree passed by the learned Subordinate Judge, First Court, Midnapore dated 23. 8. 68 in Title Appeal No. 674/67 affirming those of the learned Munsif, 3rd Court, Midnapore in Title Suit No. 162/67.

( 2 ) THE plaintiff/respondent Smt. Kalibala Bhunia instituted the said Title Suit No. 162/62 against the defendant/appellant for a declaration that the Kobala executed by her in favour of the defendant on 28. 1. 64 is a void document without consideration and not binding on the plaintiff and for permanent injunction restraining the defendant from interfering with the plaintiff's possession in respect of the suit land. Admittedly, the disputed property belonged to the husband of the plaintiff who died in 1367 B. S. leaving the plaintiff and a daughter named Gita Rani as his heirs. The plaintiff gave her daughter Gita Rani in marriage with one Haripada Sur. To meet the expenses of such marriage the plaintiff on behalf of herself and as guardian of her minor daughter sold some properties to her husband's elder brother. She also gave some properties by way of gift to her son-in-law Haripada as dowry for the marriage. Thereafter, her daughter died childless and the plaintiff inherited her share. It was alleged that after her daughter's death, her son-in-law and his father put pressure upon the plaintiff for executing a deed of gift in favour of her son-in-law Haripada but the plaintiff refused to accede to such demand. Plaintiff's husband's brother and her son-in-law then influenced plaintiff's bargadars to deliver meager quantity of paddy to the plaintiff as her share. Placed in such a predicament, the plaintiff sought for the assistance of her neighbour Khandu Singh who was then working as a labourer under defendant's father. Khandu introduced the plaintiff to the defendant who asked the plaintiff to execute and register a power of attorney in his favour for enabling him to look after her property and the plaintiff agreed to it. It was further alleged that on 21. 8. 64 the defendant got a kobala executed and registered by the plaintiff in respect of the suit land upon a fraudulent misrepresentation that the deed was a power of attorney and in that year the defendant realised plaintiff's share of bhag produce from the bargadars and delivered the same to her. Next year the defendant did not deliver her full share of the bhag crops and the plaintiff subsequently came to learn that the defendant surreptitiously procured a sale-deed from her under misrepresentation that the deed executed by her was a power of attorney. It was the case of the plaintiff that she executed the impugned sale deed on 21. 8. 84 under the impression that it was a power of attorney as misrepresented by the defendant and was not aware about the real nature of the document executed by her. It was not her conscious mental act and the sale deed was not binding on her.

( 3 ) THE defendant contented the suit by filing a written statement alleging that the impugned sale deed was executed by the plaintiff with full knowledge of its contents. The recitals in the sale deed were read over and explained to her and she understood the contents thereof. It was her conscious mental act and no fraud was practiced upon her in the matter of the execution of the sale deed. The kobala was executed by the plaintiff for repayment of debts incurred by her in connection with her daughter's marriage and sradh ceremony of her daughter. The further defence case was that subsequent to the execution of the kobala the defendant was in khas possession of a portion of the suit land and he was in possession of the remaining portion through bargadars.

( 4 ) UPON consideration of the evidence in detail the learned Munsif held that the recitals of the document were not read over and explained to the plaintiff before execution of the document by putting her thumb impression and that it was not a conscious and intelligent execut





1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top