SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2015 Supreme(Del) 1967

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
MUKTA GUPTA, J.
RAVINDRA DAYAL – Petitioner
Versus
SHASHI MEHRA – Respondent
RC.REV. 544/2011 and CM No. 23373/2011 (Stay)
Decided on: 07.08.2015

Important Points

The landlord did not need to prove absolute ownership in the proceedings under the Rent Act, and the landlord's requirement to reside in her own premises was a bona fide need.

Subject

Property Law - Landlord-Tenant Disputes

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.14 R.2, O.5 R.5
DELHI RENT CONTROL ACT : S.14(1)(e), S.25(b), S.37(2), S.3(c)
SMALL CAUSE COURTS ACT : S.17

Headnote

Eviction - Landlord-Tenant Relationship - Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958, Section 14(1)(e), Section 25B - The court discussed the ownership of the tenanted premises, the landlord-tenant relationship, and the bona fide requirement of the landlord. The court held that the landlord-tenant relationship stood established based on the unrebutted testimony of the landlord and the admission of the tenant. The court also found that the landlord had proved her ownership of the tenanted premises and her bona fide requirement for the premises. The court applied legal principles from previous judgments to conclude that the landlord did not need to prove absolute ownership in the proceedings under the Rent Act and that the landlord's requirement to reside in her own premises was a bona fide need. The court dismissed the petition and application.

Fact of the Case:

The landlord filed an eviction petition under Section 14(1)(e) of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958, claiming ownership of the tenanted premises and a bona fide requirement for the premises. The tenant disputed the landlord's ownership and the maintainability of the eviction petition.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the landlord-tenant relationship was established based on the landlord's unrebutted testimony and the tenant's admission. The court also found that the landlord had proved her ownership of the tenanted premises and her bona fide requirement for the premises. The court dismissed the petition and application.

Issues: The issues included the landlord-tenant relationship, the landlord's ownership of the tenanted premises, and the landlord's bona fide requirement for the premises.

Ratio Decidendi: The court applied legal principles from previous judgments to conclude that the landlord did not need to prove absolute ownership in the proceedings under the Rent Act and that the landlord's requirement to reside in her own premises was a bona fide need.

Final Decision: The court dismissed the petition and application.

Advocates:
Advocate Appeared:
For the Petitioner:Mr. Nitin Dayal, Advocate.
For the Respondents:Mr. Satish Sahai, Advocate.

JUDGMENT :

1. Aggrieved by the order dated 12th September, 2011 whereby the eviction petition filed by the Respondent Shashi Mehra under Section 14 (1) (e) of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958 (in short “the DRC Act”) read with Section 25B of the DRC Act was allowed after the evidence was led by the parties, the Petitioner Ravindra Dayal prefers the present petition.

2. During the pendency of the proceedings the possession of the tenanted premises has already been taken over by the Respondent Shashi Mehra.

3. In the eviction petition Shashi Mehra stated that she was the owner and landlord of residential flat/premises bearing Municipal No.7A-1 (7A/1) originally part of property No. 7, Bela Road, Civil Lines, Delhi-110054 (in short the “tenanted premises”). The tenanted premises consists of two rooms, store, kitchen, verandah, toilet, a lawn on the ground floor and one room, covered verandah, toilet, stores and terrace on the first floor. It was stated that the tenanted premises being part of property No.7, Bela Road, Civil Lines was owned by Shri Ishwar Dayal, father of Shashi Mehra by virtue of a partition and an award which was made rule of the Court vide judgment and decree dated 27th October, 1972 passed by this Court in Suit No. 302/1972 titled as “Satishwar Dayal vs. Ishwar Dayal and others”. Shri Ishwar Dayal executed a Will dated 18th September, 1974 duly registered with the Sub-Registrar whereby he created a life estate in respect of the property falling to his share, that is, four residential flats including the tenanted premises in favour of his wife Smt. Bhawani Devi @ Kashmiran Rani and after her death the said four residential flats devolved on their four daughters of which the tenanted premises devolved on Shashi Mehra. Ishwar Dayal died in the year 1983 and Smt. Bhawani Devi in the year 1986. Thus on the death of her parents Shashi Mehra became the absolute owner of the tenanted premises. The tenanted premises had been mutated in the name of Shashi Mehra as owner/landlord in the records of the Municipal Corporation of Delhi and photocopy of the Mutation Letter dated 3rd September, 1987, house tax bills and receipts were placed on record. It was stated that Ravindra Dayal, the Petitioner herein became the tenant under Shashi Mehra as he attorned in favour of Shashi Mehra as owner/landlord of the premises and started paying rent to her since 1993. Ravindra Dayal also signed counter foil of the receipts issued to him by Shashi Mehra, photocopies of counterfoils were also placed on record. The tenanted premises was let out only for residential purpose and were being used for residential purpose by Ravindra Dayal wherein he resided along with his family members which included his wife Mohini Dayal, his two sons namely Sachin Dayal and Nitin Dayal, both of whom were major at that time. Ravindra Dayal is an advocate and a member of the Delhi High Court Bar Association and in the directory of the Bar Association his residential address is mentioned as 7A/1, Bela Road, Civil Lines, Delhi, that is, the tenanted premises. Shashi Mehra had been residing along with her husband Bipin Behari Mehra in the adjoining residential flat being 7A-II (7A/2), Bela Road, Civil Lines, Delhi since 1998. The flat where Shashi Mehra was residing is identical to the tenanted premises and consists of the same accommodation. In fact property No.7, Bela Road comprises of the front portion which was sold by Ishwar Dayal to his three sons and four identical flats on the rear portion which were bestowed on the four daughters of Ishwar Dayal. After some time of Shashi Mehra and her husband shifted to the flat No.7A/2 Bela Road, her younger son Atul Mehra and his wife, who were married in the year 1997 also came to reside with them. Thereafter, Atul Mehra son of Shashi Mehra was blessed with two children namely Tanmay Mehra and Aprita Mehra who were also living with them. The tenanted premises and the adjoining flats comprise of three rooms each. Shashi


































1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top