SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

NATIONAL CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION
Ashok Bhan, President and Vineeta Rai, Member
NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD. - Appellant
Versus
SHAIK DAWOOD - Respondent
Revision Petition No. 3502 of 2009 from Order dated 1.6.2009 in Appeal No. 1261 of 2006 of State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Andhra Pradesh
Decided on : 21-02-2013

Important Points

The main legal point established in the judgment is that the Insurance Company is not liable to indemnify the loss in the case of own damage of the vehicle unless the policy is transferred in the name of the new owner.

Subject

Insurance Law - Motor Vehicle Insurance

Act Referred

CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT : S.2(1)(g), S.21(b)
MOTOR VEHICLES ACT : S.157

Headnote

Insurance - Transfer of Vehicle Ownership - Motor Vehicles Act, Section 157, GR-10, GR-17 - The court discussed the provisions of Section 157 of the Motor Vehicles Act and GR-10 and GR-17 of the Indian Motor Tariff. It highlighted the requirement for the transferee to inform the Insurance Company about the transfer of the Registration Certificate and the policy to be transferred in the name of the transferee. The court emphasized that unless the policy is transferred in the name of the new owner, the Insurance Company is not liable to indemnify the loss in the case of own damage of the vehicle.

Fact of the Case:

The Respondent purchased a second-hand car insured by the Petitioner Insurance Company. After an accident, the Petitioner repudiated the claim, stating that the policy was not transferred to the Respondent's name.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the Insurance Company was justified in repudiating the claim due to the failure of the Respondent to inform the company about the transfer of the Registration Certificate and the policy not being transferred in the name of the Respondent.

Issues: The main issue was whether the Insurance Company was liable to indemnify the loss in the case of own damage of the vehicle when the policy was not transferred to the new owner's name.

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that unless the policy is transferred in the name of the new owner, the Insurance Company is not liable to pay the claim in the case of own damage of the vehicle.

Final Decision: The court set aside the previous orders and dismissed the complaint, allowing the Revision Petition filed by the Insurance Company.

Advocates Appeared:
Mrs. M. Seetha Devi, Advocate, for the Appellant; Mr. C. Krishna Reddy, Advocate, for the Respondent

ORDER

Ashok Bhan, President - Petitioner Insurance Company which was the Opposite Party before the District Forum has filed this Revision Petition against the order and judgment dated 1.6.2009 passed by the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Andhra Pradesh (in short, the State Commission ) in appeal No. 1261/06 whereby the State Commission reversing the order of the District Forum dismissing the complaint has allowed the appeal and directed the Petitioner to settle the claim of the insurance covered under EX. A1 policy bearing No. 612701/31/03/01454 in respect of the Maruti Zen bearing No. TN 2 H 4230 purchased and owned by the Complainant along with insurance claim with interest @ 9% p.a. thereon from the date of claim till realization. Rs. 5,000 were awarded towards compensation for mental agony and Rs. 2,000 for legal expenses.

Facts:

2. Complainant/Respondent herein purchased a second hand Maruti Zen car bearing No. TN-2H-4230 from one. T. Sundhakar Reddy. The vehicle was insured with the Petitioner Insurance Company under policy bearing No. 612701/31/03/01454 for the period from 16.9.2003 to 15.9.2004. Respondent got the vehicle transferred in his name on 18.2.2004. On 3.6.2004, the vehicle met with an accident and was badly damaged. On receiving the intimation, Petitioner appointed the Surveyor, A.C. Reddy to conduct the survey and assess the loss. Surveyor submitted his report on 13.8.2004 assessing the loss at Rs. 1,60,000 on market value. Later, the vehicle was taken to Maruti Service Station at Nellore for its repairs. Respondent spent a sum of Rs. 2,80,000 towards repairs and Rs. 20,000 towards conveyance charges. In spite of repeated requests made by the Respondent, Petitioner did not settle the claim. Ultimately, vide letter dated 20.1.2005, Petitioner repudiated the claim on the ground that the policy stood in the name of third party and there was no intimation to them about the transfer of the vehicle. Complainant/Respondent, being aggrieved, filed the complaint before the District Forum.

3. Petitioner on service put in appearance and filed its written statement resisting the complaint on the grounds that the Maruti Car was insured by T. Sudhakar Reddy and he did not give any intimation about the transfer of the vehicle; that the policy was issued in the name of T. Sudhakar Reddy and it was not transferred in the name of the Respondent and, therefore, the complaint was not maintainable; that in the absence of transfer of policy, the Petitioner was not liable to indemnify the loss suffered by the Respondent; that there was violation of the provisions of Section 151 of M.V. Act and GR-17 of the Indian Motor Tariff:

4. District Forum dismissed the complaint and referring to certain judgments observed that the insured T. Sudhakar Reddy shall file the claim before the OP, New India Assurance Company as per the policy within the period of six weeks from the date of order of the District Forum and the OP Insurance Company shall consider the same sympathetically basing on the report of the Surveyor and settle the claim as per terms of the policy.

Complainant, being aggrieved, filed the appeal before the State Commission.

5. State Commission, after considering the material available on record and the evidence led by the parties, came to the conclusion that the Insurance Company was not justified in repudiating the claim and allowing the appeal directed the Petitioner to settle the claim of the insurance covered under EX A1 policy bearing No. 612701/31/03/01454 in respect of the Maruti Zen bearing No. TN 2 H 4230 purchased and owned by the Complainant along with insurance claim with interest @ 9% p.a. thereon from the date of claim till realization. Rs. 5,000 were awarded towards compensation for mental agony and Rs. 2,000 for legal expenses.

State Commission observed as under:

"The Hon'ble National Commission in C. Narayana Singh v. New India Assurance Co, Ltd.,(2007) 4 CPJ 289 (NC), made it clear that the insurer ca

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top