D.M.BHANDARI, B.P.BERI
Pukhraj – Appellant
Versus
Ummaidram – Respondent
2. Thecomplainant Pukhraj had filed a complaint against Ummaidram and six others alleging that they had
demolished the chabutri and the latrine over it on 12th of February 1958 between 9 and 10 A.M. and that the
chabutri was on the land belonging to the complainant and the demolition of the chabutri and latrine had
caused to the complainant the loss of Rs. 3 00/-. The complaint was for prosecuting the accused under
Sections 451,. 427 and 147, IPC. Ummaidram accused, took the plea that he was acting as Sarpanch of the
Gram Panchayat, Bilara, and he had directed the removal of the encroachment in that capacity in good faith.
The trial magistrate discharged the accused. In his opinion no prima facie case was made out as Ummaidram
acting as Sarpanch was discharging his duty as Sarpanch in widening the street. The learned magistrate
further held that in view of Section 79 of the Rajasthan Pan
No cases in the provided list are identified as overruled, reversed, or explicitly treated as bad law. The case law listed discusses the application of Article 311 of the Constitution but does not include any indications of subsequent judicial treatment that would classify it as overruled or invalid.
[Followed]
None: The list does not specify that this case has been followed by subsequent decisions.
[Distinguished]
None: There is no mention of the case being distinguished in later rulings.
[Criticized or Questioned]
None: The case law does not contain language indicating criticism or questioning by later courts.
[Legal Treatment]
The case appears to be a foundational or interpretative decision regarding the scope of Article 311, but without further context or subsequent treatment, it remains a standalone reference.
None: The treatment of the case law is clear and unambiguous based on the provided information. There are no indications of uncertainty or ambiguous judicial treatment.
**Source :** Satish Chandra Anand VS Union Of India - Supreme Court PARSHOTAM LAL DHINGRA VS UNION OF INDIA - Madhya Pradesh Bhagwatilal VS Bhanwarlal - Rajasthan
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.