SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2005 Supreme(Raj) 1995

High Court Of Rajasthan
Judgename : Prakash Tatia
Kamla Devi - Appellant
Versus
Nandlal - Respondent
S.B. Civil Regular Second Appeal No. 350 of 2004
Decided On : 08/30/2005

Important Points

The judgment emphasizes the tenant's obligation to comply with rent payment procedures under the Act, even in the face of the landlord's refusal to accept rent, and highlights the limited jurisdiction of the court in rent deposit proceedings under Section 19-A.

Subject

Eviction - Rent Default and Eviction Proceedings

Act Referred

RAJASTHAN PREMISES CONTROL OF RENT AND EVICTION ACT : S.13, S.19(a)

Headnote

Eviction - Default in Payment of Rent - Rajasthan Premises (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1950 - Section 13(3), Section 19-A - Benefit of avoiding eviction decree - Court's interpretation of tenant's obligations and landlord's refusal to accept rent

Fact of the Case:

The plaintiff-landlord filed a suit for eviction against the tenant-deceased Madanlal, citing default in payment of rent. The trial court determined arrears of rent under Section 13(3) of the Act and directed the tenant to pay or deposit the arrears and monthly rent. The tenant complied, but the suit resulted in a declaration of default without eviction. The landlord filed another suit for eviction of the tenant's legal representatives, claiming a second default in rent payment.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the tenant failed to comply with the procedures under Section 19-A for depositing rent, and the landlord's refusal to accept rent did not absolve the tenant of their obligation to pay. The court dismissed the appeal, upholding the eviction decree.

Issues: The issues revolved around the tenant's compliance with rent payment procedures, the landlord's refusal to accept rent, and the tenant's readiness and willingness to pay rent.

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the tenant's failure to follow the procedures for depositing rent under Section 19-A, despite the landlord's refusal to accept rent, constituted willful default. The court emphasized the tenant's obligation to pay rent and the limited jurisdiction of the court in proceedings under Section 19-A.

Final Decision: The appeal was dismissed, and the court allowed the appellants to occupy the premises for a limited time, subject to conditions for vacating the premises and paying arrears of rent.

Advocates Appeared:
Mr. M.C. Bhoot, for the Appellants.
Mr. S.C. Maloo, for the Respondent.

Judgment

Prakash Tatia, J.-Heard learned Counsel for the parties.

2. Brief facts of the case are that the plaintiff-landlord earlier filed a suit for eviction against their tenant-deceased Madanlal, which was registered as Civil Original Suit No. 26/1989. In that suit ground for eviction was default in payment of rent by the tenant. In the above suit No. 26/1989, the trial Court determined the arrears of rent under Section 13(3) of the Rajasthan Premises (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1950 and directed defendant-tenant to pay or deposit the arrears of rent and monthly rent month by month during trial of the suit. The defendant complied with the Courts order and paid the rent of the suit premises in the suit No. 26/1989. Ultimately, the suit No. 26/1989 of the plaintiff was decided by the Judgment and decree dated 16.02.1991 and the Court declared the tenant-defendant defaulter in payment of rent, but no decree for eviction was passed against the tenant on the ground of default in payment of rent by the tenant as, as per law in the case of first default in payment of rent, if tenant deposits arrears of rent and pays rent during trial within period provided for that then tenant is entitled for benefit once, of avoiding eviction decree against him.

3. The landlord thereafter, filed another suit for eviction of the legal representatives of tenant as tenant Madanlal died. In the present suit, apart from other grounds one of the ground was that the defendants have committed default in payment of rent second time and now no opportunity is available to the tenants under the provisions of Rajasthan Premises (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1950 for taking further benefit by deposit of arrears of rent to avoid the decree on the ground of default, therefore, the plaintiff is entitled for the decree for eviction of the tenant on this sole ground of default. The suit of the plaintiffs was decreed vide Judgment and decree dated 23rd September, 1996 by the trial Court on the ground of second default in payment of rent by the tenant. The defendants, legal representatives of original tenant preferred appeal, which too was dismissed by the appellate Court vide Judgment and decree dated 24th August, 2004, hence, this second appeal.

4. According to learned Counsel for the appellant in earlier suit rent was determined and the deceased tenant Madanlal paid the rent and took the benefit of first default under the provisions of the Act, 1950. Thereafter, after the decision of earlier suit No. 26/1989, he sent rent by money order to the landlord on 30.04.1991, but the landlord refused to accept the rent and, therefore, the said money order was returned to Madanlal. Madanlal, thereafter, died on 2nd August, 1991. After the death of Madanlal, Madan Lals wife appellant Smt. Kamladevi served a notice upon the landlord through her advocate on 4th September, 1991 demanding bank account particular of the plaintiff so she can deposit the rent in plaintiff s bank account. That notice was received by the landlords, but the landlords did not disclose the particulars of their bank account and, therefore, the appellants-tenants could not deposit the rent in the bank account of the landlord. Ultimately, on 28th September, 1991 the tenants submitted application in Court under Section 19-A of the Act of 1950 seeking permission of Court to pay the rent to the landlord through Court. In the proceedings under Section 19-A of the Act of 1950, the Court ordered on 16th May, 1992 permitting the appellant to deposit the rent in the Court, upon which the tenants deposited the rent in the Court. According to learned Counsel for the appellant, the landlords in proceedings under Section 19-A of the Act of 1950 even refused to recognize the appellant as tenant.

5. Before Courts order permitting appellants-tenants to deposit the rent in Court dated 16th May, 1992 the present plaintiffs filed present suit for eviction on 15th May, 1992 seeking eviction of the tenants on th













1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top