SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

1997 Supreme(Del) 807

High Court Of Delhi
SAHARA INDIA AIRLINES LIMITED - Appellant
Versus
R.A.SINGH - Respondent
First Appeal (OS) 74 of 1997
Decided On : 09/24/1997

Advocates Appeared:
ARCHANA MALIK, GITA MITTAL, NILIMA TRIPATHI, P.P.TRIPATHI, R.K.SINGHAL

Headnote:Civil Procedure Code 1908 - Section 149 — Deficiency of Court fee — Making of — Powers of Court — Exercise of — Discretion of — Granted exemption of Court Fee — Pilot died in Air Crash — Suit — Requisite Court fee not paid — Learned Single Judge granted exemption from paying of — Also held that in case plaintiff succeeds will pay Court fee from the decretal amount — Appealed against — Not indigent person — Got ex-gratia — Can only postpone and cannot grant exemption from — Appeal maintainable — Exemption quashed — Appeal allowed.

       Held:

       We are of the considered view that Section 149, C.P.C. does not empower the Court to pass an order exempting the plaintiffs from payment of requisite Court fee and directing that on the success of the plaintiffs the requisite balance of Court fee be deducted from the decretal amount. Such a power can be found only where Order XXXIII C.P.C. applies and nowhere else.

       Delhi High Court Act - Section 10 — Appeal against grant of exemption of Court fee — Ambit — Ld. Single held that in case plaintiff succeeds will pay Court fee from decretal amount — Appealed against plaintiff/respondent contended — Appeal not maintainable — Appeal raises an important question of law — Exemption quashed — Appeal maintainable — Appeal allowed.

       The impugned order in the present appeal clearly falls within the ambit of the law laid down by the Supreme Court. thereforee, in our view the appeal is maintainable. Besides this the appeal raises an important question of law.

Arun Kumar, J.

( 1 ) THIS is an appeal against an order dated 14th May 1996 passed by a learned Single Judge of this Court granting exemption to the plaintiffs from paying Court fee and directing that in case the plaintiffs succeed in the suit they will pay Court fee from the decretal amount. This order was reiterated by the same learned Single Judge on 6th February 1997 observing that it merely postponed the date for making good the deficiency of Court fee. It was further observed that the payment of Court fee is a matter between the State and the litigant and the defendant cannot have any valid grievance on account of non-payment of Court fee by the plaintiff.

( 2 ) BRIEFLY the facts are that the plaintiffs in the suit (respondents herein) are the parents of a youngman named Pramod Singh who was employed as a pilot with the defendant in the suit, i. e. the appellants in this appeal (hereinafter the parties will be REFERRED TO to as plaintiffs and defendants as in the original suit ). Pramod Singh, son of the plaintiffs was put on a training flight on 8th March 1994 alongwith two other pilots. During the course of the training flight the aircraft allegedly went out of control and crashed. Pramod Singh received fatal injuries in the incident. The other two trainee pilots as well as the instructor also died in the said accident. There were some other casualties also. The plaintiffs filed the present suit for recovery of Rs. 83,32,800. 00 against the defendant on account of the sad death of their son Pramod Singh. As per the provisions of Court fees Act and the Schedule appended thereto as applicable to Delhi, the requisite Court fee on the plaint according to the plaintiffs worked out to Rs. 83,795. 32p. The plaintiffs stated in the plaint that they did not have sufficient funds to deposit the Court fee and they deposited a sum of Rs. 21,864. 80p. only towards Court fee on the plaint and filed an application for exemption from payment of Court fee. The application which was filed alongwith the plaint for this purpose was registered as I. A. No. 3251/96. The application purports to be under Section 94 read with Section 151, Code of Civil Procedure. In the application the plaintiffs admitted receipt of a `small sum towards interim relief from the defendant. The plaintiffs further stated in the said application that they have no source of income to enable them to pay the entire amount payable as Court fee. In para 6 of the application the plaintiffs stated that on account of lack of means to pay the requisite Court fee, the plaintiffs had affixed Court fee of Rs. 21,865. 00 on the plaint. They repeated that they do not have the means to pay the balance Court fee of Rs. 61,931. 00 on the plaint. Accordingly the plaintiffs prayed that the Court be pleased to:-

"exempt the plaintiffs from paying the deficient Court fee of Rs. 61,931. 00 on the plaint in the foregoing facts and circumstances. "

( 3 ) THE order impugned in the present appeal was passed by the learned Single Judge on 14th May 1996. The plaintiffs were exempted from paying the balance amount of Court fee subject, however, to the direction that in the event of their success in the suit, they would pay the requisite Court fee from the decretal amount.

( 4 ) THE learned counsel for the appellant has challenged the aforesaid order on the ground that the same is contrary to the law. In support of this submission the learned counsel has invited our attention to the various relevant provisions contained in the Code of Civil Procedure as also in the Court fees Act. It was submitted that a receipt of Rs. one lac from the appellant was not denied by the plaintiffs. The learned counsel for the plaintiffs did not dispute this assertion. In the light of this admission on the part of the plaintiffs it was urged that the plaintiffs could not plead lack of means to pay the requisite Court fee as a ground for seeking exemption to pay the requisite Court fee. Secondly, it was contended tha























Click Here to Read the rest of this document

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top