SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2011 Supreme(Raj) 2234

RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT AT JAIPUR BENCH
Mohammad Rafiq, J.
Kamalwati Gupta - Appellant
Versus
Kanwari Lal Jain - Respondent
S.B. Civil Second Appeal No. 552 of 2009.
Decided On : 21-07-2011

Subject

Legal Procedure - Legal Representation

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.22 R.3, O.22 R.2(11), S.100
RAJASTHAN PREMISES CONTROL OF RENT AND EVICTION ACT : S.3(iii), S.2(c)
SUCCESSION ACT : S.211

Headnote

Rajasthan Premises (Control of Rent and Eviction) Act, 1950 – S. 3(iii) and 2(c) – Civil Procedure Code, 1908, Order 22 Rules 3 and 2(11) – S. 100 – Indian Succession Act, 1925 – During the pendency of appeal the appellant died – To implead partnership from application under Order 22 Rule 3 in which two sons was partner – In a wall appellant let out the despoiled shop in favour of him – Defendant raised objection that legal representation of deceased can come on record.

Advocates:
For the Appellant: G.P. Sharma, Counsel.
For the Respondent:R.K. Agarwal, Senior Advocate with Alok Chaturvedi, Counsel.

JUDGMENT

1. - This second appeal was originally filed by plaintiff Smt. Kamalwati Gupta, who was landlord of the respondent, against judgment and decree passed by learned Additional District judge No.2, Jaipur City, Jaipur, reversing the judgment and decree of the Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), whereby the suit for eviction filed by plaintiff-appellant was decreed on the ground of personal bona-fide necessity. During the pendency of appeal, the sole appellant died on 01.05.2010. An application under Order 22, Rule 3 of the CPC was moved by her counsel for impleadment of partnership firm M/s. Hotel Sweet Dream, of which the appellant was a partner with 33% share with her two sons as shareholders of half each of the remaining. The appellant executed a will on 12.02.2003 bequeathing the disputed shop, let out to defendant-respondent, in favour of the firm M/s Hotel Sweet Dream. The application was therefore made for substitution of original appellant by the said firm. Application was opposed by defendant-respondent and this court by order dated 27.01.2011, as per consent given by the parties, disposed of the application allowing said firm to argue the appeal on behalf of appellant, subject to legal objections to be raised by respondent including that the said firm is not legal representative of the decreased appellant. When the appeal was taken up for admission, an objection was raised by the counsel appearing for defendant-respondent as to maintainability of the appeal by said firm contending that it cannot be considered a legal representative of deceased-appellant.

2. The Supreme Court in Jalai Suguna (deceased) through L.Rs. v. Satya Sai Central Trust and Others , (2008) 8 SCC 521 , held that when an application for bringing on record legal representatives of deceased is filed, the court should consider and decide such question first and until such decision, the persons claiming to be legal representatives have no right to represent the estate of the deceased nor prosecute or defend the case. Decision of this objection has thus become necessary before the matter is taken up for arguments on admission in view of Jalai Suguna, supra, wherein the Supreme Court held that the court cannot postpone the decision of such question for being decided along with the appeal on merits, for that would leave the estate of the deceased unrepresented which, as held in that case, would amount to hearing of an appeal against a dead person, which was clearly impermissible in law and the judgment rendered therein was held to be nullity and inoperative. It is therefore that the matter has been heard on such objection.

3. Shri R.K. Agarwal, learned Senior Advocate, appearing on behalf of the defendant-respondent, argued that appellant has died leaving behind a will executed by her, wherein no one has been nominated as executor, therefore, even if there is no necessity of obtaining probate in the State of Rajasthan according to Section 211 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, (for short, 'the Act of 1925'), letters of administration under Section 213, has to be necessarily obtained. It was argued that had the appellant died intestate, the property would have devolved upon her legal heirs as per the personal law i.e. Hindu Succession Act and in that event, possibly they could straightaway substitute the original appellant Smt. Kamalwati to prosecute the present appeal, to which course the defendant-respondent is not having any objection even now. However, if they want the firm to substitute the deceased-appellant as appellant on the strength of will, this can be done only within the four-corners of law according to provisions contained in the Indian Succession Act, 1925. On this point, Shri R.K. Agarwal, learned Senior Advocate, relied on a decision of the Supreme Court in FGP Limited v. Saleh Hooseini Doctor and another, (2009) 10 SCC 223 , and argued that the Supreme Court in that case has drawn a fine distinction between Sections 211 and 2
























1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top