SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2015 Supreme(Del) 3127

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
HIMA KOHLI, J.
SMT MANJU ANAND & ANR – Plaintiffs
Versus
SMT GEETA CHOPRA & ORS – Defendants
CS(OS) 3315/2015 and I.A. 23296-97/2015
Decided On : 04.11.2015

Important Points

Estoppel from questioning inheritance under a will after admitting to the will and giving consent for grant of a succession certificate.

Subject

Property Law - Partition and Succession

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : S.151, O.7 R.11
SUCCESSION ACT : S.372

Headnote

Partition - Succession Certificate - Will - Indian Succession Act - AIR 1968 P& H 108, 1996 III AD (Delhi) 281, 68(1997) DLT 284, 71(1998) DLT 147, AIR 2006 Delhi 148, AIR 2002 Delhi 6 - The court dismissed the suit for partition and declaration, holding that the plaintiffs, who had admitted to the execution of the will and given their consent for grant of a succession certificate, were estopped from questioning the inheritance under the will. The suit was deemed vexatious and dismissed with costs imposed on the plaintiffs.

Fact of the Case:

The plaintiffs sought partition and declaration of a property, claiming it as joint family property, despite admitting to the execution of a will and giving their consent for grant of a succession certificate.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the plaintiffs, having admitted to the will and given their consent for grant of a succession certificate, were estopped from questioning the inheritance under the will. The court also deemed the suit vexatious and dismissed it with costs imposed on the plaintiffs.

Issues: The main issue was whether the plaintiffs, who had admitted to the execution of the will and given their consent for grant of a succession certificate, could claim the property as joint family property and seek partition.

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the plaintiffs, by admitting to the will and giving their consent for grant of a succession certificate, were estopped from questioning the inheritance under the will. The court also relied on precedents to establish that no probate was required for dealing with immovable property in Delhi under certain circumstances.

Final Decision: The court dismissed the suit for partition and declaration, deeming it vexatious, and imposed costs on the plaintiffs.

Advocates Appeared:
Mr. Sunil Agarwal, Advocate

ORDER

1. The present suit has been instituted by two plaintiffs against their sister (defendant no. 1) and deceased brother’s widow and children [defendant no. 2 (a) to (c)], praying inter alia for a decree of partition in respect of premises No.E-29, Rajouri Garden, New Delhi. Further, the plaintiffs seek a decree of declaration for cancellation of the mutation letter dated 22.04.2013, issued by the civic authorities mutating the suit premises in favour of the defendants No.2 (a) and (b) and for declaring the Sale Deed dated 24.03.2015, executed by the defendants No.2(a) and (b) in favour of defendant No.3, as null and void.

2. Brief facts of the case as stated in the plaint are that Shri Mohan Lal Sahni, father of the plaintiff, defendant no. 1 and Lt. Jitender Sahni was the owner of the suit premises, which has been described as his “self-acquired property”. Sh. M.L. Sahni had expired at New Delhi on 21.06.1995, leaving behind four class I heirs, i.e., three daughters, namely, the plaintiffs No.1 and 2, defendant No.1 and Shri Jitender Sahni, [predecessor-in-title of the defendants No.2 (a) to (c)]. Sh. M.L. Sahni’s wife had predeceased her husband, having expired on 21.6.1979. Prior to his demise, Shri M. L. Sahni had executed a will dated 17.12.1993, whereunder he had bequeathed the suit premises in favour of his daughter-in-law and grandson, i.e., defendants No.2 (a) and (b) while authorizing his son, Shri Jitender Sahni to act as a caretaker, till the defendant no. 2(b) would attain majority. Apart from the suit premises, the deceased had bequeathed another immovable property in favour of his son, and all his movable assets jointly in favour of his son and daughter-in-law [defendant no. 2(a)]. It has been specifically stated by the testator in the captioned will that his three daughters, who were already married, had been well provided for by way of dowry given to them at the time of performing their marriages and he did propose to bequeath anything else to them.

3. Based on the aforesaid will, Shri Jitender Sahni and his wife, [defendant No.2(a)] had filed a joint petition under Section 372 of the Indian Succession Act in the trial court for grant of a succession certificate in respect of the debts and securities of late Shri Mohan Lal Sahni, registered as Petition No.831/1995. Initially, the plaintiffs herein, (impleaded as respondent no. 2 and 4 there) and the defendant no. 1 (impleaded as respondent No.3 there) had given their NOC for grant of a succession certificate in favour of the petitioners therein. Subsequently, the plaintiffs did a flip flop and made a statement before the concerned court that they wished to withdraw their consent. Thereafter, the plaintiffs once again turned turtle and moved an application under Section 151 CPC on 12.10.2001, stating inter alia that the earlier statement made by them wanting to withdraw their NOC, was on account of some misunderstanding and now that the said misunderstanding had been clarified, they wished to abide by the no objection given by them for grant of a succession certificate in favour of their brother and sister-in-law.

4. A perusal of the said application filed by the plaintiffs in the petition for grant of a succession certificate and enclosed with the documents filed with the plaint reveals that they had categorically stated in the supporting affidavits that they were withdrawing all the objections raised by them and had given their consent to grant of a succession certificate in favour of their brother and sister-in-law, “of their own free will, without any force, threat and undue influence.” Further, the plaintiffs had confirmed in para 6 of the application that their father had executed the will dated 17.12.1993 during his lifetime and gone on to state that it was a genuine document and could be acted upon. Thereafter, the statement of both the plaintiffs was recorded separately by the learned Administrative Civil Judge on 15.10.2001, and they had reiterated















1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top