2020 Supreme(Chh) 359
IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Sanjay K. Agrawal, J.
Kheduram Sahu (died)and Others - Appellant
Versus
Agasiya Bai Sahu & Ors. - Respondent
Second Appeal No. 257 of 2007
Decided On : 16-03-2020
Important Points
Subject
Property Law - Ancestral Property and Partition
Act Referred
HINDU SUCCESSION ACT : S.6, S.8, S.4, S.19
LAND REVENUE CODE : S.178, S.44
Headnote
Ancestral Property - Property Partition - Land Revenue Code, 1959 - Hindu Succession Act, 1956 - [Section 178 of Land Revenue Code, 1959, Section 44 of Land Revenue Code, 1959, Explanation 1 of Section 6 of Hindu Succession Act, 1956]
Fact of the Case:
The plaintiff filed a suit for declaration of title and partition of ancestral property. The trial court held the property as ancestral, but the first appellate court reversed the decision, holding it as self-acquired property. The plaintiff appealed, questioning the finding and the refusal of partition.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the property was ancestral in nature and entitled the plaintiff to a share as per the Hindu Succession Act, 1956. The court also held that the first appellate court's decision was unjustified and modified the judgment and decree of both lower courts.
Issues: The main issues were the nature of the property (ancestral or self-acquired) and the entitlement to partition among the parties.
Ratio Decidendi: The court relied on the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, and the Land Revenue Code, 1959 to determine the nature of the property and the entitlement to partition. It emphasized the principles of ancestral property and succession under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.
Final Decision: The second appeal was allowed, and the judgment and decree of both lower courts were modified to grant the plaintiff a share in the ancestral property and order partition among the parties.
Mr. Shashi Bhushan Tiwari, Advocate, for the Appellant; Mr. H.S. Patel, Advocate, Mr. Ravi Bhagat, Dy. Government Advocate, for the Respondent
JUDGMENT
1. This second appeal preferred by the appellants/LRs. of original plaintiff Kheduram Sahu was admitted for hearing on the following substantial questions of law :
''1. Whether the finding recorded by the first appellate Court that the suit land Schedule ''A'' was the selfacquired property of Phool Singh ?
2. Whether the Courts below have committed error of law by refusing decree of partition between the parties when the plaintiff as well as defendants No. 1 & 2 have claimed decree for partition ?''
(For the sake of convenience, parties would be referred hereinafter as per their status and ranking shown in the suit before the trial Court.)
2. The following genealogical tree would demonstrate the relationship among the parties :
3. Sukhram had four sons namely Milau, Phoolsingh, Banaram and Sadaram. Phoolsingh had one son namely Kheduram who is the plaintiff and two daughters namely Agasiya who is defendant No. 1 and Khediya who died leaving behind her daughter Neminbai who is defendant No. 2.
4. Plaintiff Kheduram filed a suit for declaration of title and in alternative partition and possession stating inter alia that the suit land shown in Schedule ''A'' annexed with the plaint was originally held by his grandfather Sukhram and Sukhram''s brother Sukham and his wife Anariyabai. Sukham and Anariyabai died issueless and after the death of Sukhram, Sukham and his wife Anariyabai, the said suit land was inherited by the four sons of Sukhram and partition took place amongst them in which the suit land shown in Schedule ''A'' fell in the share of plaintiff''s father Phoolsingh, as such, the suit land was the ancestral property of Phoolsingh. After the death of Phoolsingh, the names of all three of his children i.e. Kheduram, Khediya and Agasiya were jointly recorded in the revenue records as the three of them were coowners of the suit land. The said suit land shown in Schedule ''A'' was later on orally partitioned amongst the plaintiff and defendants No. 1 and 2, yet the revenue records continued to be in the joint names of all three of them which persuaded defendants No. 1 and 2 to file an application under Section 178 of the Land Revenue Code, 1959 wherein Tahsildar, Kawardha, by its order dated 30/08/2001, directed that plaintiff along with defendants No. 1 and 2, each of them is entitled to get 1/3 rd share in the suit land against which plaintiff preferred an appeal under Section 44 of the Land Revenue Code, 1959 wherein the Subdivisional Officer, Kawardha, by its order dated 01/05/2002, dismissed the appeal by affirming the order of the Tahsildar. Thereafter, defendants No. 1 and 2 sold some part of the suit land to defendants No. 3, 4 and 5 by various sale deeds whereas both defendants No. 1 and 2 had no right title to alienate part of the suit land in favour of defendants No. 3, 4 and 5. It was further pleaded that the exclusive title of plaintiff is not found then partition be directed amongst the parties as per explanation 1 of Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.
5. Defendants opposed the plaint allegations by setting up a plea that since Sukham and his wife Anariya were issueless, they adopted Phoolsingh, as such, suit land was the selfacquired property of Phoolsingh. Defendants No. 1 and 2 also filed a counterclaim for partition and possession stating that each of them are entitled for 1/3 rd share in the suit land.
6. Learned trial Court, upon consideration of oral and documentary evidence on record, vide its judgment and decree dated 24/07/2006, dismissed the suit as well as the counterclaim though held that the suit property shown in Schedule ''A'' was the ancestral property of Phoolsingh.
7. On appeal being preferred by the plaintiff and crossobjection preferred by the defendants, learned first appellate Court, vide its judgment and decree dated 28/04/2007, though interfered with the finding of the trial Court with respect to issues No. 5 and 10 and held that suit land was the selfacquired property