2019 Supreme(Cal) 882
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT CALCUTTA
Sanjib Banerjee, Jay Sengupta, JJ.
Smt. Jyotsna Das - Appellant
Vs.
Sailendra Nath Paul - Respondent
SAT 18 of 2019
Decided On : 27-06-2019
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Appeals and Cross-objections
Act Referred
WEST BENGAL PREMISES TENANCY ACT : S.2(g)
Headnote
Cross-objection - Suit Maintainability - West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997 - Order XIV Rule 2(1) of the Code - Section 2(g) of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997 - Order XLI Rule 22 of the Code
Fact of the Case:
The suit was filed against the widow of the deceased original tenant for eviction. The trial court found the suit not maintainable due to the original tenant being survived by other heirs who had not been impleaded. The first appellate court reversed the finding on maintainability, but the defendant did not challenge the decision on the issue of reasonable requirement. The plaintiff contended that the defendant should have filed a cross-objection within the period of limitation to challenge the finding on the issue of reasonable requirement.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the defendant's failure to challenge the finding on the issue of reasonable requirement before the first appellate court precluded her from raising the ground for the first time in the second appeal. The judgment and decree obtained by the plaintiff were left undisturbed.
Issues: The main issue was whether the defendant, not aggrieved by the decree of the trial court, was obliged to file a cross-objection against any finding rendered on an issue against such party by the trial court in any other party’s appeal for the decision on the relevant issue to be reversed.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that a party not aggrieved by the decree but aggrieved by a finding on an issue may challenge the finding without filing a cross-objection. However, if a party intends to challenge any part of the decree, a cross-objection must be filed within the period of limitation.
Final Decision: The judgment and decree obtained by the plaintiff were left undisturbed.
For the Appellant : Mr. Partha Pratim Roy
For the Respondent: Mr. Aniruddha Chatterjee, Mr. Saptarshi Kumar Mal
JUDGMENT :
1. The principal question of law which is sought to be raised in this second appeal is whether a party who is not aggrieved by the decree of the trial court is obliged to file a cross-objection against any finding rendered on an issue against such party by the trial court in any other party’s appeal for the decision on the relevant issue to be reversed.
2. Following a written notice issued to the widow of the deceased original tenant, a suit was instituted against such widow for eviction. An objection was taken by the defendant, who seeks to prefer the present second appeal, that the suit was not maintainable since the original tenant was survived by other heirs who had not been impleaded in the suit. The trial court found the suit not to be maintainable on such ground. However, in consonance with the somewhat strange command of Order XIV Rule 2(1) of the Code, despite the trial court holding that the suit was not maintainable, it proceeded to address the other issues, including the one as to whether the plaintiff was entitled to possession on the ground of reasonable requirement. Quite surprisingly, the issue was answered in favour of the plaintiff and in a rather cursory manner.
3. The plaintiff preferred an appeal against the dismissal of the suit. No cross objection was filed by the defendant who is the would-be second appellant. On the maintainability of the suit, the respondent-landlord asserted before the first appellate court that in view of Section 2(g) of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997, the landlord was obliged only to implead the widow of the original tenant as a party to the eviction suit since the other heirs of the original tenant had either surrendered their rights in favour of the widow or the other heirs had no further right to continue in possession of the tenanted premises. The first appellate court agreed with the landlord. The defendant-widow does not challenge such finding of the first appellate court.
4. However, the defendant submits that notwithstanding the first appellate court having reversed the finding on the issue as to the maintainability of the suit, it was incumbent on the first appellate court to look into the grounds for eviction made out and permit the defendant to urge that the decision of the trial court on the relevant issue was erroneous before disposing of the appeal.
6. The defendant takes particular objection to what is recorded at paragraph 7 of the appellate judgment:
“(7) It appears from the case record that Ld. Trial Court decided issue No.3 (Whether the instant suit is barred by any principles of law), issue No.4 (Whether the notice to quit dt.23.05.2012 is legal, valid and sufficient and it has been served properly to the defendant) and issue No.6 (Whether the plaintiff reasonably requires the suit property for self and for use of his family members) in favour of the plaintiff. No cross appeal has been preferred from the side of defendant/respondent challenging the observation of Ld. Trial Court in respect of issues No.3, 4 & 6. In the decision reported in (2017) 2 Supreme Court Cases (Civ) 241 (Laxman & others Vs G. Ayyasamy) it has been held that in the absence of an independent appeal or cross-objection being filed by the aggrieved party in respect of the relief concerned, the relief which was denied by the courts below cannot be granted in 2nd appeal filed by the appellant. So, I do not find any reason for interference with the observation of the Ld. Trial Court in respect of issues No.3, 4 & 6.”
7. Though it is evident from paragraph 7 of the appellate judgment sought to be assailed herein that the first appellate court thought that the issue as to reasonable requirement could not be reopened in the absence of any cross-objection being taken by the defendant, it does not appear from the grounds taken in the second appeal or from the recording of what transpired before the first appellate court in the impugned judgment that any attempt was made by the defenda