Vineet Kothari, J.

This unfortunate fight between the two real brothers has been brought up before this Court by the appellant/plaintiff, Inder Singh S/o late Sh. Loonsingh Rajpurohit, against his younger brother, namely, Bheem Singh S/o late Sh. Loonsingh, in respect of suit property, a plot of land ad-measuring 21' x 54', situated in Village-Dhariya, Tehsil-Desuri, upon which the appellant/plaintiff constructed two rooms, one Hall, Chowk, Kitchen, store, bathroom, varanda, etc. after seeking requisite permission from the concerned Gram Panchayat.

2. The appellant/plaintiff, Inder Singh, was in service of Jodhpur Central Cooperative Bank, and undisputedly, the Patta No. 49/77 dated 19.06.1980 (Exhibit-2) was issued in respect of said plot of land by the concerned Gram Panchayat-Dhariya, in the name of plaintiff, Inder Singh. Since, the plaintiff/appellant was serving at Jodhpur, he gave permissive possession of the part of the said house to his younger brother, Bheem Singh, on 01.08.1996 for a period of two years. The father of the parties, late Sh. Loon Singh, expired on 27.03.2002 but before his death, he executed a Will on 17.12.1989 (Exhibit-1) in favour of his three sons, viz. two being parties to the present suit and other one Sh. Dalpat Singh. However, said brother, Dalpat Singh, having no lis in the present case, was not a party to the present suit, which was filed by the appellant/plaintiff for seeking possession of the suit house in question from the defendant, Bheem Singh and the mesne profits.

3. The learned trial court, however, vide the impugned judgment and decree dated 01.05.2003 rejected the suit filed by the plaintiff basically on two grounds, namely, that the plaintiff has failed to prove the Will (Exhibit-11) dated 17.12.1989 of the father, late Sh. Loon Singh, and also that the neighbourhood of the Patta (Exhibit-2) dated 19.06.1980 and as given in the Will and later on in the Notice revoking the licence of the defendant was different. The relevant portion of the trial court's order is quoted herein below for ready reference: -

fo}ku vf/koDrk oknh dh cgl lquhA i=koyh dk /;kuiwoZd voyksdu fd;k x;kA

oknh bUnjflag ih0MCY;w0 1 us vius l'kiFk dFkuksa esa crk;k gS fd xzke <+kfj;k esa mldk jgoklh edku vk;k gqvk gSA mlds edku ds mRrj esa pSuflag dk edku gS] nf{k.k esa vke jkLrk gS] iwoZ esa y{e.kflag dk edku gS rFkk if'pe esa pSuflag dk edku gSA ;g edku 21 x 54 QhV ds uki ds IyksV ij cuk gqvk gSA edku dk uD'kk ,Xth0 1 gSA ,Xth0 1 uD'kk vCnqy djhc M~k~VeSu ls cuok;k FkkA bl IyksV ij igys mlds firkth us dCtk fd;k FkkA mlds firkth us iV~Vk bl IyksV ij esjs uke ls cuok;k Fkk tks ,Xth0 2 gS] bldh QksVks izfr ,Xth0 2&, gSA iV~Vk cuokdj esjs firkth us iapk;r ls izkIr fd;k Fkk ftlds izkIr gksus dh izekf.kr izfrfyfi ,Xth0 3 gSA bl ij esjs firkth ds , ls ch gLrk{kj gSA bl IyksV ij fuekZ.k dk;Z eSaus djok;k FkkA fuekZ.k dk;Z djokus gsrq xzke iapk;r <+kfj;k ls vuqefr izkIr dh FkhA eSaus esjs fu;ksDrk cSad tks/kiqj lsUV~y dks&vksijsfVo cSad tks/kiqj ls edku fuekZ.k djus gsrq _.k fy;k Fkk rFkk blds vykok esjs Lo;a ds lalk/kuksa ls jde tqVkdj fuekZ.k dk;Z djok;k FkkA edku ds fuekZ.k dk;Z esa 80000@& :i;s ykxr yxh FkhA _.k Lohd`fr vkns'k ,Xth0 4 gSA mlds ckn edku dh ejEer djokus ds fy, Hkh _.k fy;k Fkk ftldk vkns'k ,Xth0 5 gSA eSaus cSad ls tks _.k fy;k Fkk mldk pqdrk Hkqxrku dj fn;k Fkk ftldk uks M;wt izek.k i= ,Xth0 6 gSA bl edku esa fo|qr dusD'ku eSaus esjs uke ls fy;k Fkk ftlds fcy ,Xth0 7 ls 9 gSA esjs firkth yw.kflag dk nsgkUr fnukad 27-03-2002 dks gks x;k gSA esjs firkth us e`R;q ls iwoZ bPNk i= fu"ikfnr fd;k Fkk tks ,Xth0 11 gSA bPNk i= esjs :c: fd;k Fkk ftl ij , ls ch gLrk{kj esjs firkth yw.kflag us esjs le{k fd;s FksA bl ij lh ls Mh lk[k nsohflag us o bZ ls ,Q lk[k iksdjnkl us Mkyh FkhA ,Xth0 11 dks uksVjh ls lR;kfir djok;k FkkA bl bPNk i= ds vuqlkj oknxzLr edku esjs firkth us eq>s olh;r djus dh ?kks"k.kk dh FkhA esjs firkth ds thoudky rd ;g olh;rukek izHkkoh jgk FkkA eSa tks/kiqj esa o"kZ 1971 ls LFkk;h :i ls jg