SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1987 Supreme(Gau) 21

GAUHATI HIGH COURT
MANISANA, J.
Ala Uddin -Appellant
Versus
Sishir Kumar Dutta -Respondent
Civil Revn. No. 21 of 1982
Decided On : 23-04-1987

Important Points

The court's comparison of signatures or handwriting is a mode of ascertaining the truth, but the court does not play the role of an expert, and its opinion is not conclusive. Therefore, the court should be slow to base its findings solely on the comparison made by itself, especially when it is not made by one conversant with the subject.

Subject

Civil Law - Evidence

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : S.34
EVIDENCE ACT : S.45, S.47, S.73
INTEREST ACT : S.1

Headnote

COMPARISON OF SIGNATURE - EVIDENCE ACT - SECTION 45, 47, 73 - INTEREST ACT - SECTION 1 - INTEREST ACT, 1839 - SECTION 1 - INTEREST - AWARD OF INTEREST - CONDITIONS - COURT'S COMPARISON OF SIGNATURE - OPINION OF EXPERT - OPINION OF WITNESS - COURT'S OWN OBSERVATION - PRUDENCE AND CAUTION - INTEREST ACT, 1978 - SECTION 1 - ENFORCEMENT - APPLICABILITY OF INTEREST ACT, 1839 - AGREEMENT, USAGE OF TRADE, STATUTORY PROVISION - NOTICE OF DEMAND - RELEVANCY OF OPINION - CONCLUSIVENESS OF OPINION - COMPARISON OF SIGNATURE OR HANDWRITING - MODE OF ASCERTAINING TRUTH - COURT'S ROLE - RISK OF ERROR - DECISIVE WEIGHT OR INFLUENCE.

Fact of the Case:

Plaintiff filed a suit for recovery of a loan amount of Rs. 1,800/- borrowed by the defendant on 26-5-75, along with interest at the rate of 6.25% per annum from 26-5-75 to 11-5-78, totaling Rs. 332.81. The suit was instituted on 12-5-78. The trial court decreed the claim, and the appellate court affirmed the decree. The defendant challenged the findings of the courts below, arguing that the courts should have sent the disputed document for expert opinion instead of relying solely on their own comparison of signatures.

Finding of the Court:

The court held that the courts below did not err in relying on their own comparison of signatures, as there is no legal bar to the judge using their own eyes to compare the disputed writing with the admitted writing under Section 73 of the Evidence Act. However, the court cautioned that the court should be slow to base its findings solely on the comparison made by itself, as the opinion formed by the court is not conclusive and is liable to error, especially when it is not made by one conversant with the subject. The court also held that the plaintiff was not entitled to interest under the Interest Act, 1978, as the suit was instituted before the enforcement of the act, and the Interest Act, 1839, which was applicable to the case, did not provide for the award of interest in the absence of an agreement, usage of trade, statutory provision, or notice of demand.

Issues: 1. Whether the courts below erred in relying solely on their own comparison of signatures without sending the disputed document for expert opinion? 2. Whether the plaintiff was entitled to interest under the Interest Act, 1978?

Ratio Decidendi: 1. The court held that the courts below did not err in relying solely on their own comparison of signatures, as there is no legal bar to the judge using their own eyes to compare the disputed writing with the admitted writing under Section 73 of the Evidence Act. However, the court cautioned that the court should be slow to base its findings solely on the comparison made by itself, as the opinion formed by the court is not conclusive and is liable to error, especially when it is not made by one conversant with the subject. 2. The court held that the plaintiff was not entitled to interest under the Interest Act, 1978, as the suit was instituted before the enforcement of the act, and the Interest Act, 1839, which was applicable to the case, did not provide for the award of interest in the absence of an agreement, usage of trade, statutory provision, or notice of demand.

Final Decision: The court partly allowed the petition, setting aside the award of interest by the courts below and reducing the decretal amount by Rs. 332.81. The plaintiff was entitled to Rs. 1,800/- only with costs awarded by the courts below.

Advocates Appeared:
M. A. Laskar and B. L Singh

Judgement

ORDER:- This revision petition arises from the judgment and decree passed by the learned Assistant District Judge Karimganj in Money Appeal No. 40 of 1979 dismissing the appeal and affirming the judgment and decree passed by the learned Munsiff Karimganj in Money Suit No. 43 of 1978 decreeing the claim of the plaintiff for recovery of a sum of Rs. 2,132.81 with costs; hence this petition.

2. The plaintiff-opposite party brought the suit on the footing that on 26-5-75, the defendant-petitioner borrowed a sum of Rs. 1,800/- by executing a document (Ex.-1) promising to repay the amount on demand but in spite of repeated demands, the defendant failed to re-pay the same. Out of Rs. 2,132.81 claimed by the plaintiff, Rs. 1,800/- was principal amount and Rs. 332.81 was the interest at the rate of 6.25% per annum from 26-5-75 to 11-5-78. The suit was instituted on 12-5-78.

3. Mr. M.A. Laskar, the learned counsel for the petitioner, has submitted that the learned Munsiff compared the disputed signature of the defendant on the document (Ext.-1) with the admitted signatures of the defendant on his written-statement and also on the Vakalatnama executed by him, and based his findings on the comparison made by himself. Mr. Laskar has contended that the Court should not have given its findings solely on such comparison made by itself, and that the Courts below ought to have sent the document (Ext.-1) to the expert.

4. In the Evidence Act, for proving handwriting the opinion of expert and of persons acquainted with the handwritings of the persons concerned have been made relevant under S.45 and S.47 respectively. Both under S.45 and S.47, the evidence is an opinion, in the former by a scientific comparison and in the latter on the basis of familiarity resulting from the frequent observations and experience. However, the opinion of handwriting expert is not conclusive. The opinion of an expert is fallible or liable to error like any other witness. Still it cannot be brushed aside as useless.

5. With regard to comparison of signature and writing by the Court there is no legal bar to the Judge using his own eyes to compare the disputed writing with the admitted writing under S.73 of the Evidence Act, that is, the Court can apply its own observation to the admitted or proved handwritings and compare them with the disputed one. But by doing so the Court does not become a handwriting expert. Although a comparison of signature or handwriting is a mode of ascertaining the truth, the Court does not play the role of an expert. The opinion of the Court is also not conclusive. Therefore, to base findings solely on the comparison of signatures or handwritings, the Court is taking the risk of doing so, as the opinion formed by the Court is not conclusive and is liable to error, and especially when it is not made by one not conversant with the subject. Therefore, the Court as a matter of prudence and caution should hesitate or be slow to base its findings solely on the comparison made by himself. However, if there is an opinion whether of the expert or any witness, the Court may apply its own observation by comparing the signatures or handwritings for giving a decisive weight or influence.

6. I have perused the findings of the Courts below. The findings of the learned Munsiff are based on the evidence of the scribe of PW 2 and the plaintiff (P.W. 1 ), and not solely on the comparison of signatures. The learned Munsiff made a comparison of the signatures for satisfying itself that it was safe to accept the evidence of PWS. 1 and 2. I have also perused the evidence on records for my own satisfaction. The findings of the Courts below are supported by the evidence and materials on record. It is not a case where the Courts below have exercised their jurisdiction illegally or with material irregularity. Therefore, any of the provisions under S.115, CPC is not attracted.

7. Mr. Laskar has further submitted that the plaintiff was not entitled to interest unde












1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top