2020 Supreme(Gau) 778
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GAUHATI
Soumitra Saikia, J.
Julfikar Ali (Md.) - Appellants
Vs.
Sajia Begum and Ors.- Respondent
CRP No. 519 of 2015
Decided On : 10-02-2020
Subject
Civil Law - Additional Evidence
Act Referred
Headnote
Civil Procedure Code, 1908 - Section 151 - Order 41 - Rule 27 - Sale deed - Recovery of possession - Permanent injunction - Plaintiff instituted a Title Suit No. for declaration, cancellation of sale deed, recovery of possession and for permanent injunction - Suit was contested by defendant/respondents by filing their written statements - Learned Civil Judge vide Judgment & Order dated dismissed suit of plaintiff - Being aggrieved plaintiff/petitioner preferred an appeal being Title Appeal No. before the Learned Additional District Judge No. 3 - Appeal was admitted and Lower Court Records called for - Petitioner contends that rejection of application is contrary to provisions of law inasmuch as under provisions of Code of Civil Procedure application seeking permission to bring on additional evidence on oral or documentary ought to have been taken up at final hearing of appeal - Whether to look into documents sought to be brought in as additional evidence – Held, Appellate Court below justified its order of rejecting application filed by petitioner/appellant, it erred in considering matter, seeking to bring in additional evidence, well before final hearing of matter while fixing matter for arguments at a much later date - As such, in view of law laid down by Hon'ble Supreme Court it will be just and proper and in interest of appropriate adjudication of matter that order dated - Impugned order dated passed in Application No. in Title Appeal No. by Learned Additional District Judge No. 3 Kamrup (M) is hereby set aside and matter is remanded back to learned Appellate Court below to re-hear and re-decide application seeking to bring additional evidence by petitioner/appellant at time of final hearing of matter after hearing all parties to list - Revision Petition is, accordingly, disposed of
For the Appellant :T.K. Bhuyan, S. Sarma, S.K. Deka and A. Kashyap, Advocates
For the Respondents:S. Dutta, Advocate
ORDER :
Soumitra Saikia, J.
1. Mr. S. Sarma, learned counsel assisted by Mr. S.K. Deka and Mr. A. Kashyap, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. S. Dutta, learned counsel for the respondent No. 1. None appears for the legal heirs of erstwhile respondent No. 2 although service of notice is complete on them, when the matter is being called.
2. The revision petitioner has preferred the present petition impugning the order dated 07.10.2015 passed in Application No. 1014/2015 in Title Appeal No. 6/2012 by the Court of the Additional District Judge No. 3, Kamrup (M), Guwahati.
3. The present petitioner as the plaintiff instituted a Title Suit No. 225/2007 for declaration, cancellation of sale deed, recovery of possession and for permanent injunction. The suit was contested by the defendant/respondents by filing their written statements. The learned Civil Judge vide Judgment & Order dated 28.5.2012 dismissed the suit of the plaintiff. Being aggrieved the plaintiff/petitioner preferred an appeal being Title Appeal No. 6/2012 before the Learned Additional District Judge No. 3, Kamrup. The appeal was admitted and the Lower Court Records called for.
4. The petitioner/appellant, before the hearing commenced in the Title Appeal, by an application being Application No. 1014/2015 under Order 41 Rule 27 read with Section 151 CPC filed before the Hon'ble Court sought liberty to bring on record additional evidence as the same was stated to have an important bearing in the matter and was required for proper adjudication of the Title Appeal No. 6/2012. The learned First Appellate Court below after hearing the parties rejected the petition by the impugned order dated 7.10.2015 and fixed the matter for arguments on 7.12.2015.
5. The petitioner has assailed the impugned order on the ground that the same is in violation of the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure as well as the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in a series of judgments. The petitioner contends that the rejection of the application is contrary to the provisions of law inasmuch as under the provisions of Code of Civil Procedure the application seeking permission to bring on additional evidence on oral or documentary ought to have been taken up at the final hearing of the appeal, however by this particular order which is impugned, the learned Court below rejected the application while fixing the matter for arguments on 07.12.2015. As such, the petitioner submits that it is apparent that the application for bringing on additional evidence which ought to have been taken up for final hearing, the petition has been rejected prematurely and the matter has not been considered as per law. The petitioner in support of his contention places reliance on the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Union of India Vs. Ibrahim Uddin & Anr., reported in (2012) 8 SCC 148. The petitioner relies on the said judgment in support of his contention that an application for bringing additional evidence on record at the appellate stage is to be heard at the time of final hearing in the appeal. Para 52 of the Judgment is extracted for reference is as under:-
"Thus, from, the above, it is crystal clear that an application for taking additional evidence on record at an appellate stage, even if filed during the pendency of the appeal, is to be heard at the time of final hearing of the appeal at a stage when after appreciating the evidence on record, the court reaches the conclusion that additional evidence was required to be taken on record in order to pronounce the judgment or for any other substantial cause. In case, the application for taking additional evidence on record has been considered and allowed prior to the hearing of the appeal, the order being a product of total and complete non-application of mind, as to whether such evidence is required to be taken on record to pronounce the judgment or not, remains inconsequential/inexecutable and is liable to be ignored."