1993 Supreme(Gau) 82
GAUHATI HIGH COURT
S. N. PHUKAN, J.
Kailash Singh -Appellant
Versus
Hiralal Dey -Respondent
Civil Revn. No. 17 of 1987
Decided On : 31-03-1993
Important Points
Subject
Landlord and Tenant - RENT CONTROL
Act Referred
CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.6 R.14, O.6 R.15, S.115, S.99
Headnote
LANDLORD AND TENANT - RENT CONTROL - DEFAULT - BONA FIDE REQUIREMENT - INTERPRETATION OF SECTION 5(1)(A) OF THE ASSAM URBAN AREAS RENT CONTROL ACT, 1972 - DUE DATE FOR PAYMENT OF RENT - JURISDICTIONAL ERROR - REVISION PETITION - SCOPE OF INTERFERENCE.
Fact of the Case:
The tenant, who was a monthly tenant, failed to pay rent from April 1979 onwards. The landlord issued a notice of ejectment on 27-12-79, demanding arrears of rent and terminating the tenancy with effect from 1-2-80. The tenant contested the suit, denying that he was a defaulter and that the suit premises was required by the landlord for his own use and occupation.
Finding of the Court:
The trial court and the lower appellate court held that the tenant was a defaulter and that the landlord had a bona fide requirement for the suit premises. The tenant filed a revision petition in the High Court.
Issues: 1. Whether the tenant was a defaulter within the meaning of Section 5(1)(a) of the Assam Urban Areas Rent Control Act, 1972? 2. Whether the landlord had a bona fide requirement for the suit premises?
Ratio Decidendi: 1. The court held that the tenant was a defaulter as he failed to pay rent within 15 days from the date of demand by the landlord, as required by Section 5(1)(a) of the Assam Urban Areas Rent Control Act, 1972. 2. The court held that the landlord did not have a bona fide requirement for the suit premises as he failed to adduce sufficient evidence to show that he genuinely required the accommodation for his own use and occupation.
Final Decision: The court dismissed the revision petition and upheld the impugned judgment and decree.
T. C. Khatri and K. K. Bhatra, J. N. Sarka and R. C. Shamchetri
This revision petition under S. 115 read with S. 151, CPC is by the tenant against the judgment and decree dated 9-12-86 of the first appellate court viz. Asstt. District Judge, Tezpur in Title Appeal No. 14 of 1983 dismissing the appeal by the present petitioner and up-holding the decree for ejectment passed by the learned Munsiff No. 2 Tezpur in Title Suit No. 9 of 1980.
2. There is no dispute that the present petitioner-defendant was a monthly tenant in respect of the suit premises at a monthly rent of Rs. 50/- plus Rs. 5/- per month as electric charge and the tenancy was according to English Calendar month. Plaintiff has alleged that the monthly rent of Rs. 55/- was payable on the 1st day of each following month according to English Calendar month. Plaintiff started a shop in the suit premises. According to plaintiff after April, 1979, the defendant did not pay any rent and became a defaulter. It has also been pleaded that the suit room is required by the plaintiff for his own use and occupation. Thereafter a notice of ejectment dated 27-12-79 was issued by the plaintiff on the defendant asking him to quit and vacate with effect from 1-2-80. The claim for arrears of rent due till the month of January, 1980 was put forward in the notice and the relationship of the landlord and tenant with effect from l.-2-80 was terminated. As the suit premises was not vacated the present suit was filed praying for a decree for ejectment of the defendant and also for recovery of rents amounting to Rs. 450/- from May, 1979 to January, 1980. Plaintiff has also claimed Rs. 100/- as mesne profits from 1-2-1980 to 20-2-1980 and future mesne profits @ Rs. 5/- per day.
3. The suit was contested by the defendant by filing a written statement. According to defendant the rent was payable after it became due and/or being demanded from the defendant by the plaintiff or his agent or representative and accordingly he used to pay rent whenever such a demand was made. In view of this procedure for payment of rent, there used to be accumulation of rent for several months and defendants used to pay whenever demanded was made by the plaintiff or his agent. It has been denied that there was any agreement that the rent was payable per month as alleged by the plaintiff. Accordingly defendant has denied that he was a defaulter. It has also been denied that the suit house was required by the plaintiff for his own use and occupation or by the members of his family and there was no bona fide requirement. In the written statement, it has been stated that there was pressure on the defendant to vacate the suit premises and as a result, the plaintiff illegally and wrongfully disconnected electricity with effect from June, 1977. In para 3 of the written statement a specific plea has been taken that the plaint was not signed and verified according to law and without correct particulars of the suit premises.
4. The learned trial court on pleadings framed the following issues viz :-
1) Whether there is cause of action ?
2) Whether the plaint has been signed and verified according to law ?
3) Whether the suit is bad for waiver, estoppel and acquiescence ?
4) Whether the defendant is defaulter as alleged by the plaintiff ?
5) Whether the suit premises is required by the plaintiff ?
6) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree as prayed for ?
7) Whether the plaintiffs suit is false and vexatious and defendant is entitled to get compensation under Section 35A of C.P.C. as prayed by him ?
8) To what other relief or reliefs the parties are entitled ?
5. I have heard Mr. Khetri, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. Sarma learned counsel for the opposite party.
6. Mr. Khetri has urged before this court four issues viz issue Nos. 2, 3, 4 and 5.
7. Let me first take up the issue No. 2 i.e. whether the plaint was signed and verified according to law. In this connection learned counsel has drawn my attention to the relevant portion of the judgment of the learned lower appellate C