SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2004 Supreme(Cal) 746

High Court Of Calcutta
P. N. SINHA
PAWAN KUMAR SANTHALIA SI - Appellant
Versus
STATE OF WEST BENGAL - Respondent
C. R. R.  2206  Of  2003
Decided On : 12/01/2004

Important Points

A Magistrate is empowered to direct further investigation and is not bound to accept the report submitted by police, if the learned magistrate finds that there were defects in the investigation and there is scope of further investigation.

Subject

Criminal Law - Investigation

Act Referred

CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE : S.173(8), S.482, S.397, S.200, S.401, S.173(2)
INDIAN PENAL CODE : S.182, S.363, S.211, S.365, S.34

Headnote

CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE - SECTION 173 (8) - FURTHER INVESTIGATION - ADOPTION - VALIDITY - JURISDICTION - MAGISTRATE'S POWER - INVESTIGATION STAGE - ALIBI OF ACCUSED - ESSENTIAL CONDITIONS - CUSTODY OF MINOR INDIAN BOY TAKEN AWAY - RECOVERY OF MINOR BOY - SCOPE OF FURTHER INVESTIGATION - REVISIONAL POWERS OF HIGH COURT - INTERFERENCE - GUIDELINES FOR FURTHER INVESTIGATION.

Fact of the Case:

Petitioners filed a revisional application under sections 397/401 read with section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code, challenging the order of the learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate (SDJM), Malda, directing the Superintendent of Police (SP), Malda, for further investigation into the case and rejecting the prayer of the Investigating Officer (IO) to accord permission to initiate a proceeding under section 182/211 of the Indian Penal Code against the de facto complainant and also praying for quashing the criminal proceeding being G. R. Case No. 1604/97.

Finding of the Court:

1. The order of the learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate giving direction for reinvestigation is bad in law as the term 'reinvestigation' implies initiation of investigation from the inception, whereas the term 'further investigation' implies continuation of previous investigation. 2. A Magistrate is empowered to direct further investigation and is not bound to accept the report submitted by police, if the learned magistrate finds that there were defects in the investigation and there is scope of further investigation. 3. The story of adoption of Pankaj Santhalia by the accused Arjun Santhalia and his wife has been affirmed by the Hon'ble Supreme court of Bangladesh. After such order affirming adoption of Pankaj santhalia, the story of kidnapping of the said minor introduced by de facto complainant is absolutely unbelievable. 4. The learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate has jurisdiction either to accept the report in final form submitted by police or not to accept the same and if he finds that there is scope of further investigation he is empowered to direct further investigation. 5. Learned Sub-Divisional Judicial magistrate, Malda has jurisdiction to direct further investigation when the incident of kidnapping was within Kaliachak P. S. area in the District of Malda. 6. The kidnapped boy has not yet been recovered. Instead of recovering the kidnapped boy, the I. O. sought for permission to initiate proceeding against the de facto complainant under section 211 Indian Penal Code, which action was bad in law and shows that investigation was not done properly. 7. Order for further investigation was proper and valid as the learned Magistrate has jurisdiction to direct further investigation. 8. The said order being interlocutory order and no revision lies against that order. 9. The judgment of the Supreme Court of Bangladesh cannot be a bar in the matter of investigation into the story depicted in the first Information Report. 10. The I. O. acted illegally by relying upon the story of adoption as he was not entrusted with the duty of investigation of adoption of the minor boy. 11. The story of adoption whether acceptable or not or, whether there was valid adoption or not are to be considered by the Court during trial on the basis of evidence and not during the stage of investigation. 12. The learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate by his impugned order dated 4. 9. 03 discussed the entire matter elaborately and considered all aspects. 13. It is clear that in the instant matter investigation was not proper and the I. Os misdirected themselves into the matter of investigation and erroneously submitted final report. 14. During the stage of naraji petition and before taking cognizance learned Magistrate is not bound to hear the accused. 15. Accordingly, after receiving a report in final form from police officer after investigation, if a Magistrate considering the entire matter and applying his mind decides that investigation so far made was not proper, he had every authority to direct further investigation. 16. The impugned order cannot be regarded as without jurisdiction and the learned magistrate rightly passed the order for further investigation. 17. This is not a fit case at all to quash the impugned proceeding being G. R. Case No. 1604 of 97 arising out of kaliachak P. S. Case No. 206 dated 4. 12. 97. 18. The order of learned Sub-Divisional judicial Magistrate, Malda directing further investigation into the case being correct, proper and legal requires no interference.

Issues: None

Ratio Decidendi: 1. The term 'reinvestigation' implies initiation of investigation from the inception, whereas the term 'further investigation' implies continuation of previous investigation. 2. A Magistrate is empowered to direct further investigation and is not bound to accept the report submitted by police, if the learned magistrate finds that there were defects in the investigation and there is scope of further investigation. 3. The story of adoption of Pankaj Santhalia by the accused Arjun Santhalia and his wife has been affirmed by the Hon'ble Supreme court of Bangladesh. After such order affirming adoption of Pankaj santhalia, the story of kidnapping of the said minor introduced by de facto complainant is absolutely unbelievable. 4. The order for further investigation was proper and valid as the learned Magistrate has jurisdiction to direct further investigation. 5. The said order being interlocutory order and no revision lies against that order. 6. The judgment of the Supreme Court of Bangladesh cannot be a bar in the matter of investigation into the story depicted in the first Information Report. 7. The I. O. acted illegally by relying upon the story of adoption as he was not entrusted with the duty of investigation of adoption of the minor boy. 8. The story of adoption whether acceptable or not or, whether there was valid adoption or not are to be considered by the Court during trial on the basis of evidence and not during the stage of investigation.

Final Decision: The revisional application is accordingly disposed of in the light of observations made above.

Advocates Appeared:
MILON MUKHARJI, S.PARMER, SANDIPAN GANGULY, Sk.Kasem Ali Ahmed, SUBHAJIT DAN, SUDIPTA MOITRA

P. N. SINHA, J.

( 1 ) THIS revlsional application has been preferred by the petitioners under sections 397/401 read with section 482 of criminal Procedure Code praying for setting aside the order dated 4. 9. 03 passed by the learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate (in short SDJM), Malda in G. R. Case No. 1604 of 1997 arising out of kaliachak P. S. Case No. 206 dated 4. 12. 97 thereby directing the superintendent of Police (in short S. P.), Malda for further investigation into the said case and rejecting FRT No. 21 dated 14. 2. 03 and also rejecting prayer of the Investigating Officer (in short i. O.) to accord permission to initiate a proceeding under section 182/ 211 of the Indian Penal Code (in short I. P. C.) against the de facto complainant and also praying for quashing the criminal proceeding being G. R. Case No. 1604/97.

( 2 ) THE facts of the case as it transpires from the revisional application is that Bina Devi Santhalia, the opposite party No. 2 filed a complaint in the Court of the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate (in short CJM), Malda on 4. 12. 97 praying for sending the petition of complaint to O. C. , Kaliachak P. S. for investigation under section 156 (3) of Cr. P. C. and the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate duly forwarded the complaint to O. C. , Kaliachak P. S. for investigation and on the basis of such complaint/first Information Report Kaliachak p. S. Case No. 206 dated 4. 12. 97 under sections 363/ 365/ 34 of I. P. C. was started against the accused persons including the present petitioners. The allegations made in the First Information Report by opposite party No. 2 Bina Devi Santhalia was that, on 15. 12. 96 there was a ceremony in the house of Kailash Agarwal to celebrate birth of his son and opposite party No. 2 along with her minor son Pankaj kumar, aged about five years, attended the said ceremony. Bina Devi was talking with her relatives who assembled in the said ceremony and at about 1 P. M. she found her son absent and she started searching for her son. Subsequently, she learnt from some persons that the accused persons including the petitioners had taken away her son keeping her busy talking to other relatives. There was a rivalry between accused persons and husband of Bina Devi Santhalia and in order to teach a lesson to her husband, the accused persons kidnapped her minor son Pankaj. She earlier lodged written complaint at Kaliachak P. S. on 17. 12. 96 but, the police officers reduced it into g. D. Entry No. 706 dated 17. 12. 96 and did not take any step for investigation or for the recovery of the kidnapped minor son of complainant. Thereafter, she lodged the complaint before the learned chief Judicial Magistrate on 4. 12. 97 which was sent to the O. C. , kaliachak P. S. for investigation and accordingly the aforesaid kaliachak P. S. Case was started.

( 3 ) THE petitioners thereafter obtained anticipatory bail and after surrendering before learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate they were enlarged on regular bail. Subsequently C. I. D. , West Bengal took up investigation and after completing investigation the Investigating officer (in short I. O.) submitted final report No. 88 dated 27. 4. 01. The learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate after considering the materials on record by his order dated 30. 5. 02 directed further investigation into the matter. Thereafter, investigation was made for the second time by different I. O. and the second I. O. also submitted report in final form vide final report No. 21 dated 14. 02. 03 and also submitted a prayer before the learned Sub-Divisional Judicial magistrate to accord sanction to initiate a criminal proceeding under sections 182/211 of Indian Penal Code against the complainant. The complainant Bina Devi filed a naraji petition against the said second final report. The accused persons also filed an application against the naraji petition. The learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate, malda after considering the materials on record by

























1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top