SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2006 Supreme(Raj) 961

High Court Of Rajasthan
Judgename : Prem Shanker Asopa
Prem Singh - Appellant
Versus
Savitri Devi - Respondent
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 7682 of 2004
Decided On : 04/07/2006

Important Points

Legal representatives cannot take a hostile stand to that of the deceased-defendant and cannot assert their individual right or hostile title to the suit.

Subject

Civil Law - Civil Procedure

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.22, O.4(2)
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : Art.227

Headnote

Amendment - Civil Suit - Order XXII Rule 4 - [Order XXII Rule 4] - The court discussed the legal provisions of Order XXII Rule 4 of the Civil Procedure Code, which allows legal representatives to make any defense appropriate to their character as legal representatives of the deceased defendant. The court referred to previous judgments to establish that legal representatives cannot take a hostile stand to that of the deceased-defendant and cannot assert their individual right or hostile title to the suit. The court also cited a Supreme Court judgment to support the position that legal representatives cannot raise pleas which were personal to the deceased. The court concluded that the trial court's decision to not take on record the written statement and counter claim filed by the legal representatives of the deceased was valid and did not call for any interference under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

Fact of the Case:

The civil suit for partition and possession was filed by Plaintiff -respondent No. 1 against Madan Singh, Prem Singh & others. Deceased Prem Singh in his written statement admitted 1/5th share of the plaintiff in the property but the legal representatives of the deceased have filed counter claim seeking partition of the property. Defendant No. 1 Madan Singh objected to taking on record the subsequent written statement and counter claim filed by the legal representatives of deceased Prem Singh.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the trial court's decision to not take on record the written statement and counter claim filed by the legal representatives of the deceased was valid and did not call for any interference under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

Issues: The main issue was whether the legal representatives of the deceased could file a counter claim seeking partition of the property after the deceased had previously sought a similar amendment, which was rejected.

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that legal representatives cannot take a hostile stand to that of the deceased-defendant and cannot assert their individual right or hostile title to the suit. They cannot raise pleas which were personal to the deceased. The trial court's decision to not take on record the written statement and counter claim filed by the legal representatives of the deceased was valid.

Final Decision: The writ petition was dismissed with no order as to costs.

Advocates Appeared:
Mr. J.P. Goyal, for the Petitioners.
Mr. G.P. Kaushik, for the Respondents.

Judgment

Prem Shanker Asopa, J.-The instant writ petition is directed against the order dated 010.2004

passed by the Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Dholpur whereby the written statement dated 26.05.2004 alongwith counter claim filed by legal Representatives Nos. 2/1 to 2/5 of Deceased-defendant No. 2 Prem Singh has not been taken on record on the objection of Defendant No. 1 Madan Singh that the written statement has been filed by deceased Prem Singh wherein the amendment of similar counter claim was rejected on 25.01.2001, therefore, the legal representatives are bound by the same and they have no individual right to take inconsistent pleas by re-agitating the same.

2. Briefly stated the relevant facts of the case are that Plaintiff -respondent No. 1 filed a civil suit for partition and possession against Madan Singh, Prem Singh and others. On the death of Prem Singh, amended suit was filed by the plaintiff and the present petitioners were also brought on record as legal representatives of deceased Prem Singh.

3. A bare perusal of the contents of the writ petition would reveal that the civil suit for partition and possession was filed by Plaintiff -respondent No. 1 Smt. Savitri Devi D/o late Shri Dilvar Singh Thakur, W/o Ratan Singh Negi against Madan Singh, Prem Singh & others. claiming possession of 1/5th share in the property. Deceased Prem Singh in his written statement admitted 1/5th share of the plaintiff in the property but the legal representatives of the deceased have filed counter claim seeking partition of the property.

4. Defendant No. 1 Madan Singh raised an objection for taking on record the subsequent written statement filed by the legal representatives of deceased Prem Singh alongwith the counter claim on the ground that there was counter claim sought to be made by way of amendment by deceased Prem Singh was rejected and now the legal representatives cannot be allowed to raise inconsistent plea.

5. The trial Court after hearing both the parties, accepted the objection raised by Defendant No. 2 Madan Singh and has not taken on record the written statement dated 26.05.2004 and counter claim filed by Defendant Nos. 2/1 to 2/5 on the ground that earlier the application for amendment of the written statement similar to the counter claim filed by Prem Singh was rejected on 25.01.2001 and upheld by this Court on 22.02.2002 in revision, which is valid. Therefore, the legal representatives of deceased Prem Singh cannot re-agitate the issue.

6. The submission of the Counsel for the petitioners is that the heirs and legal representatives of the deceased under Sub-rule (2) of Rule 4 of Order XXII CPC in a case of suit for partition are entitled to make defence appropriate to their character and claim independent right. He further submits that it is true that legal representatives are bound by the plea raised by their predecessor in title and are further entitled to raise contrary plea but not inconsistent plea already raised by him. In support of his submissions, the Counsel for the petitioners placed reliance on the Judgment s in Smt. Shyama Devi & Ors. vs. Smt. Manju Shukhla & Ors., 1991 (1) RLR 351, Para Nos. 37 to 39, 41 and 42 and Nasiruddin & Ors. vs. Smt. Noor Jahan & Ors., 1990 (2) RLR 234.

7. The Counsel for the respondents has submitted that this Court has on another occasion while examining the scope of the said sub-rule in the case of Dayali (Smt.) & Ors. vs. Kumari Lata & Ors., 2003 (2) DNJ (Raj.) 568 and has held that it is not open for legal representative of deceased to assert their individual right or hostile title to the suit. All the legal representative can do is to take up the suit at the stage at which it was left when the original defendant died and to continue it. They cannot take up a plea contrary to the one taken up by the deceased-defendant. Here in the instant case, deceased Prem Singh himself filed an application for amendment of the written statement for inserting counter claim which was reject

























1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top