2012 Supreme(Del) 645
189 (2012) DLT 236
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
VALMIKI AND MEHTA, JJ.
GULAB CHAUDHARY - Appellant
versus
GOVINDER SINGH DAHIYA & ANR. - Respondents
RFA No.465/2010
Decided On : 28th February, 2012
Important Points
Subject
Property Law - Will Dispute
Act Referred
Headnote
Will - Property Dispute - Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 - Section 96 - Limitation Act, 1963 - Article 65 - Indian Succession Act - Section 213 - Specific Relief Act, 1963 - Section 34, 41(e) - [SUMMARY]
Fact of the Case:
The appellant, a daughter, filed a suit for declaration, possession, and injunction with respect to her father's property. The suit was dismissed by the Trial Court, which held that the father had executed a Will bequeathing the property to the respondent. The appellant claimed that the Will was a manipulation by the respondent.
Finding of the Court:
The Court found the suit to be time-barred, as the appellant was aware of the respondent's claim to the property since 1987 but filed the suit in 2006. The Court also held that the suit was actually one for partition and possession, which was time-barred under Article 65 of the Limitation Act. Additionally, the suit was barred under the Specific Relief Act for not claiming proper relief and not being properly valued for court fees and jurisdiction.
Issues: The issues included the validity of the Will, the limitation of the suit, and the nature of the suit filed by the appellant.
Ratio Decidendi: The Court held that the suit was time-barred, and even if the Will was invalid, the suit would still be dismissed. The Court also emphasized that the suit was an attempt to harass the respondent after a long period of inaction.
Final Decision: The appeal was dismissed with costs of `25,000/- imposed on the appellant.
Ms. Deepika, Adv.
Mr. Ajay Dahiya, Adv. for R-1.
1. The challenge by means of this Regular First Appeal (RFA) filed under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) is to the impugned judgment of the Trial Court dated 15.1.2010 dismissing the suit filed by the appellant/plaintiff/sister for declaration, possession and injunction with respect to the property of the father, late Sh. Bhagwan Singh.
2. The appellant/plaintiff in the plaint pleaded that she was the daughter of late Sh. Bhagwan Singh and was entitled to one-fourth share in the suit property bearing no. 6301/1A(2), Kamla Nagar, Delhi. The appellant/plaintiff/sister also prayed for possession of the suit property to the extent of her one-fourth share. Direction was also sought against the defendant no.2/respondent no.2/Municipal Corporation of Delhi to mutate one-fourth share of the property in the name of the appellant/plaintiff, and injunction was prayed for restraining the respondent no.1/defendant no.1 from transferring etc the suit property. The appellant/plaintiff claimed that the father-Bhagwan Singh died on 25.11.1987 leaving behind, besides the appellant/plaintiff-the daughter and the defendant no.1-son, two other daughters namely, Smt. Daya and Smt. Kamla. It was pleaded in the plaint that in 1987, in around the time of death of her father the respondent no.1/defendant no.1 told her of a Will executed in his name by the father. It is pleaded that till 2006, i.e. for 19 years, the appellant/plaintiff took no action because she only came to know in May, 2006 that the Will was a manipulation done by the defendant no.1/respondent no.1. The appellant/plaintiff claimed to have sent the legal notice dated 3.5.2006 and thereafter in the absence of response filed the subject suit.
3. The respondent no.1/defendant no.1contested the suit on two basic grounds. The first was that the suit was barred by limitation and the second was that the respondent no.1/defendant no.1 became the owner of the suit property by virtue of a registered Will dated 20.9.1986 executed by the father, and which was registered with the sub-Registrar at Sonepat, Haryana on 29.9.1986.
4. After completion of pleadings, the Trial Court framed the following issues:
“1. Whether the suit has not been valued for the purpose of court fees and pecuniary jurisdiction? (OPD)
2. Whether the suit is barred by limitation? (OPD)
3. Whether the Will dated 29.9.1986 of late Sh. Bhagwan Dass is genuine as per the pleadings in the Written Statement? If yes, its effect upon the relief for declaration sought for by the plaintiff in the plaint? (OP Parties)
4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the relief of possession as asked for in the plaint? (OPP)
5. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the relief of permanent and mandatory injunction as asked for in the plaint? (OPP)
6. Relief.”
5. The Trial Court held the suit to be within limitation, however, dismissed the suit by holding that the father-late Sh. Bhagwan Singh had executed a Will dated 29.9.1986, Ex.PW2/1, bequeathing the suit property in favour of the respondent no.1/defendant no1. The reasoning of the Trial Court to uphold the Will dated 29.9.1986 is on the basis of following observations:-
“I have given my careful consideration to the aspects raised before me. Firstly the Will in dispute dated 29.9.1986 which is Ex.PW2/1 is a registered document and proved by PW2 is admissible in evidence. Secondly it is not disputed that late Sh. Bhagwan Singh who had executed the Will, was highly qualified having studied in London and was a retired Class-I Gazetted Officer from the Indian Railway Services. Thirdly it has been duly proved by the defendant that both the attesting witnesses namely Mahender Singh S/o Late Sh. Swaroop Singh and Sh. Sukhbir Singh S/o Late Sh. Kali Ram have expired whose death certificate are Ex.DW3/A & Ex.DW3/B have been duly proved by the witness from the Sub Registrar Office (Death & Birth) Sonepat, Haryana. Both the said witnesses were from the same village