2019 Supreme(Raj) 972
IN THE HIGH COURT OF RAJASTHAN AT JODHPUR
SANJEEV PRAKASH SHARMA, J.
Madangopal and Ors - Appellant
Versus
Sagar and Ors - Respondent
S.B. Civil Revision Petition No. 216 of 2012
Decided On : 09-08-2019
Subject
Partition - Maintainability of Suit
Act Referred
SUCCESSION ACT : S.6
Headnote
Hindu Succession Act – Section 6 or Section 8 – Petition against order passed by Additional District Judge – Disposal of Plaintiff preferred suit for partition of coparcenary property, which was later amended As per amended plaint, it is stated that defendants and plaintiff are members of Joint Hindu Family and are coparceners – Trial court wrongly held that there are mixed questions of facts and law – Challenged – Held, Issues not pure legal issues, but would depend on factual aspects and evidence which may recorded – Thus said extent order of trial court in deferring matter on said issues cannot be objected to as in all said aspects – Factual aspects have to dealt with, as has been noticed in impugned order relating to issues – Directions issued to trial court to decide issue – Revision Petition partly allowed – (Paras: 15 to 17)
Facts of the case:
Petition against order passed by Additional District Judge – Disposal of Plaintiff preferred suit for partition of coparcenary property, which was later amended As per amended plaint, it is stated that defendants and plaintiff are members of Joint Hindu Family and are coparceners – Trial court wrongly held that there are mixed questions of facts and law, which required to be examined after recording evidence and submitted that all issues were legal issues and were required to be decided first and trial court failed to perform its duty and to follow order passed by this Court in earlier revision petition – Challenged.
Findings of the court:
Issues not pure legal issues, but would depend on factual aspects and evidence which may recorded – Thus said extent order of trial court in deferring matter on said issues cannot be objected to as in all said aspects – Factual aspects have to dealt with, as has been noticed in impugned order relating to issues – Directions issued to trial court to decide issue.
Result: Revision Petition partly allowed
Advocate Appeared:
For the Appellant : S.C. Maloo
For the Respondent: Sajjan Singh and K.N. Prajapat
JUDGMENT :
SANJEEV PRAKASH SHARMA, J.
1. This is second round of litigation by the petitioners in revision preferred before this Court against the order dated 20.10.2012, whereby learned Additional District Judge No. 2, Jodhpur Metropolitan in a civil suit preferred for partition by plaintiff-Sagar alias Bharat Kumar has refused to decide issues No. 5, 10, 11, 12, 13 & 15 as preliminary issues and has held that the same involve questions of fact and law and shall be decided after recording evidence.
2. Brief facts, which require to be noted for disposal of the petition, are that the plaintiff has preferred a suit for partition of a coparcenary property, which was later on amended. As per the amended plaint, it is stated that the defendants No. 1, 2, 3 and 4 and the plaintiff are members of a Joint Hindu Family and are coparceners.
3. It is stated that Late Mal Ji was the ancestor of all the parties, who expired leaving behind two brothers, Mohan Lal and Kanhaiya Lal in 1960. The property of Mal Ji being an inherited property jointly owned was divided by oral partition between Mohan Lal and Kanhaiya Lal on 03.11.1964. The property which came in possession of Mohan Lal and his children is the subject matter of the present suit.
4. Mohan Lal had two sons, Madangopal and Satyanarayan. Plaintiff-Sagar alias Bharat Kumar s/o. Satyanarayan and sons of Madangopal, namely, Lalit Kumar and Mahesh Kumar acquired property rights in the Hindu coparcenary from the date of their birth in the property of their grandfather Mohan Lal. It is stated that after the death of Mal Ji, the shop by the name of "Mal Ji Ghee Wala" was being run jointly by the family as a commercial establishment. On the basis of the coparcenary business, four shops in plot No. 617 at Laxmi Niwas were purchased in the name of Madangopal Ji on 12.07.1966, which was also part of the joint family. On 03.04.1968, another plot No. 618 Jagdamba Bhawan was purchased in the name of Mohanlal Ji by the joint family income, and the construction was done on the said plot from the income of the joint family. On 26.07.1969, plot No. 68 Koks Kutir was purchased in the name of Mohan Lal on 25.06.1991; half portion of plot No. 75 was purchased from Shivgiri for which a written agreement was entered into and a specific performance suit was preferred, which was decreed in favour of Mohan Lal on 05.03.1993.
It was stated that Mohan Lal expired on 20.03.1999 and Madangopal and Satyanarayan were impleaded as legal representatives in the execution application. Other properties were also mentioned in the plaint which were purchased in the name of Mohan Lal, which included a farm house by the name of Bhawani Krishi Farm House at Village Ajeet in the name of Mohan Lal, Madangopal and Satyanarayan. Land bearing khasra No. 62/43 to 49 was purchased by Mohan Lal in Shikargarh admeasuring 7 bighas. 73 bighas 2 biswas of land was purchased in Brahmano ki Jajiwal in the name of Mohan Lal by the joint family. 160 bighas 18 biswas of agricultural land was purchased by the family jointly in the name of Adarsh Ghachiyan Dugdh Utpadak Sahakari Samiti Limited. Half bigha of land was purchased at Jodhpur Chopasani Chokha by the joint family in the name of Mohan Lal, and there were moveable properties, which were also mentioned to be in the name of joint family.
5. With the said averments, demand was raised by the plaintiff for partition. It was also stated that one plot No. 618 which belonged to the joint family was given out in Will by Mohan Lal in favour of Madangopal and that Will was illegal and would have no affect on the coparcenary property of the joint family. Certain other averments were also made in the plaint in relation to the properties.
6. For the purpose of present petition, suffice it to state that a written statement was filed by defendant No. 1 Madangopal and several facts were denied. Defendants No. 2 and 3 adopted the written statement filed by defendant No. 1, but later on filed amended written st