SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2019 Supreme(Chh) 233

IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
SANJAY K AGRAWAL, J.
BACHCHI DEVI - Appellant
Versus
RADHESHYAM GUPTA (DEAD) THROUGH LRS - Respondent
Second Appeal No. 65 of 2003
Decided on : 05-03-2019

Subject

Contract Law - Void and Voidable Contracts

Act Referred

CONTRACT ACT : S.19, S.17
LIMITATION ACT : Art.95

Headnote

Indian Contract Act, 1872 - Section 19 - Suit to be barred - Null and void - Registered deed of sale - Whether Courts below were justified in holding that plaintiffs are not entitled to get alleged registered deed of sale - Suit property was originally held by - He had two sons and one daughter respectively executed sale deed in favor of defendant No.1 and died On - Original plaintiff - He had filed suit for setting aside the sale deed executed by in favor of defendant No.1 on the ground that sale deed was obtained by fraud as was taken for treatment and got sale deed executed fraudulently - Defendant No.1 filed his written statement denying and opposing plaint allegations and stated that the sale deed was executed for legal necessity and it is in accordance with law - Held, Lapse of time is not of itself a bar to setting aside a contract but may be material as evidence of acquiescence that is, of tacit election to affirm the contract was as stated, seriously ill therefore he could not challenge despite noticed the fraud played with him, as such same will not bar plaintiff to question said sale deed after death of being successor-in-interest - As such judgments & decrees of both Courts below to extent of issue No.3(b) holding that the sale deed is only voidable, is set aside and sale deed executed is held to be void and sale deed being void is accordingly set aside - Judgments and decrees of both the Courts below to that extent are set aside and it is decreed that sale deed - Second appeal is allowed

Advocates:
Advocate Appeared:
Ashok Kumar Shukla, Adv., Atanu Ghosh, Adv., H.B. Agrawal, Adv., Prabha Sharma, Adv., Meha Kumar, Adv.

JUDGMENT :

SANJAY K AGRAWAL, J.

1. This plaintiffs' second appeal was admitted for hearing on the following substantial question of law: -

"Whether the Courts below were justified in holding that the plaintiffs are not entitled to get the alleged registered deed of sale, dated 29.10.1975 (Exhibit D/1) as null and void as its executor Chunnilal has failed to assail the same during his lifetime despite knowing the fact that it was not validly executed?"

(Parties hereinafter will be referred as per their status shown and ranking given in the plaint before the trial Court.)

2. The suit property was originally held by Jaina. He had two sons and one daughter namely Sonsai, Chunnilal and Nanki, respectively. Chunnilal executed sale deed dated 29-10-1975 in favour of defendant No.1 and died on 22-1-1976. The original plaintiff was Sonsai (died during the pendency of suit). He had filed suit for setting aside the sale deed executed by Chunnilal in favour of defendant No.1 on the ground that the sale deed was obtained by fraud, as Chunnilal was taken for treatment and got the sale deed executed fraudulently. Defendant No.1 filed his written statement denying and opposing the plaint allegations and stated that the sale deed was executed for legal necessity and it is in accordance with law. The trial Court after appreciating oral and documentary evidence on record, came to the conclusion that the suit land was jointly owned by plaintiff Sonsai, Chunnilal and defendant No.2 Nanki; and the plaintiff has ?rd share, defendant No.2 Nanki has ?rd share and Chunnilal has also ?rd share in the suit property. Chunnilal had no legal necessity to sell the suit land of his share and the sale deed was executed on 29-10-1975 fraudulently, but the sale deed cannot be set aside by virtue of the provisions contained in Section 19 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, as though Chunnilal was aware of the fraudulent act, but he did not challenge the sale deed during his lifetime and the plaintiff cannot question the validity of the sale deed and also held that Bharos and Vanshgopal were also necessary party. On appeal being preferred by the plaintiffs, the first appellate Court maintained the finding of the trial Court with regard to the fact that the plaintiffs cannot question the sale deed being third party / strangers, but set aside the finding with regard to necessary party and non-impleadment of the State as party defendant in the suit against which this second appeal has been filed in which substantial question of law has been formulated and which has been set-out in the opening paragraph of the judgment.

3. Mr. Ashok Kumar Shukla, learned counsel appearing for the appellants / plaintiffs, would submit that both the Courts below have concurrently committed grave legal error in holding that the plaintiffs are like strangers / third party to question the sale deed dated 29-10-1975 (Ex.D-1). He would further submit that in the suit property the plaintiff had also undivided share and since the sale deed was obtained by fraud as concurrently recorded by both the Courts below, the Courts below committed legal error by dismissing the suit being hit by Section 19 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, therefore, the sale deed be declared null and void by granting the appeal and by setting aside the concurrent finding of the two Courts below with regard to issue No.3(b).

4. Mr. H.B. Agrawal, learned Senior Advocate appearing for LRs of the original defendant No.1 / respondents No.1(a) to (c) herein, would support the impugned judgment & decree and submit that Chunnilal had right to alienate his undivided share of the suit property and that was for legal necessity as he was ill and money was required for his treatment, as such, both the Courts below have rightly held the suit to be barred by Section 19 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872.

5. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and considered their rival submissions made herein-above and also went through the records with




















































1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top