2010 Supreme(Gau) 447
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GAUHATI
AMITAVA ROY, J.
Meera Bora – Appellant
Vs.
Hiranath and Ors. – Respondent
CRP No. 217 of 2009
Decided On: 29.06.2010
Subject
Civil Law - Pleadings and Verification
Headnote
Indian Succession Act, 1925 - Sections 280 and 281 - Civil Procedure Code,1908 – Section 99 - Executor of the Will involved - Mandatory requirements - Petitioner, though not executor of Will involved, initially filed a petition for probate under aforementioned legal provision and thereafter sought amendment in averments to condition same to facilitate issuance of a Letter of Administration instead - Will and testament involved is one executed on by since deceased, who was maternal uncle of Petitioner and brother of - Opposite party/Respondents - According to Petitioner, though bequest was in her favour, she was not appointed as executor of Will- Seeking probate she instituted Probate under Section280 of Act - Though Respondent filed their counter in said proceeding and Respondent also entered appearance therein, they did not contest same as such - Petition for probate was in order being in compliance of requirements outlined in relevant provisions of Act – Held, Petitioner as well as her witnesses is on record, same is vis-a-vis for petition for probate and not one for Letter of Administration - It is not case of Petitioner that she had urged before learned Court below to treat petition for probate to be one for application for Letter of Administration - She consciously chose to have petition for probate amended by integrating deletions and substitutions - Though amendments were allowed, she admittedly, failed to verify same as required under of Act amended application cannot be construed to be a wholesome substitute of petition for probate to exempt compliance of - evidence on record, in opinion of this Court is, therefore, of no significance to tilt the balance in favour of Petitioner, her omission as above, notwithstanding - On a totality of considerations hereinabove, this Court therefore, finds itself in agreement, with decision taken by .,learned Court below
Advocate Appeared
For Appellant/Petitioner/Plaintiff: K.K. Mahanta, Sr. Adv., N.K. Kalita and A. Barman, Advs.
For Respondents/Defendant: None
Amitava Roy, J.
1. In challenge is the order dated 28.04.2009 passed by the learned District Judge, Kamrup, Guwahati, in Probate Case No. 344/2007, rejecting the application filed by the present Petitioner for Letters of Administration on the ground that the same being not verified by her, was not in compliance of the mandatory requirements of Section 280 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 (hereafter referred to as the Act).
2. I have heard Mr. K.K. Mahanta, Senior Advocate assisted by Mr. N.K. Kalita and Mr. A. Barman, Advocates for the Petitioner. Inspite of service of notice on the Respondents, none has entered appearance to resist the prayer made herein.
3. The Petitioner, though not the executor of the Will involved, initially filed a petition for probate under the aforementioned legal provision and thereafter sought amendment in the averments to condition the same to facilitate issuance of a Letter of Administration instead. The Will and testament involved is one executed on 10.08.2006 by Kamal Chandra Nath (since deceased), who was the maternal uncle of the Petitioner and the brother of the opposite party/Respondents. According to the Petitioner, though the bequest was in her favour, she was not appointed as the executor of the Will. Seeking probate she instituted Probate Case No. 3447/2007 under Section280 of the Act.
Though the Respondent Nos. 1 & 2 filed their counter in the said proceeding and the Respondent No. 3 also entered appearance therein, they did not contest the same as such. The petition for probate was in order being in compliance of the requirements outlined in the relevant provisions of the Act. On an application for amendment of the petition for probate suitably for issuance of a Letter of Administration, the same was allowed by the learned Court below. Consequently, an amended petition was filed on 08.04.2009. The application for amendment discloses that thereby the Petitioner sought to delete and substitute words and sentences in the original petition for probate and also to replace the prayer made therein by one for Letter of Administration. Admittedly, the verification accompanying the amended application for Letter of Administration was not verified by the Petitioner or by her learned Counsel. By the impugned order dated 28.04.2009 this application was dismissed by the learned Court below on the ground that it did not satisfy the requirement of verification as obligated by Section 280 of the Act.
4. Mr. Mahanta has persuasively argued that the requirement of verification as comprehended under Section 280 of the Act is not mandatory but directory in nature and that therefore, on that count alone the impugned order is liable to be set aside. According to him, as the petition for probate had been duly verified by the Petitioner, it was not imperatively essential for her to sign the verification of the application for Letter of Administration anew. He has sought to endorse this plea by contending that as meanwhile the evidence in the proceedings has been recorded and that the same was pending at the stage of arguments, the rejection of the application for Letter of Administration was visibly illegal and unsustainable in law. The learned Senior Counsel has argued without prejudice to the above that even assuming that the requirement of signing of the verification of the application for Letter of Administration was imperative, the learned Court below ought to have treated such omission to be a curable and permitted the Petitioner to sign the same at a later point of time. Mr. Mahanta has insisted that as the signing of the verification of pleadings is a procedural requirement, the learned Court below was apparently in error in adopting a rigid outlook therefore and in dismissing the application for Letter of Administration on that count. In support of his contention the learned Senior Counsel has placed reliance on the decisions in Kailash Singh v. Hiralal Dey AIR 1994 Gau 12 Nand Kishore Raj and Anr